Eloise Lavacek
Overall, Amici provides a wonderful experience on all categories. The atmosphere inside is wonderful and there is a great ambiance. When you sit they give you some bread, nothing special but a nice touch. The servings on the entrees were big and each entree comes with a side salad. We tried 3 entrees all were good but nothing incredible. I would definitely recommend this place. I think it provides one of best experiences and food out of the Italian restaurants on main street. Would be great for date night.
… moreBiBi B
Our waitress was excellent! Super friendly and attentive, answered all our questions, and she was taking plates as we went so the table never filled up. Our food came out fast and we loved everything! We had the stuffed mushrooms, the eggplant parm panini, and the penne amici. It was all delicious. The waitress even refilled my drink without me having to ask. The bread was so good but the real star of the show was the olive oil! It was so good I had to ask the waitress what brand they used. I wanted to take the bottle home! ( I didn’t lol). The prices weren’t bad. There was a good range from 13-20+ so really not bad for 2025. I’d love to come back and try more of their menu.
… moreShirah Mark
Great food and atmosphere. I got the chicken salad and added avocado to it (2.50 upcharge). The chicken was fresh, but I will say I wish the salad was tossed since the toppings were just sitting on top of the leafy greens. My grandmother got the Caesar with salmon and she had no complaints. Our waiter was hilarious too. Will come back.
… moreMike H
The food is great, service has been excellent on each visit, very good portion sizes as well. We got the Penne ala vodka, salmon, French onion soup and chicken vegetable soup. Everything came out great. Atmosphere is pretty cool and modern.
… moreTerri S
The atmosphere is amazing.
My husband got the Monk Fish wrapped in bacon, I’ve never had it before and it was fantastic. A very unique taste. I got the salmon, and of course it was delicious. Highly recommend this restaurant. The staff is very tending and kind. Excellent all around.
… moreKashanna Hector
Food was delicious and gave large portions i had Watermelon martini delicious. Chicken parm with linguine noodles dessert big chocolate cake. Moist with just enough chocolate frosting. Our server Pete was the best. $$ Menu items
… moreAaron Davis
We had a group of about 30 people and the staff did a very good job serving us. The food was a 4.5 and wish there was that option. Our event was prepaid 4 course with open bar.
… moreAnge Amichia
Definitely 5 star dining and one of Middletown finest establishment. Service is amazing and people are super friendly. Now the food, on another level. My steak was cook perfect with so much season and flavor. Drinks were amazing. Couldn’t be happier knowing this amazing place is right in our hometown
… moreJessica Tattersall
I used to be a regular for many years, but after what I experienced on September 26th, I will never go to them again because of terrible service. I placed an order for my entire family for pick up and when I got home, I was missing a meal. I called back and they said they would refund me. A week goes by and I get no refund so I call back. They say they will refund me but now it’s been over two weeks and they still haven’t refunded me. They can keep that money because I’m posting this review and warning others of their bad service
… moreBrooke Chang (KMC’s Mom)
Lunch on Saturday with a group of 5. Great service, tasty food, good size portions. We weren’t rushed. This is the second time we have been here.
… more