Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Anthony’s Pizzeria & Family Restaurant is located at 51 West Main Street in Rockaway, NJ 07866. We are open for Lunch and Dinner and serve a full Italian menu featuring all types of Pizza, Hot and Cold Sandwiches, Antipasto, Soup, Pasta, Chicken, Veal, and Seafood Dishes. We offer Eat In or Take Out service and have a Private Dining Room for Parties, Birthdays, Holidays, and all Special Occasions including Corporate Dinners and Functions. We Provide Catering For All Occasions. We were voted 2007 Readers Choice for Best Pizza by the Daily Record. For a Delicious Italian Meal, Stop By Today.
Relaxed, old-school Italian eatery serving pizza, pasta, sandwiches & classic entrees since 1979.
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Anthony’s Pizzeria & Family Restaurant: Anthony’s Pizzeria – Best …
Discover Anthony’s Pizzeria & Family Restaurant in Rockaway, NJ. Enjoy our full Italian menu, including pizza, sandwiches, and seafood. We offer dine-in, …
Anthony’s Pizzeria & Family Restaurant | Rockaway NJ – Facebook
51 W Main St, Rockaway, NJ, United States, 07866. Links. . anthonyspizzarockaway.com. Contact info. . (973) 627-1397. . [email protected]. Photos.
Anthony’s Pizzeria & Family Restaurant – MapQuest
Anthony’s Pizzeria & Family Restaurant is a beloved dining establishment located in Rockaway, NJ, offering a diverse menu that highlights their signature pizzas …
Reviews
Sue Saggese
Our server was so friendly and accommodating. I ordered Chicken Marsala, which was excellent. My husband ordered Veal Parmesan. He enjoyed his, too. Portions were above and beyond. My only suggestion would be to paint the incoming side door. When entering a restaurant, the door is your first impression. Don’t judge the restaurant by the door.
… moreElizabeth Secallus
The best place ever!!! If you are looking for authentic, delicious food , this is the place to be. Owners and staff are absolutely wonderful and the food is top notch. Great price and huge portions. Will always keep coming back to this place!
… moreMarie Pena
We recently had a family event catered by Anthony’s, and the experience exceeded every expectation. From start to finish, the team delivered exceptional food and truly outstanding service. Every interaction felt warm and genuine, and it was clear that they take great pride not only in what they serve, but in how they treat their customers.
The food itself was phenomenal—fresh, flavorful, and prepared with real care. Our guests raved about every dish, and the generous portions ensured that no one left hungry (and we even had leftovers to enjoy the next day!). What stood out most was the personalized attention Anthony’s provided. They listened thoughtfully to our needs, offered honest guidance, and customized the menu to suit our family perfectly.
Their professionalism and kindness made our event feel special and stress-free. If you’re looking for caterers who deliver delicious food, warm hospitality, and reliability you can trust, Anthony’s is an outstanding choice. Highly recommended.
… moreThe food itself was phenomenal—fresh, flavorful, and prepared with real care. Our guests raved about every dish, and the generous portions ensured that no one left hungry (and we even had leftovers to enjoy the next day!). What stood out most was the personalized attention Anthony’s provided. They listened thoughtfully to our needs, offered honest guidance, and customized the menu to suit our family perfectly.
Their professionalism and kindness made our event feel special and stress-free. If you’re looking for caterers who deliver delicious food, warm hospitality, and reliability you can trust, Anthony’s is an outstanding choice. Highly recommended.
Elite Martial Arts
So much to say about them. How do you not love them? Their food: amazing (check out their pasta faggioli…no one makes it as a pasta dish like they do). Their service: fast and friendly. Their ambiance: small town, main street comfort. Our staff frequent them and have done so for nearly 20 years. There is a reason why. Go – see for yourself!
… moreChuck Mound
Very Good Slice of Pizza here. Parking is located off Main Street behind the building. The slice was super greasy, but had a lot of flavor. The sauce was really good..They offer many different variations with any topping you cN imagine. There is a separate dining area from the pizzeria. Both were really clean and aesthetically good looking. There is a side entrance to the pizzeria for your quick slice. The servers and people were super nice. The only area of improvement I would suggest is to find another area for the empty pizza boxes. Gorgeous pizzeria and restaurant, but I had to eat surrounded by boxes. Maybe it’s a detail item, but this is one of the Best Slices in the County, so attention to detail continues to raise standards. Great Slice, I will be back soon to try the sicilian. Great Job.
… moreScott Shack
We were in the area working on a charitable project. The owner was so kind to give us a discount on our order after hearing about what we were doing. Pizza and garlic knots were great and the kindness of the staff was even better. We would definitely return if we are ever back in the area. Thank you again.
… moreMyrianne Clitus-Bustillo
I wish people understood how important kindness & being good-natured is to maintaining a viable business. And to top it off, the pizza here Is on par with a Brooklyn slice . I hobbled in after feeling bad vibes somewhere else & it made my night & long drive home all the better. I only wish I’d gotten another slice. I’ll definitely come back if I’m ever in the area again.
… moreJoe Calicchio
This place was amazing! I tried a few different slices and all of them were outstanding especially the stuffed pie! I will definitely be going back for sure. Great job guys, keep it up!!
… moreDirk De hosson
I stopped eating here after they were very rude to me… they took my order of 2 slices and told me to take a seat.. then, they kept walking over to my table and asked me what I ordered… very odd behavior
Finally, I said I could take the slices cold to go… obviously, they never put my slices in the first time… I think they read my negative review of a nearby pizzeria that they are friendly with…
very petty, shoddy treatment.
… moreFinally, I said I could take the slices cold to go… obviously, they never put my slices in the first time… I think they read my negative review of a nearby pizzeria that they are friendly with…
very petty, shoddy treatment.
Mass Engineer
The small Caesar salad is big enough for two people. And it’s good. We also got the eggplant pizza, my family liked it, but I’m not an eggplant fan. Free parking in back. Gulf station with inexpensive gas about 100 feet down the street.
… more