Erika McMillen
We had a wonderful experience at this Italian restaurant! The food was delicious and tasted genuinely homemade, just like they promised. The service was warm and attentive, which made the meal even better. We tried the Works pizza and the Fettuccine Alfredo with mushrooms—both were outstanding. Highly recommend!
… moreDavid
Went past this place 100 times and finally stopped. Got garlic knots and a meat lovers pizza. Knots were ok, but the pizza was great. Staff was super friendly.
… moreCarol Gonzalez
If I can give them more than 5 stars, I definitely will! This place is 10/10. Their pasta is delicious, and the pizza is amazing ❤️ Sabine, our server, was excellent. Thanks!
… moreCarlevelyn VanOrmer
Had lunch today at Amore Mio pizzeria on CR 210 West. Best pizza I’ve had in a long time! Thin crust just the way I like it. Awesome service. Almost ate the whole pie. Argh.
… moreV T
Ordered 2 pizzas. Both were too salty. It’s not bad, but the salt ruined the whole thing. Could barely finish 2 slices. I hope they’ll go easier on the salt for future customers.
… moreChristine Tarpey
My 13 year-old insisted on writing a review and so here it is:
Absolutely delicious! The food was so good they make EVERYTHING from scratch and it is amazing! Even though the food took awhile it was totally worth the wait and our waitress Sabine was so nice to us. The atmosphere is very relaxing with the music and decorations. Only thing that’s missing is cushion for your back at the booth. Overall this place is amazing definitely worth the detour through the construction!
… moreJeannine Daly
Everything was excellent and the best I’ve had since leaving Jersey! Everything is made from scratch and with love, and it shows. Will absolutely be back. It was a little bit of a wait for the food, but trust me it’s worth it.
Got a Chicken parm sub & and a cheese pizza with half black olives
… moreKaren Davis
This little restaurant is right in the front of Shearwater where we live. We’ve often gotten take out of pizza but had yet to dine in and enjoy an entree. If you have had a similar experience, take the time to go in! Stacy was absolutely fantastic and the food was amazing. If you want wine, here are your options; each entree gets a free glass or if you want to enjoy more together, you can bring your own. Grab your opener and bring your favorite. It’s perfectly acceptable. The one thing I don’t suggest, as we did, is to just do take out without experiencing the staff and food when dining in. It’s so much better than the location represents.
… moreAshley Hamilton
This was our first time here and everything was great! Pizza and sub were delicious and the kids loved their pastas. The Caesar salad was especially good. You can tell everything is fresh made in house. We would definitely eat there again! It’s nice to find a new place the whole family enjoys.
… moreCeline Parot
Awesome pizza!!! I read some reviews and I wasn’t sure if I wanted to try this place but I am so glad that I did! Everything was homemade and so fresh! The Mediterranean salad was huge and well worth the money. I will definitely be back again soon!
… more