Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Aunt Cookies Sub Shop has been serving the same delicious toasted subs to the Geneseo, NY community since 1971. We are an iconic SUNY Geneseo alumni favorite and we strongly believe that If it works and people love it, don’t change it! We are open for lunch and dinner 7 days a week and we can’t wait to see you!
Address and Contact Information
Address: 76 Main St, Geneseo, NY 14454
Phone: (585) 243-2650
Website: http://auntcookiessubshop.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Aunt Cookie’s Sub Shop: Home of the Best Tasting “Toasted Roll …
Serving Geneseo, NY since August 4th, 1971! Visit us at 76 Main Street, Geneseo NY or call (585) 243-2650 Call Ahead Orders are Welcome!
Aunt Cookie’s Sub Shop | Explore Genesee Valley
Located just 10 minutes from the north entrance to Letchworth State Park, Aunt Cookie’s Sub Shop is an iconic Geneseo eatery and home of the world’s best …
Aunt Cookie’s Sub Shop | Geneseo, NY 14454 – ILoveNY.com
Aunt Cookie’s Sub Shop · 76 Main St · Geneseo, NY 14454 · (585) 243-2650 · Visit Site | E-Mail · Add to Calendar · Add to Trip Planner.
Reviews
Bear_Converse
Called my order in. The rude lady put the phone down so she could talk to somebody else about her weekend plans. Finally took my order and told me 15 minutes. We showed up in 15 minutes and we had to wait another 20 minutes. We finally got our food home. It was nasty. We couldn’t finish it and then we spent the rest of the night and the next day in the bathroom. Aunt Cookies is not the old Aunt Cookies who were polite, courteous, and respectful. Will not be going back there ever again just nasty
… moreKerryAnn Kraft
Disappointed. I’ve been eating at aunt cookies since I was a kid. Drove 30 mins for a sub got there about 8pm aware they close at 9pm. Was told we couldn’t eat there because the dinner room closes at 8pm. Everyone knows the subs are better hot. Update your hours on Google if you have different dinning room hours. I would have stayed home.
… moreScott McNinch
I love this place, reminds me of when I was a kid every time we go there! And, the subs are still made the same way all these years later. Every time we come back from Seattle we make it one of the first places we go! Enjoy!
… morePatricia Pierce (PattyAnne)
College town sub joint. Maybe 5 booths. Two young ladies working. Slowly working. But food is well worth the wait. Been going here for 25 years.
… moreJohn Norris
Awesome, old school sub shop with generous portions and friendly people working. Giant cookies and a better selection of chips than most. Two thumbs up.
… moreKnight_D7
Haven’t been here in 9 years!! Just cave back, stopped by the place. Subs are still great!! They remodeled it since we were here last. Looks great!!
… moreJustin Schillinger
The subs used to be a lot better when they toasted their buns more. That is their whole slogan. And yet when you get your sub it’s barely even warm, and when you asked them to toast it twice it’s barely browned like it used to be. If they toasted their roles better I would give it a four and a half Stars.
… moreRichard K
I was a first time visitor to the Central New York college town of Geneseo on Monday September 9, 2019. I was hungry and it was lunchtime so I went exploring this charming village looking for some food. I had just walked out of the pizza place across the street because the music was obnoxiously loud and then I saw this sandwich shop. Apparently this business is the oldest one in town. The restaurant was quiet and comfortable. I had an half Italian sub, toasted with yellow mustard. Delicious. The staff was friendly and my Discover Card was accepted. I recommend Aunt Cookies when in Geneseo NY.
… moreDaniel Moore
Best subs in the greater Rochester area! Toasted italian rolls are next level.
… moreMichelle Dunn
Love the subs at aunt cookies. The staff is amazing. Always friendly and welcoming. Orders are always right and on time.
… more