Social Profile: ![]()
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
All Star Pizza – a local pizza restaurant serves Penfield and East Rochester NY. Voted as best pizza, sauce, and crust in Penfield our pizzeria has been committed to delicious food, quality ingredients, and convenient delivery. Select from our pizza menus and order online for delivery. We offer Penfield’s best New York Style Pizza along with chicken wings, subs, salads. Our full menu is available for delivery to your home or business 7 days a week. We also offer catering and can accommodate any size party from 10 people or more. Call us today and have an All Star dining experience! Visit our website for more details.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 1628 Penfield Rd, Rochester, NY 14625
Phone: (585) 385-2244
Website: https://www.allstar-pizza.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Reservations: allstar-pizza.com
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
All Star Pizza – Penfield NY Pizzeria, New York Style Pizza | East …
All Star Pizza offers the best New York style Thin Crust Pizza in Penfield NY. Pizza take-out and pizza delivery available! Make your selection and order …
All Star Pizza – Rochester, NY – 1628 Penfield Rd – Hours, Menu, Order
View the menu, hours, address, and photos for All Star Pizza in Rochester, NY. Order online for delivery or pickup on Slicelife.com.
All Star Pizza Penfield | Rochester NY – Facebook
All Star Pizza Penfield, Rochester. 3637 likes · 17 talking about this · 87 were here. Family owned BRICK OVEN, MADE TO ORDER PIZZERIA.
Reviews
J T
Great pizza and great service, no complaints. This place is NY pizza to a T; yeasty dough, tangy sauce, fresh cheese, fresh toppings (that they do not skimp on). You know you’re in the right place when you walk into a pizzeria that is 95% ovens and 5% walking space. I have zero complaints.
Go Bills.
… moreGo Bills.
Heather Hendrix
I love Mike and his staff. So friendly, nice, professional, and efficient. I’ve been picking up wings before the Bills game this season. Love the wings. Their website is so easy to use. You can order wings exactly the way you want them! They are always ready on time. The pick up is fun! Always greeted with a big smile! I haven’t had the pizza yet, but given the high praise in the reviews, I definitely will. Go Mike!!
… moreCynthia Love
I was craving a sub for lunch and I’ve been in search of the old school submarine sandwich that I remember having growing up. I’ve only been able to find it once recently, and that was about 2 hours out side of town. Although, the ham and cheese sub I had at All Star Pizza wasn’t 100% of what I am searching for, it was absolutely delicious. I walked in and ordered, sat at the counter to wait, which was only a few minutes. The employees were really friendly, and the atmosphere was clean. I recommend checking them out if you’re in the area.
… morePamela Foye
We have had some great pizzas here. Tonight we tried the Four cheese and were disappointed. It had no tomato sauce, just oily overcooked cheese. The cheese made the crust soggy and greasy. Will go back but not for the Four Cheese. Prices are now higher than website.
… moreRonald Reagan
This place serves very good pie. Not disappointed at all. Just enough toppings and sauce. Great! New York style pizza won’t be fooled from the outside. Unbelievable
… moreRyley Phoenix-Hunt
Nicest pizza guys I’ve ever encountered. Extremely friendly and professional. Incredible pizza, and I’m picky. Super quick service, convenient location and easy parking. Nice part of town. Cannot go wrong with All Star Pizza! Thank you for making my tough night better by paying it forward.
I went around 9:30 on a Saturday night. Thank you so much for the two nice men that assisted me.
… moreI went around 9:30 on a Saturday night. Thank you so much for the two nice men that assisted me.
Alison Rothfuss
Burnt my boneless wings. They were suppose to be with medium sauce, this clearly isn’t the color of medium sauce. What a waste of money. Won’t be ordering here again. I used to get pizza quite frequently and it was always fine, but now I won’t be getting anything from here again.
… moreLabel 7 Napa Eatery & Bar
Don’t listen to the people talking about wrong coupons or getting the wrong order, because that’s normal for small business. Honest mistakes are normal in this world. The bottom line is the food here is good and the people are great; support your small businesses!!!
… moreLouisa Sanchez
We drive all the way from Irondequoit to get their pizza. It is seriously the best in Rochester. Its very similar to NYC pizza. Go check them out. You won’t regret it.
… moreDwight Roeters
I had a coupon from the weekly Clipper flyer for a large cheese pizza and 10 wings for a price of $15.75. The coupon said it was a $31.50 value. When I got there and showed the guy at the counter the coupon, he rang up the bill and said it was something like $35 or $37 dollars. He then said the coupon was some kind of mistake. I don’t know if the guy at the counter was the owner or just some other idiot who was told to treat customers that way, but it is false advertising. I just ordered the pizza, which by the way was very good. This place now needs to be boycotted until they make things right … shame on them. A total lack of customer service.
… more