DAVE KITTO
I cannot say enough about this place!!
1/2 lb burger w fries for 8$
And it was piping hot, flavorful & absolutely delicious. The bag of fries was enough for two people and the same way ..extremely hot.
this was my first time here and I will definitely be going back.. so many choices
… moreMitchel Morrison
For food, the quality of ingredients, especially meats & cheeses, puts Algonquin Sub Shop one distinctive notch above the bland corporate drag on Randall. The smoked gouda on my Smoke Stack and the melted cheesy beef was top notch. There’s your choice of over twenty types of Italian style subs. At first bite, you can tell the sub rolls are baked fresh daily. There’s that true Italian sub crunch of the pickle and lettuce. The subs hit the spot like torpedos. In terms of service, you’re greeted warmly and called by name instead of the vacuous indifference of droids yelling numbers. This is what makes a beloved local business different from just another corporate franchise. As someone from Algonquin, I respect the fact this business has weathered 35 years of economic turbulence with their uncompromising commitment to quality and friendly Midwest service. Bottom line: premium sandwiches in an inauspicious, lower traffic location off IL route 31 instead of the roaring eight lanes of Randall. The atmosphere offers both indoor and outdoor seating and unique, seasonal decor, like a fun candy corn pumpkin turkey in the photo. Happy Fall y’all.
… moreVeronica Kulik
My boyfriend raves about this sub shop. He was ordering lunch for us and I ordered a salad. Absolutely stunning, delicious, fresh salad. (California Fusion – highly recommend). When they say gourmet on the menu, they mean it! Great flavors!
… moreLucas Kalios
It has been over a decade since the last time I’ve been here. And I have to say it’s absolutely amazing food just like I remember it! What an awesome local gem! And I once again got so excited for the food I forgot to take pictures! Soo now you will have to come here and experience excellence for yourself!
… moreOwen Lawson
I tried the Veggie soup along with the Al Capone Sub, and both dishes were packed with amazing flavor. I am already excited to return and explore more of the subs on their menu.
… moreV Rom
I’ve driven past Algonquin Sub Shop for over 10 years and always wanted to stop in—but somehow never did until today. And wow… it was so worth the wait.
Tracy rang us up and she was absolutely wonderful—super sweet, thoughtful, and welcoming. She went above and beyond to make our family feel comfortable and never pressured while ordering. Her energy was top-notch and truly made the experience.
The food was fantastic, and the soups were especially delicious—so warm and homey. This place has such a comforting, welcoming vibe.
We loved it and it’s easily becoming one of our favorites. Highly recommend!
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
… moreSandra Boltryk
The best sandwich is salad you will have in your life…full stop. I get a togo order every weekend because it’s that’s good and you crave it. Nothing fancy-just good food!
… moreLexi
Been wanting to try this place for a while… so glad we finally decided too! Me and my husband absolutely LOVED it! Their fries were so fresh, crispy, and seasoned well.. sooo good. And the sandwiches were amazing!!! They use the best bread.. which in my opinion makes or breaks a sandwich. I love the fact they are a small family owned business. Makes it that much better. This will definitely be a staple for us moving forward. The people there are so nice as well 🙂 SUPPORT SMALL FAMILY OWNED BUSINESSES!!
… moreMatylda Iskra
Tried them for the first time the other day and wow… their subs are seriously SO good!! I got the California and it was just perfect. You can tell they use fresh ingredients. The fries were also really good. Super crispy and seasoned!
… moreCary Hughes
An OUTSTANDING sub!!! Loved the fries, too. Very fresh and unique spot for sure. The special, the Pesto Chicken, was phenomenal!!!
… more