andrew yakobitis
walked into this amazing , smelling restaurant Never heard of before! Bagelman!! Was told to hit it up in the morning and by far the best bagels I ever had!!!
Got the salt bagel and rainbow bagel!!
10/10 thank you !! Staff was friendly and busy!!
Coffee was also great
Nice little tables to sit inside
… moreJames F
Coffee was amazing. One of the best iced coffees i had when i visited the area. Food was okay. My friend asked if they had vegan egg but said they were unsure. When i asked someone else said they did. So lack of consistency. As we got our food i asked for a little side cup of jelly. That took about 10 minutes to get for whatever reason. The young kid told me he had to go to the back to get it and i never saw him again. One of the other workers had to go and get it for me which took him like 2 seconds.
… moreWill Martinez
Horrible!! $8 for a bacon egg and cheese with extra bacon.. there was hardly any bacon and the bacon was flabby and gross. Do yourselves a favor and go to Jo Jo’s deli. $4 with extra bacon and they actually put extra bacon.
… moreThe Foodie Baddie
Sooo I’m new to the New Milford location! What a nice surprise… and they even have vegan sausage available. The bagel was cooked that morning you could tell how fresh it was! Soft deliciousness. I called in a to go order and picked up it promptly.
… moreCarly Hilliard
I love bagelmans food. The people are kind. Also, thye offer gluten free bagels and bread and it’s actually delicious!
… moreMarc A. Neal
Clean bagel cafe with all the extras you need. Bagels are tasty, large and cream cheese excellent.
… morepatrick carneiro
i’ve gone to the bagel man in new Fairfield in Danburry and I came to the bagel man in New Milford for the first time today. All I ordered was a bacon egg and cheese with extra bacon extra egg and it turned out to $9.$.50 just about I will never ever in my life come here again for not even for a cuppa coffee and that’s a sad part. I wanted a cuppa coffee on top of my breakfast sandwich and I didn’t even order one because that is waaayyy to much!! what I paid here today will never happen again I paid $6-$7 and something cents at the other two bagel man I have gone to I did not even get enough bacon for what I have paid for. This is so wrong and disrespectful towards the customers who work hard to come here to give our money to get robbed. That’s how I see it as everywhere I get shorted on if it’s at the diner, if it’s at the deli I will file complain. I’m not gonna complain about it because it’s my first time here and I am posting this so people know yes their food is good but there are other places we can go for the same quality food for half the price I am very upset right now as a customer I will never come back!
… moreDan R
First of all the service was not as bad as everyone said. The order was taken, correctly executed in a timely fashion.
Atmosphere? It’s got a few seats and does a lot of take out. What are people expecting? Live music and free hookah?
The only real complaint is the bagels. I’m a snotty NYer and the Bagelman bagels.. They were ok, but should have been a little more dense. And when I say toast it dark, really… You should toast it.
Good coffee.
… moreNelly Moctezuma
I specifically requested on my online order a slightly toasted bagel and I got instead a dry,hard and burn bagel. I feel very disappointed
… moreDeborah Szymanski
Great experience there yesterday… walked over while waiting for my car to be serviced at a nearby dealer.
The atmosphere was great there. Very clean and nicely lit when walking in. Friendly staff. Felt welcomed. Open kitchen to watch your creation made.
The selection to choose from is wonderful from sandwiches to of course, all varieties of bagels. We tried a bagel with seasonal Pumpkin cream cheese Yum!! The flavor was delightful. Not to spicy or sweet… a perfect blend.
No skimping here either. Which is a nice bonus.
There’s ample parking in the back and front of building.
We sat In their outside seating area. Tables were very clean and it felt like a little slice of heaven outside in the sun and clouds.
Of course, when we were ready to leave, we went home with a 1/2 dozen and a container of the pumpkin cream cheese to go for the family to enjoy later!
Highly recommend a stop here! Will definitely visit again!
… more