Shem Ishler
Those boys are having fun making and serving pizza. They treat everyone like a friend who walks through the door, even the whackadoodles that frequent the neighborhood. The slices are hot and huge. It’s NY style, so don’t get in a tiff when you try getting a Chicago casserole slice.
… moreRayne Vieger
We ordered to go pizza while passing through town overnight. Really great New York style with the unique twist of sesame seeds on the crust. I’ve never had this before and we loved it!! The website makes it confusing which location you are ordering from, but luckily they are only about 5 minutes apart.
… moreMatt H. (TwoWay)
Finally, I will play my ace card. Fellas, let me reveal my identity: I am a New Yorker. Happy? I said it, and I will say it: as a New Yorker (20 years in the Big Apple, buddy), I can say with no little cred, that I know pizza. Oh yes.. Pizza snob? Hey! well.. mebe.
What’s the point? The point is that I can say with some authority that Americana is the best pizza in Boise.
Pro Tip: This cool building sits on a big wide blacktop, undivided parking, one wonders: where to land this Chevy? Seeing how I have only picked up pies to go, this hasn’t been an ish. But were I to finally have a big dine-in pizza party? Methinks Americana no setup for much table action…
Pro Tip: Are you MARRIED to BOTH your arms and legs? ‘Cause these delish pies might set you back half of those appendages.
THEME SONG: Rick Astley – Never Gonna Give You Up
… moreJustin Goar
I’ve watched a lot of One Bite reviews and I think Dave would easily give this an 8.1+. Perfectly cooked, great undercarriage, no flop.
… moreB Travel mom
Yum Yum Yum! Great pizza! A hidden little gem near the skate park. I like trying out new small businesses. This was a great surprise and love the pizza box. We got one medium one large pizza. Excellent ingredients. Very good crust.
… moreTaylor Sowle
If you’re wasting your money on chain pizza you’re doing it all wrong. Go support local and get yourself an amazing pizza at Americana! It’s a gem in Boise. The cost of a pie here is worth the quality you’re getting and there are a lot of places where that doesn’t happen.
… moreSamuel Duffey
I really liked the crust, it was crunchy and chewy, but it wasn’t heavy. Shouldn’t have worn a white t shirt to eat this on the way home.
Might be worth investing in a fly trap for the summer just because the door is always opening and closing is all.
… moreAshley Kay
Loved everything about it! Great service, delicious pizza, and a reasonable price. Excellent crust and marinara sauce. Fresh veggies. Will go back when we’re back in town.
… moreroger Norman
Love this place . My favorite pizza in Boise hands down. Crispy thin crust , sauce cheese and pepperoni in perfect balance . It’s my go to pizza
… moreMC Living
Phenomenal Vegan Pizza in Boise!
Stopped by Americana Pizza 9/14/25 and was blown away by their vegan pizza crispy, flavorful, and full of NYC-style goodness. So happy to see Boise offering amazing vegan options! Brandon, the owner, was super welcoming. If you’re in town and craving great pizza, this is the spot!
… more