Social Profile: 
✔️Breakfast ✔️Lunch ✔️Take out
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 94 New York Ave, Huntington, NY 11743
Phone: (631) 421-4250
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Related Web Results
Order Bay Delicatessen – Menu & Prices – Huntington Delivery
Use your Uber account to order delivery from Bay Delicatessen in Huntington … 94 New York Ave, Huntington, NY 11743. Sandwiches. More. x $0 delivery fee.
Bay Deli of Huntington (@thebaydeli) • Instagram photos and videos
522 followers · 52 following · 31 posts · @thebaydeli: “”
Bay Deli Delivery Menu | Order Online | 94 New York Ave Huntington
Order delivery or pickup from Bay Deli in Huntington! View Bay Deli’s February 2026 deals and menus. Support your local restaurants with Grubhub!
Reviews
Nick Tavella
Hands down the best deli on Long Island!!!! Bacon is amazing, service is unmatched, and prices are normal. I’ve been coming to Huntington as of recently due to a new lady I am dating. I tried multiple delis in the area and was so disappointed in every experience I had. My new lady friend suggested this small deli up the road called bay deli. I was reluctant to give another deli a try in this area but let me tell you. I was so surprised at the price of my egg sandwich amongst everything going up these prices were fairly priced and the service was fast and friendly and it was the best egg sandwich I’ve probably ever had. Deff come here if you want a delicious egg sandwich without having to refinance your house!
… moreR Carr
Bay Deli’s staff is the best. And they make a perfect egg sandwich. Every time.
… moreRobinson Soto
The sandwiches were delicious and I would go back again, the service was a bit slow. If there is anything you can do to speed that up, it would be great.
I recommend calling ahead?
… moreI recommend calling ahead?
Gerald Laing
Been going here on and off for years.
When I’m in the area I stop in.
Today though, not happy.
Not going to say which employee but ordered 2 egg sandwiches one has onion right
So as I’m paying the person goes to put the sandwiches down and goes OH I need to check something, the onion was on the wrong sandwich I see him swapping something in the back but can’t see what, get to my jobsite and realize they put raw onion on my mine instead of the other, they swap it hoping I wouldn’t realize.
Whatever, I like onion that’s not the point.
These days everyone is allergic to everything thankfully I’m not.
Do that to someone with an allergy and you could put someone in the hospital.
Get the order right, or explain and ask if the customer wants it remade….. not cool
… moreWhen I’m in the area I stop in.
Today though, not happy.
Not going to say which employee but ordered 2 egg sandwiches one has onion right
So as I’m paying the person goes to put the sandwiches down and goes OH I need to check something, the onion was on the wrong sandwich I see him swapping something in the back but can’t see what, get to my jobsite and realize they put raw onion on my mine instead of the other, they swap it hoping I wouldn’t realize.
Whatever, I like onion that’s not the point.
These days everyone is allergic to everything thankfully I’m not.
Do that to someone with an allergy and you could put someone in the hospital.
Get the order right, or explain and ask if the customer wants it remade….. not cool
Christine Levy
Very good breakfast sandwich. I would’ve given them 5 ⭐ but I was a little disappointed when I got home and wanted to enjoy my rainbow popcorn I opened the bag and the popcorn was stail rubbery and when I looked at the date it had expired in Dec 2022
… moreFrederick Schneider
The best egg sandwiches around for the last 40 years. Great heros and home brewed iced tea. Can’t go wrong at the Bay Deli. Bring your appetite.
… moreBill Cavanagh
Another north shore Long Island amazing deli . everybody loved the sandwiches thank you so much .
… moreJeffrey Fowler
Never going back. 2nd time I walked out. Place is terrible.
… more