Snug, straightforward pizzaria with booth seating serving pies & pastas from a counter.
Middle possum
Everything we got here was excellent! Their sub rolls are homemade & delicious! We got a cheese pizza and a meatball parm, chicken parm, and ham & cheese subs. The place is a little off the square but tucked away so there’s plenty of free parking. Owner is friendly & service was fast. Restaurant was clean but small. We will be back!
… moreJaime Burke
An absolutely fantastic experience!
We received a friendly greeting when we walked in and immediately felt welcome.
We ordered The Grandma and a Sicilian, and they did not disappoint! Both were delicious, but Grandma was our favorite. Fresh, and just so simply good. Both pizzas full of flavor, and with a crust you actually want to finish!
The owner stopped by to talk with us for several minutes, as I told him about my Italian/Sicilian heritage. This guy is the real deal and is doing things right. You can see the pride he takes in his business and the appreciation he has for his customers.
We will definitely be back when we’re in the area, and will recommend to everyone we know who is coming to Gettysburg!
❤️
❤️
… moreJimmy B
My visit to Antica Napoli Pizza was simply splendid. Everyone there is super friendly. I really liked the pre-configured pizza options on the menu and there’s no hesitation to add any other topping to make it your own. It’s tucked near the end of the parking lot. If you’re in the mood for pizza, I recommend a visit.
… moreD Atch
This was our first time visiting Gettysburg and dined here our first night. Delicious! My pizza reminded me of being in Italy years ago. One thing we didn’t know is that you could BYOB, which I would do if you enjoy a beer with your pizza. We also ordered two different pizzas on one pie which worked perfect.
The staff was very friendly and welcoming. I would highly recommend eating here for dine in or carry out.
… moreBettrina Reimer
Delicious!! Travelled to Gettysburg with my family and ate lunch at Antica Napoli Pizza. I really wanted pizza and they had great reviews so we decided to try. The guy at the counter was so friendly and helped us decide what we wanted. It was amazing. I come from a pizza eating family but my husband only likes pizza..sometimes. He loved his pizza and wanted to go back the next day. Unfortunately we were only in town 1 night & left early. I ordered garlic knots for a late night snack at the hotel. So glad I ordered them.
… moreAnn Rudd
We stopped in as we were traveling through town and wanted something low key that didn’t attract tourists. What a fantastic restaurant!! Super friendly owner, food came out quickly and our Stromboli was fantastic. We come through town occasionally and we will certainly be back! If you are looking for authentic tomato sauce, fresh ingredients and a fantastic crust, give this one a try. Prices are great as well.
… moreKristyn Triplett
Pizza was fantastic! By far the best pizza I have had in a very long time. Crust was perfect, toppings were heaven, and sauce was right on point. The owner and customer service were out of this world. Customer service seems to be a dying art and let me tell you, this place is top notch. From the moment we walked in, we were greeted with a huge smile. He checked in on us multiple times and was so warm and friendly. Will definitely be back! The world needs Antica Napoli Pizza and more humans like the owner. Thanks for making our Friday night! Very grateful.
… moreAleana Riddell
Employees were friendly but I have to say I was a little bit put off that they don’t offer free water to their dine-in customers. Never in my 52 years have I ever ate at a restaurant were they charged you full price for water. We ordered a traditional pizza and it was just okay.
… moreBrooke W.
The food was really good! You order at the counter, and they bring the food to your table. The dining area is pretty small—our group of 8 had to split between two tables. We went on a Saturday, so it was busy, and the food came out in waves. The cheesesteaks took the longest, and we were already done with our pizza by the time they arrived. That said, everything was tasty, and I’d definitely recommend stopping by!
… moreFrances Croom
What a refreshing experience! We did take out and it was ready when promised! Friendly smiles greeted me when I walked in the door.
Easy to pay using Slice and Apple Pay. Ordered the Supreme and it was one of the best we have ever had!
… more