Social Profile: ![]()
✔️Breakfast ✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
At Bagel Shack, we handcraft classic bagels on-premises every day: mixed, hand-rolled, proofed, kettle-boiled, and baked fresh in all the traditional flavors—from plain to everything. Enjoy our breakfast sandwiches: artisan cream cheeses, bacon, Taylor ham, sausage, eggs, lunch sandwiches: Boar’s Head deli meats, house-made salads, burgers, cheesesteaks, and Lacas Coffee—roasted for over 100 years. Quick, friendly service and every way to order: drive-thru, curbside, phone, our website, DoorDash, Uber Eats, Grubhub—cash or card, we’ve got you. Plenty of parking (even for big rigs), easy access off Route 17 north & south at Island Road, MacArthur Blvd in Mahwah, NJ. We greet regulars by name and turn newcomers into friends.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 395 NJ-17, Mahwah, NJ 07430
Phone: (201) 331-3237
Website: https://bagelshack.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Related Web Results
Classic Bagel, New Experience | Bagel Shack | Mahwah
Bagel Shack | Mahwah … We take pride in our classic bagels, which are made on-premises: mixed, hand-rolled, proofed, kettle-cooked, and baked daily in various …
Bagel Shack (@bagelshacknj) • Instagram photos and videos
Bagel Shack | Classic Bagel, New Experience ☕️ 395 NJ-17, Mahwah, NJ 07430 201-331-3237 …
Bagel Shack | Mahwah NJ – Facebook
Bagels before the blizzard ❄️ We’re opening tomorrow morning at our normal time (5AM) with closing depending on the weather. Come early, stock up, and stay warm …
Product
Last Updates
Reviews
Hani Batla
After several friends recommended Bagel Shack I finally checked them out. They are legit purveyors of excellent delicious bagels. The bagels are massive and the sandwiches are generously made.
The whole place is optimized for good service and providing your yummy bagel as quickly as possible.
In addition it’s got great parking, curbside pickup for online orders and a fairly decent online ordering system.
They are permanently part of my bagel rotation!
… moreThe whole place is optimized for good service and providing your yummy bagel as quickly as possible.
In addition it’s got great parking, curbside pickup for online orders and a fairly decent online ordering system.
They are permanently part of my bagel rotation!
Adrienne Brizzi
UPDATE! Best flagels I’ve ever had. So amazingly good. I also purchased dozens of bagels from Bagel Shack for a catering I was doing for my store, The Little Kitchen. They couldn’t have been easier to work with. They loaded our car with hot, amazing bagels and my clients raved about them. Their bagels are huge, crispy outside and soft inside, with great flavor. Very excited to have a new go-to bagel shop so close to home and work. Service is also outstanding. ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Posting a pic of their bagels on the buffet I set up. Look at the size of them!
Stopped in and got a tuna sandwich on a sesame bagel. My order was made correctly, staff was great. I will say, the bagels are smaller, more NY style bagels. But sandwich was good, the tuna was fresh and well seasoned, the bagel has a good texture. Next time, I’m getting a flagel with their delicious looking bacon and red onion cream cheese.
… morePosting a pic of their bagels on the buffet I set up. Look at the size of them!
Stopped in and got a tuna sandwich on a sesame bagel. My order was made correctly, staff was great. I will say, the bagels are smaller, more NY style bagels. But sandwich was good, the tuna was fresh and well seasoned, the bagel has a good texture. Next time, I’m getting a flagel with their delicious looking bacon and red onion cream cheese.
Christian
Genuinely just had the most frustrating food experience I’ve had in months. I’ve been to this place 3 times. This 3rd time is the last. First time I got a bacon, egg, and cheese on a plain bagel. That was ok, nothing spectacular. I didn’t come back for a while, but I like supporting small business so I gave them another chance after a few weeks.
I went again and ordered the same thing. This time was much better. I guess they improved the way they prepare their food.
This 3rd time just plain pissed me off. I ordered the French toast platter. If you look at the menu it says platters come with eggs, bacon, and home fries. Guess what? This one apparently doesn’t. Can you imagine my surprise when I got my order and there were just 3 measly pieces of French toast on an aluminum plate.
I thought it was a mistake. No biggie, they happen. . But the cashier informed me that they don’t come with any of that. So I just paid $8.50 for 3 pieces of French toast that I 100% could have made at home and better.
To top it off, they were burned. Not badly, but enough so that I had to pick at my food and work around the burn pieces. Looks crispy in the picture right? It’s not. Those are pieces of burned whatever. Not going here again anytime soon.
Pretty obvious when the staff shows differential treatment to other customers too.
… moreI went again and ordered the same thing. This time was much better. I guess they improved the way they prepare their food.
This 3rd time just plain pissed me off. I ordered the French toast platter. If you look at the menu it says platters come with eggs, bacon, and home fries. Guess what? This one apparently doesn’t. Can you imagine my surprise when I got my order and there were just 3 measly pieces of French toast on an aluminum plate.
I thought it was a mistake. No biggie, they happen. . But the cashier informed me that they don’t come with any of that. So I just paid $8.50 for 3 pieces of French toast that I 100% could have made at home and better.
To top it off, they were burned. Not badly, but enough so that I had to pick at my food and work around the burn pieces. Looks crispy in the picture right? It’s not. Those are pieces of burned whatever. Not going here again anytime soon.
Pretty obvious when the staff shows differential treatment to other customers too.
