Chloe Nimps
Amazing all around! Went here tonight to try the pizza and drink special. Absolutely worth the price, and incredible food and service! I definitely recommend the Margherita pizza and cheesy focaccia bread! Our waitress (I believe her name was Allie) was very kind and super sweet and took great care of us. For 2 people the price was great! I absolutely would recommend giving Batista’s a try! Cozy location is a plus 🙂
… moreMaverick
Me and my Aunt came here, service was kind, open and friendly. The food was great mostly the appetizers. Though it was hard to find
… moreSunshine Recososa
Andre is absolutely incredible! From the moment we walked in, he made us feel so welcome and taken care of. He’s attentive without being overbearing, and you can tell he genuinely cares about his customers. He recommended a few menu items, and every single one was spot on, the pizza was delicious, perfectly cooked, and full of flavor. Andre’s friendly energy and professionalism really made the whole experience stand out. Battista’s Pizza Place is lucky to have him, can’t wait to come back!
… moreKelly Brooks
My husband and I went for dinner tonight. The best meal we’ve had out in quite a while. The wine, the app, the hot sandwiches
… moreBenjamin Grant
Every time we come here the food and service are amazing, Brian is our server today and He’s fantastic. Have never left here and not been beyond pleased. If you want delicious food and authentic Italian feel COME TO BATTISTA’S
… moremarydileo Poole
First time coming here. The bucatini Alfredo was delicious. The goat cheese smear also great. Fun atmosphere and nice people. Although they already have a Christmas tree up and it isn’t even Thanksgiving yet. Hmm. I think they should dress their tree up as a Thanksgiving turkey. Anyway, good experience. The host, Elliott, and server, Haley, even talked to us for a few mins and we felt very welcome. The chef even came out! Great time.
… moreJoe Ero
The Cluck, Cluck, Boom was great! Loved the crust, especially. The roast beef sandwich was tasty, and the bread was flaky. Highly recommend the strawberry lemonade cocktail.
The knots were solid, but I’d like to try another flavor.
Will definitely be back!
… moreAmanda G
This pizzeria was very tucked away and you’d miss it if you didn’t know it was there. I’m SO glad we stopped in. We were the very first customers of the day and had the place to ourselves. They gave us bread with olive oil and each of them were amazing!! I could not get enough of both. The pepperoni pizza was delicious! This is the best pizza in NWI hands down. This is REAL pizza. The crust was crunch but chewy. The cheese was to die for! And the sauce was super juicy. I will only be eating pizza from here now!
… moreManda G.
Coming into this place I was a little confused. As a reviewer you have to be open-minded coming into new spots. This place is a cozy little corner. Very warm, welcoming, and great company. As a New Yorker I find it very hard to find thin crust pizza. And we always say it’s in the water.
With covid-19 we all have to remember everyone’s menu is limited. We came here for a nice pie! Not the desert pie you guys think. A cheese margarita pie!
We choose the classic and buffalo margarita pies. The crust was thin and crispy with goodness! Both fresh mozzarella and buffalo mozzarella were phenomenal. You definitely taste the difference in both pies.
The decor I absolutely loved! It’s very antique looking with a rustic feel. It’s very warm just like the staff!
Thank you Kristen and the whole staff for making us feel at home. We are the margarita group. That can’t wait to come back!
… moreAshourrina Auz
If pizza could be a love affair, Battista’s would be my guilty pleasure. From the moment that first slice touched my lips, I knew I was in for something dangerous, something… irresistible. The crust? Oh, baby, it’s firm but soft in all the right places. Every bite had me moaning—out loud. Yeah, that’s right. It’s that good.
The sauce? Let’s just say it’s smoother than a well-rehearsed pickup line, and when it mingles with the cheese, they dance together in a slow, seductive waltz on my tongue. By the time I got to the pepperoni, I wasn’t sure if I was still at a pizza joint or a romantic rendezvous. I could feel it… deep. You know, that satisfaction.
Battista’s doesn’t just serve pizza; they serve you an experience that’s saucier than your Saturday night plans. If you haven’t tried it yet, get yourself there—just be prepared to get a little hot and bothered.
… more