Stella McCarty
Best italian food! Absolutely incredible service and delicious meal options! We asked if they were still serving pretty late into the night and they welcomed us in and were so gracious and hospitable. Beyond the wonderful service, the food is delicious. We were served fresh bread with a beautiful and fresh salad, and our food was amazing. I’ve been here once before, a long time ago (and came back because I couldn’t stop thinking about it), and the food is even better than I remember. Beautiful and clean restaurant, and the ambience is great for a date night or get-together with friends. I couldn’t recommend this place more.
… moreDennis Ceppa
We run all over the country for work and we love trying local places along the way. When you arrive it doesn’t necessarily look like much. It gets more welcoming inside though. And the best part…the food and service were amazing. We didn’t know what we were in for until the salad and garlic bread showed up. Great! We had chicken cordon bleu and baked ziti. Again, great. If what you’re looking for is great food and service without the frills, this is an awesome option. At least it proved so for us!
… moreJenni B
I had an exceptional dining experience here. They stayed open late so my daughter & I could enjoy a meal. We were not disappointed!
… moreSammy Carver
The food was delicious. I got the tiramisu for dessert and it was perfect. Definitely my favorite tiramisu to date. Greg was my server and he was very nice and speedy. He made the atmosphere very warm and welcoming, definitely made the whole experience even more enjoyable.
… moreKhalil Taliaferro
Staff were nice and accommodating.
Nice artwork and painting giving Italian atmosphere. I wish they were playing music that matches Italian atmosphere. The lighting could have been better. Clean bathrooms.
Started with the house salad and bread -5
Salad had too much dressing on it.
Bread was homemade and tasty but too much oil.
Spaghetti was a 7
The pasta quality was average at best.
The sauce was well balanced but seemed store brought. This meal cost $14. I believe the portion was decent for the cost.
Stuffed mushrooms were a 6
They were not stuffed with real crab meat and I didn’t taste any ricotta cheese or bread crumb. The cheese was good that the mushrooms came in.
Italian margarita was a 5
They were out of orange juice so I subbed pineapple juice and it did not hit.
Dessert wine was a 9
Silk pie is just a chocolate cake. They were out of chocolate syrup. The texture was not our favorite – 7
Cheesecake – 7
It was a cheesecake lol not a fan of cherry sauce but not bad.
Overall, Angelo’s was a 4 star. I would eat there again but maybe not dine in.
… moreMatthew Wallach
Delicious Italian food. Highly recommend the baked ziti, and if you can get a side of marinara sauce to dip the amazing garlic knots in, that’s the pro move. Great staff and great food, will definitely be back.
… moreDeAira Floyd
Angelo’s is amazing, we had my birthday dinner here and the service was TOP TIER!!! Everything was fresh and delicious. If this little boy is eating it then it’s a must try. He is my picky eater. I will always go to Angelo’s it if I want an authentic Italian meal.
… moreRico Bulaclac
Garlic knots were awesome. My fettucine alfredo was great, but too high of a sauce to pasta ratio. Salad bowl arrived with a chip in it. I thought that was an outlier but then my entree plate also had a chip in it. Utensils were not provided until after salad had already been served. Mistakes were made on multiple orders at our table and had to be sent back to be corrected. Place was not busy at all at the time, so that was not an excuse for the confusion. Hostess was super nice and apologized, but it seemed like it was an ongoing situation that day as I also overheard apologies at a table across from ours.
… moreTravis Smith
We LOVE this place! A great place for real authentic Italian fine cuisine food. We eat here quite a bit! The wine is amazing and the service is outstanding! We actually met the owner and he is an amazing guy. He actually interact with his customers! The environment is wonderful and we love to sit outside at dusk on Main St. to enjoy the city ambience along with the way Angelos have their setup. Highly recommend if your looking for good Italian food and service in the downtown area of Evansville!
… moreAnn Ladenberger
Yum! Fabulous old-school Italian food in downtown Evansville. I went alone close to closing time and had the spinach ravioli, which came with a side salad and yummy buttered rolls. Not low calorie and I did not care! Reasonably priced; friendly service. I will be back next time I’m in town.
… more