Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Small, modest counter-service pizza joint featuring classic pies, BBQ ribs & chicken wings.
Hours
| Monday | 3 PM–12:45 AM |
| Tuesday | 3 PM–12:45 AM |
| Wednesday | 3 PM–12:45 AM |
| Thursday | 3 PM–1:45 AM |
| Friday | 3 PM–1:45 AM |
| Saturday | 3 PM–1:45 AM |
| Sunday | 3 PM–12:45 AM |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 5339 English Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46219
Phone: (317) 638-3663
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Aunt Pollys Pizza | Indianapolis IN – Facebook
Aunt Pollys Pizza, Indianapolis. 4855 likes · 4 talking about this · 465 were here. Delivering delicious Pizzas, Breadsticks, Sandwiches,Chicken, Wings,…
Aunt Polly’s Pizza – Hot Pizza, Wings & Late-Night Deals
Aunt Polly’s Pizza serves fresh 18 pies, BBQ wings & sandwiches. Open till 3AM in Indianapolis with hot deals like 2 XL pizzas for just $24.99!
Aunt Polly’s Pizza, 5339 English Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46219, US
Get more information for Aunt Polly’s Pizza in Indianapolis, IN. See reviews, map, get the address, and find directions.
Reviews
Ivy Rahne
I order the ‘special one’ that came with the 18” pizza, breadsticks, and a 2 liter for 25$. The food was super super good and smelled great too. The buildings a little shabby but don’t let that dissuade you. I already took a slice out before I even took the pic
… moreTony Owens
AVOID THIS BUISSNESS!!!
UPDATE 05/19/2025
Thought I would give them another chance and was disappointed with them again. They were extremely rude and hateful on the call had to cancel the order. Had no choice b
Update 7/30/2024
Dave talks pretty nice and offers a free meal on him for the inconvenience and trouble for my last purchase but never calls back or follows through with his agreement.
Look elsewhere for your meals. Try “Just Pizza” instead. You get two for one at BOGO every day and are great their bread sticks are great also with garlic and parmasan on them.
Update, 5/25/2023
I spoke with the owner David, and he genuinely wants to make things right with my last order. So I gave Aunt Polly’s Pizza another chance.
David did not fail to impress me. He replaced my order and sent a half rack of ribs, baked beans, and cookies. All of which were excellent, love the ribs!! I have attacked tonight’s photos to this as well.
5/20/2023
Ordered a medium pizza with beef, pepperoni, onions with extra beef and extra cheese, and an order of bread sticks. What I got was a regular pizza with nothing extra. I called, and the fellow that answered just wanted to call me a liar. And hung up. Order with caution… this cost me $36
… moreUPDATE 05/19/2025
Thought I would give them another chance and was disappointed with them again. They were extremely rude and hateful on the call had to cancel the order. Had no choice b
Update 7/30/2024
Dave talks pretty nice and offers a free meal on him for the inconvenience and trouble for my last purchase but never calls back or follows through with his agreement.
Look elsewhere for your meals. Try “Just Pizza” instead. You get two for one at BOGO every day and are great their bread sticks are great also with garlic and parmasan on them.
Update, 5/25/2023
I spoke with the owner David, and he genuinely wants to make things right with my last order. So I gave Aunt Polly’s Pizza another chance.
David did not fail to impress me. He replaced my order and sent a half rack of ribs, baked beans, and cookies. All of which were excellent, love the ribs!! I have attacked tonight’s photos to this as well.
5/20/2023
Ordered a medium pizza with beef, pepperoni, onions with extra beef and extra cheese, and an order of bread sticks. What I got was a regular pizza with nothing extra. I called, and the fellow that answered just wanted to call me a liar. And hung up. Order with caution… this cost me $36
Sunshine Aria
The food is really good. Especially for the price. And the people are so so so friendly. But the shop itself is really inconsistent. There is no website. And the Facebook page isn’t updated more than every few months. And they don’t appear to update hours in Google. So they don’t really utilize any of the available methods to let their customers know when they’ll be closing outside of the normal hours.
For example: the Saturday between Christmas and new years and they’re closed. But nobody knows that unless they magically get someone to answer the phone. Which is hard on a regular day.
For many repeat customers, we know they don’t always get to every phone call. So a lot of us drive up there and place an order and wait. How does that work if they’re not open during their open hours, you ask?
It doesn’t. At all. And results in some pretty unhappy customers that normally try pretty hard to be understanding of their inconsistencies and barriers.
If Facebook is the only method you’re going to use to communicate with your customers, please try using it to its full capacity. Like making a post for days you’ll be closed.
And based on comments on that fb page and reviews here, it appears it’s a regular problem that could be better resolved with some communication.
… moreFor example: the Saturday between Christmas and new years and they’re closed. But nobody knows that unless they magically get someone to answer the phone. Which is hard on a regular day.
For many repeat customers, we know they don’t always get to every phone call. So a lot of us drive up there and place an order and wait. How does that work if they’re not open during their open hours, you ask?
It doesn’t. At all. And results in some pretty unhappy customers that normally try pretty hard to be understanding of their inconsistencies and barriers.
If Facebook is the only method you’re going to use to communicate with your customers, please try using it to its full capacity. Like making a post for days you’ll be closed.
And based on comments on that fb page and reviews here, it appears it’s a regular problem that could be better resolved with some communication.
Korrine Clayton
Nice little hole in the wall pizza place! My family learned about Aunt Polly’s from a co-worker. We have been enjoying Aunt Polly’s for almost three years.
… moreLauren Roller
We ordered from Aunt Polly’s Pizza during the Pacers game and everything was absolutely amazing! We got pizza, wings, ribs, subs, and breadsticks—and every single item was delicious. You could tell everything was fresh. The staff was incredibly friendly and helpful, which made the experience even better. Everyone at our party raved about the food—it was the perfect game day feast! Highly recommend and will definitely be ordering again. Thanks Aunt Polly’s!
… moreAngel Tarver
Kevin gave wonderful service! If you haven’t tried this spot and you are in Indianapolis you are missing out. This is the best pizza joint in Indianapolis!! Crystal brought our pizza out with the biggest smile on her face. She was so cheerful and sweet, she made my day!!! They must be family owned because the services and hospitality is top tier, the best I’ve experienced since moving to Indianapolis, Indiana in 2014!!!
… moreBeth Meyer
Aunt Polly’s really went above and beyond for service on my large order for a church event! They were able to provide staff to prepare and deliver my order 3 and 1/2 hours BEFORE their regular opening time. The food quality was delicious! They were pleasant and friendly during the telephone ordering/payment process. They also looked for ways to save me some money through their special offers! I was super satisfied.
… morejordan mathews
We love aunt Polly’s pizza and it’s a hit every time for every occasion! Along with great food they have amazing people there that are always there for everyone! They provided pizza for my Uncle Gary Cockrill’s Celebration of life we had for everyone and it was amazing! We appreciate it so much! My uncle worked for Aunt Polly’s for so long and they showed their love and support to us!
… moreEmily Neal
I’ve been coming here for like 15 years or more and I ABSOLUTELY LOVE THIS PLACE! the manager Kevin is my favorite! He always takes care of me and the pizza is my FAVORITE! I usually get it like once a week! The best pizza place around!!
… moreAmanda Reed
Delicious didnt know they had 2 different crusts and didn’t get asked either which I would of liked . my hubs wasn’t a fan of the thick crust.. I loved it the wings were amazing ppl are nice will be returning
… more