James McKee
I have visited more than several BC’s in northern Michigan. The quality is very consistent, and the results, delicious. The staff at Petoskey was so friendly and engaging. I had a Spicy Peach pizza this time and it was amazing. These things are important as I trust the brand, and am now a loyal customer!! As always, highly recommended. Thank you!!
… moreGwenevere Mueller
The pizza took a long time to arrive but was really good. Breadsticks were buttery and awesome. My kiddo enjoyed the salad bar/pizza buffet for $4.
Overall, decent experience if you’re trying to avoid crowds.
… moreTyler Weisner
I always go to BC Pizza if I Stay near one on vacation! I’ve been to a dozen. I always get the spirals and they never disappoint. BUT, this is the only location they’ve ever been an utter disappointment… little to no cheese in them (just bread and a pepperoni…) they said 25-30min and we got there right on time they were already cold. Slowest and worst location hands down
… moreEvan Gunthner
First off, I’d like to say I LIKE BC Pizza. I’ve ordered from them several times, in Boyne City, Gaylord, and Mackinac City. Never been disappointed. However, today I ordered for the first time at the Petoskey location… also… the last time. I ordered a Dill Pickle Pizza, with extra white sauce, extra garlic crust, added bacon, well done. Aside from the “well done” part… everything else was wrong, as you can see in the pictures. It either had ALMOST no sauce, or flat out NO sauce. I picked up the first piece and everything just fell off as I picked it up. In one of the photos I pressed my finger into the top of the pizza to illustrate that it was just gummy plain dough. The pizza also had NO dill on it whatsoever, as well as NO garlic on the crust. I tried my best to illustrate all this in the pictures. I basically got plain dough, with some pickles, bacon, and a little bit of cheese and parmesean on it. It tasted like white bread with salt on it. The whole point of dill pickle pizza is to cut the saltiness with the sweet and savory of the sauce, which is why I ordered extra sauce and garlic. I ate what I could cause I’m cheap and hate wasting food… but… it’s just… so incredibly bad. I physically don’t think I could keep anymore down. A Little Ceasars Hot and Ready, in comparison, sounds like fillet mignon right now… for less than half the price. Fool me ONCE Petoskey! Yuck!
… moreBen Mason
I used to love this place. Super good pizza, good specialty items, decent price. Just ordered three items and was charged over $13 for delivery, fuel, and “credit cards fees” only to receive a sad looking sandwich and a 10 piece chicken wing for $11. $42 to deliver two miles from your store? Will never spend money here again.
… moreDawn L
Love ❤️ this place, we come a 40 minute drive and pass by two other BC Pizza on the way. It is worth the trip, the pizza and salad bar buffet is amazing. Fresh hot and full. We appreciate how nice and accommodating the staff is.
… moreChrista Krotkiewicz
Awful customer service. The front desk was rude and made us feel like a bother for going in. We also won the coin game at the front desk (won a free small pizza) and the front desk was pissed. We wanted to order the free pizza and we weren’t acknowledged by the staff. Spicy dill pickle pizza itself we ordered was excellent. But overall the poor service made for an overall upsetting experience.
… moreCory Davis
I’m traveling, and my gosh, I had the Buffalo chicken pizza and the extra cheezy bread Styx and it’s top notch! Even when he was short handed, was delicious!
… moreBenjamin B
I decided to order the sarge because I wanted to have delicious amazing pizza for a couple days but when I tasted the first morsel of BC pizza I immediately crammed piece after piece of heaven into my buccal cavity and down my gullet. I would obviously throw up from that amount of food at any other establishment but my stomach would not allow any food to exit its domain because of how glorious the taste and texture was. Glory to BC. Glory to the Sarge.
… moresteve groner
Outstanding spaghetti and pizza. Some of the best in have ever had. Delivery guy was awesome as well.
… more