Social Profile: 
![]()
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Angelinas Pizzeria is located in the heart of Downtown Key West, right on Duval Street within the Ricks/Durty Harrys Complex, across the street from Sloppy Joes! We serve pizza BY THE SLICE too! We are a full service pizzeria with lasagna, calzone, salads, wings and subs!
Grab ‘n’ go pizza slices & pies served up from a counter in a no-frills space with limited seating.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 208 Duval St #6508, Key West, FL 33040
Phone: (305) 296-3600
Website: https://angelinaspizzakeywest.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Angelina’s Pizza Key West
For over three decades, Angelina’s Pizzeria has been the go-to destination for the freshest and most mouthwatering pizza in the heart of Old Key West, FL, …
Angelina’s Pizzeria | Key West FL – Facebook
Angelina’s Pizzeria · Details · Links · Contact info. . (305) 296-3600. . [email protected]. Photos. See all. Posts. Angelina’s Pizzeria. 1d · .
Angelina’s Pizza – etabWebOrdering
close. Angelina’s Pizza. 208 Duval Street, Key West, FL. Open 11:00 am – 2:30 am. info_outlined. Search. Search Here. search. Current.
Reviews
Giovanni
Angelina’s Pizzeria is ideally located and renowned for its delicious, high quality pizza, even when handling large crowds. While it may not be the best, it is certainly tasty. They stay open very late and offer various pie sizes, ensuring they have something for everyone. The pizzas are prepared and served quickly, making it a convenient choice for late-night cravings.
… moreAmanda Judkins
We love pizza and I had done a lot of research on where to get a slice of pizza for lunch. This place came up as a consistent recommendation, so we gave it a try. My goodness… we planned to only eat a couple bites and ended up eating the whole slice! The slice is made fresh to order. The crust was thin and crispy and pizza was full of flavor.
… moreTim Enright
Horrible pizza and the service was even worse. I asked up-front if the pizza was ready to go. I was told “yes of course”. I then paid and was told “it will be 5 minutes”. I asked why he told me it was ready to go? He replied “it’s ready to go, in 5 minutes”. What a scam!
I wish I would have known how bad the pizza was before I was lied to. It was chewy, dry and otherwise tasted like cardboard.
Avoid this place.
… moreI wish I would have known how bad the pizza was before I was lied to. It was chewy, dry and otherwise tasted like cardboard.
Avoid this place.
Der “Wertzeit” Tester
Conclusion first: If you’re questing for good vibes, great pizza, and even greater service — this is your tavern.
The staff at Angelina’s were genuinely kind, like NPCs programmed with nothing but helpful dialogue. Super friendly, attentive, and quick with a smile. Drinks? Offered for free when asked, and not just a sip — generously poured, like from a bottomless goblet of refreshment.
The pizza itself? Crispy, cheesy, and flavorful enough to make a bard sing. Easily one of the tastiest we had on our journey through the land of Key West.
Final verdict: A magical little pizzeria where service and flavor both roll natural 20s.
… moreThe staff at Angelina’s were genuinely kind, like NPCs programmed with nothing but helpful dialogue. Super friendly, attentive, and quick with a smile. Drinks? Offered for free when asked, and not just a sip — generously poured, like from a bottomless goblet of refreshment.
The pizza itself? Crispy, cheesy, and flavorful enough to make a bard sing. Easily one of the tastiest we had on our journey through the land of Key West.
Final verdict: A magical little pizzeria where service and flavor both roll natural 20s.
Diane Miranda
PHENOMENAL Thank You Roma Roberts EXCEPTIONAL Delivery Service, Superior Customer Service. AMAZING PIZZA !
YOU ROMA and your A-Tea n Rock!
Super Happy Miranda Family at the Key West Hyatt Vacation Club…….
… moreYOU ROMA and your A-Tea n Rock!
Super Happy Miranda Family at the Key West Hyatt Vacation Club…….
Squib Dickie
Anyone who rates this is as good pizza has no experience with good pizza. They must live in another country, or they must live in South Florida, where the pizza is the worst in the country. Everyone has their preferences, and there are different styles of pizza, but it should never be a piece of cardboard. Typical South Florida low quality pizza. The only thing that makes it worse is that they want five dollars for a slice. I ordered a slice, I ate about a third of it, and I threw it away. And don’t be fooled by the Italian-sounding business name. Just awful low quality.
… moreCody K
This place has really great pizza! We went there over Christmas Break to Key West and was craving pizza. We were not disappointed! Pizza was great, employees were nice, & the price was as expected! They got you in & out pretty quickly. We will definitely be back!
… moreNichole Nichols
I ordered Angelina’s loaded with pineapple added and had it delivered to my hotel room. The pizza was delicious! Generous toppings, crispy crust on the bottom, arrived hot. My only gripe is the delivery driver ran out of my sodas and had to go to the store to get more which took 50 minutes. However I am choosing to rate the pizza itself because it was that good.
… moreRoger Cox
By the slice or by the pie.. the pizza is really good. Whole pizza takes about 15 minutes to make.. they get busy but no worries.. they keep things moving and orderly.
They have beer on tap, by the glass or by the pitcher. Seating is just outside.. usually you can find a spot to sit.
We had a simple pepperoni pie. Large was 33$ and could handle three adults easily. Nice sauce and the dough was delicious.
… moreThey have beer on tap, by the glass or by the pitcher. Seating is just outside.. usually you can find a spot to sit.
We had a simple pepperoni pie. Large was 33$ and could handle three adults easily. Nice sauce and the dough was delicious.
Charmy Patel
Angelina’s Pizzeria is, by far, the best pizza place I’ve ever been to. Not only do they serve incredible pizza, but they also offer gluten-free options, making it accessible for everyone. This place is very famous, and for good reason!
The location is great, adding to the overall experience. One of the best parts is the ability to customize your pizza with whatever toppings you desire. I highly recommend Angelina’s Pizzeria to any pizza lover out there!
… moreThe location is great, adding to the overall experience. One of the best parts is the ability to customize your pizza with whatever toppings you desire. I highly recommend Angelina’s Pizzeria to any pizza lover out there!