Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Andy’s Sub Shop | Hornell NY – Facebook
The special for today is a whole Italian sub for the low price of $10.50 plus tax! Our soup of the day is Potato Bacon! We have our daily specials available …
Andy’s Sub Shop 32 Seneca Street – Order Online
Get delivery or takeout from Andy’s Sub Shop at 32 Seneca Street in Hornell … Andy’s Sub Shop. 32 Seneca St, Hornell, NY 14843, USAOnline ordering hours …
Order Andy’s Sub Shop – Hornell, NY Menu Delivery [Menu & Prices]
Get delivery or takeout from Andy’s Sub Shop at 32 Seneca Street in Hornell. Order online and track your order live. No delivery fee on your first order!
Reviews
Laura Curtin
Honestly I used to love this place……
But the lack of signs and explanation or questions from workers when ordering subs ended up with my 6 year old having hot pepper relish on her sub.
I only ordered a turkey sub with mayo, cheese, lettuce, tomato.
… moreBut the lack of signs and explanation or questions from workers when ordering subs ended up with my 6 year old having hot pepper relish on her sub.
I only ordered a turkey sub with mayo, cheese, lettuce, tomato.
CHET LOWE
Andy’s is under new ownership and moved to 100 loader st. I eat there today. The taste of the ham sub took me in time to when I would order all the time when I was younger… Same great taste… It is 100% spot on !! I am truly a big fan….
… moreSteve Brewer
Love their subs,salad and brownies. The staff is always friendly and quick to get your food prepared for you.
… morecrash Nisbet
Unfortunately, I was not impressed with the Andy’s sub I received. The “whole sub” was only 10″ long. It wasn’t even big enough to share with my husband. I basically paid $12 for a half sub! The roll wasn’t very soft at all. I was told the roast beef was med rare, and as you can see it was anything but. There was hardly any meat on it at all also.
As anyone from this area knows, Andy’s has had a reputation for years in Hornell for the best subs! Unfortunately, the new owners haven’t quite lived up to the reputation. I’ll definitely be trying them again after giving them time to work it out.
… moreAs anyone from this area knows, Andy’s has had a reputation for years in Hornell for the best subs! Unfortunately, the new owners haven’t quite lived up to the reputation. I’ll definitely be trying them again after giving them time to work it out.
The Blue Whale (Gabe)
Absolutely delicious! This is a HUGE upgrade from their last location. Andy’s staff are very kind and accommodating. If you wan a real, quality sub, forget Subway or Wegmans. Andy’s Sub Shop is the place to go!
… moreMichelle W.
The best subs around….still, after so many years! It’s just the perfect combo- the tasty bread, the delicious meat, and the pepper relish. I was back in town visiting and I’m so glad it’s still the same here. It was a pleasure to chat with Connie!
… moreLauren S
Fast and tasty.
Lots of veg and tasty hot pepper sauce
… moreLots of veg and tasty hot pepper sauce
Neil Chevalier
The place is still good quality, but the prices jumped like 3 bucks since they moved from Loder St. I paid $9.72 (which is still way too high) for a half sub then. Now on Seneca i go in there and they wanted $12.54 for a HALF sub. That’s outrageous and i don’t see this place lasting much longer with prices like this. Hell, Subway offers a lunch DEAL with chips and drink for $6.99 why would i go back to Andy’s?
… morekeely olecharski
We just ordered large taco salads from here for the first time. They are fantastic! You get a huge amount for little price and everything was fresh. Service from person taking phone order to picking up was top notch! Highly recommend and definitely will be making it a regular order! Thanks for all your hard work!!!
… moreJake Pope
Stopped here during the eclipse for a quick lunch and we loved these sandwiches! Quality ingredients make all the difference and Andy’s understands that. The staff made great conversation with us which i always appreciate and a military discount was a nice cherry on top.
… more