Steven Boettcher
Born and raised in Jersey but living down south since 2005. I have missed real bagels and when I saw that this location was near my hotel, I knew I had to try it. We ordered online and picked up inside. It was easy and my order was ready and accurate. Let’s start with the iced coffee. It was amazing and just what we needed to start the morning. The bagels and cream cheese selections were fantastic. You can’t go wrong with a Taylor ham, egg, and cheese on a toasted poppy bagel. My son loved the Nutella cream cheese on a plain bagel. I wish I could have brought home a dozen before I left but I will definitely stop by when I’m in the area again.
… moreMichael
Here’s your foodie-style review with that part added in naturally about the bagels not being flat:
⸻
I saw a couple negative reviews floating around and honestly I think they either hit the wrong spot or they’re just salty competitors. From the second I walked in I was like whoa. The place is gorgeous, spotless, and has that “I could hang out here all day” kind of vibe. The staff were super friendly and really on point with everyone coming through the door.
I rolled in around noon on October 1st and grabbed a whitefish salad sandwich with lettuce, tomato, and onion on a garlic bagel. Yes, I snapped a pic. And wow, easily one of the best bagel sandwiches I’ve ever had. Fluffy, massive, and absolutely loaded. I saw someone say in a review that the bagels here were flat—absolutely not true. Mine was a beast, perfectly baked, soft and fluffy, and piled high. Honestly felt like I could’ve made two sandwiches out of it.
What stood out most was the vibe behind the counter. It looked like some of the owners were there running things, and they were super professional but also just good energy all around. Positive with their employees too, which as a fellow food business owner, I really noticed.
Now the coffee. I don’t say this lightly, but it was one of the best cups I’ve ever had. Rich, nutty, smooth, just perfect. And it wasn’t even flavored, just straight up good coffee.
I didn’t even know this spot existed until now and I wish I had found it sooner. Parking was easy even with some construction going on. The menu has plenty of options, and the prices are almost too good to be true. $9.99 for that monster of a sandwich, while other places like Goldbergs charges double for half the size.
… more⸻
I saw a couple negative reviews floating around and honestly I think they either hit the wrong spot or they’re just salty competitors. From the second I walked in I was like whoa. The place is gorgeous, spotless, and has that “I could hang out here all day” kind of vibe. The staff were super friendly and really on point with everyone coming through the door.
I rolled in around noon on October 1st and grabbed a whitefish salad sandwich with lettuce, tomato, and onion on a garlic bagel. Yes, I snapped a pic. And wow, easily one of the best bagel sandwiches I’ve ever had. Fluffy, massive, and absolutely loaded. I saw someone say in a review that the bagels here were flat—absolutely not true. Mine was a beast, perfectly baked, soft and fluffy, and piled high. Honestly felt like I could’ve made two sandwiches out of it.
What stood out most was the vibe behind the counter. It looked like some of the owners were there running things, and they were super professional but also just good energy all around. Positive with their employees too, which as a fellow food business owner, I really noticed.
Now the coffee. I don’t say this lightly, but it was one of the best cups I’ve ever had. Rich, nutty, smooth, just perfect. And it wasn’t even flavored, just straight up good coffee.
I didn’t even know this spot existed until now and I wish I had found it sooner. Parking was easy even with some construction going on. The menu has plenty of options, and the prices are almost too good to be true. $9.99 for that monster of a sandwich, while other places like Goldbergs charges double for half the size.
Stephanie
Just discovered this gem of a bagel shop, and I’m already planning my next visit. The bagels here are incredibly fluffy—think soft and pillowy on the inside, with just the right amount of chew and a golden, satisfying crust. These aren’t your average grocery store bagels; they’re thick, hearty, and clearly made with care. You can really taste the freshness. We bought 6 plain bagels and two ice coffees for our first visit, and it was great!!!
The staff are super friendly, they greet you as you walk in, and it was smooth and efficient ordering processing all under 6 minutes.
If you’re looking for bagels that feel substantial, comforting, and freshly made, this place is worth the visit. A new favorite in Bergen County, NJ!
… moreThe staff are super friendly, they greet you as you walk in, and it was smooth and efficient ordering processing all under 6 minutes.
If you’re looking for bagels that feel substantial, comforting, and freshly made, this place is worth the visit. A new favorite in Bergen County, NJ!
Rosabel Ferber
Great vibe. They have plants. Food is great , huge bagels. We got a flat bagel. Really nice sound system. Super clean and sunny, lots of windows. Good chip selection, nice parking lot too. Cherry on top – very clean bathrooms. Best breakfast road trip spot!
… moreScott DeFranco-Norton
Phenomenal. And I say this as a Bagel Train (Suffern) customer for over 30 years. I grew up in Bagel train with my mom and grandmother. Over the years it has faded. Yesterday I even called and spoke to the owner. They had excuses. Not bagel Shack. LOOK at this Lox bagel. The one on the left (fat) is from Bagel Shack. The one on the right (pathetic) is Bagel Train. Literally back to back days. My day is complete today. I found my new breakfast home and I am so excited to bring my daughter here as she loves bagels. Welcome Bagel Shack! Looking forward to eating all your food! 😀
… moreSiwat Siengsanaoh
Their bagels are HUGE! Crispy on the outside & soft on the inside. Their sausage egg & cheese was delicious. We are saving the cinnamon raisin bagel for later.
… moreNicole Johnson
Tried Bagel Shack this morning for the first time and it was pretty good! I got a sesame bagel with scallion cream cheese and bacon and my husband got a taylor ham egg and cheese on an everything. Both were pretty solid! Called in the order and picked up at the counter and both were ready by the time I got there (<8min). Won’t replace our go-to place, but a good spot for bagels in the area.
… more