Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 2095 Smizer Station Rd, Fenton, MO 63026
Phone: (636) 225-6175
Website: http://www.pieomypizzastl.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Order Pie O My Pizza – Fenton, MO Menu Delivery [Menu & Prices]
Get delivery or takeout from Pie O My Pizza at 2095 Smizer Station Road in Fenton. Order online and track your order live. No delivery fee on your first …
Pie O My Pizza – CLOSED, 2095 Bentley Plz, Fenton, MO 63026, US
Get more information for Pie O My Pizza in Fenton, MO. See reviews, map, get the address, and find directions.
Pie O’ My Pizza
Our menu · Ham & Mushroom Pizza. Our famous tomato base, fior di latte mozzarella, smoked ham, sliced closed-cup mushroom and topped with hot honey. · Italiana …
Reviews
Tony Polizzi
I’ve tried Pie O My a few times in the past and I felt like the hand tossed pizza crust/dough was thicker. This one was a little flat. Crust was somewhat chewy and bland. Moz cheese was good and so we’re the toppings.
Overall I’m not a massive fan of the pizza, the hand tossed reminded me of pizza hut thin crust. It is not bad pizza, but it just isn’t 27$ for a three topping good. For $3 dollars more I can get a large pizza from Mellow Mushroom with a greater variety, amount, and quality of toppings. Also with a much thicker hand tossed crust.
4 stars for friendly and genuine service. The seemingly undying motivation of improving their products as seen on STL pizza connoisseurs. And because in the past it was very good. Will be back in a few months to see how things are going.
… moreOverall I’m not a massive fan of the pizza, the hand tossed reminded me of pizza hut thin crust. It is not bad pizza, but it just isn’t 27$ for a three topping good. For $3 dollars more I can get a large pizza from Mellow Mushroom with a greater variety, amount, and quality of toppings. Also with a much thicker hand tossed crust.
4 stars for friendly and genuine service. The seemingly undying motivation of improving their products as seen on STL pizza connoisseurs. And because in the past it was very good. Will be back in a few months to see how things are going.
Debbie Schou
This is a small business. I went in there last night to get pizza for my kids. We have been waiting for this place to open, and it did not disappoint! The wait was long, but you could tell that they were trying very hard to accommodate. As a new business, it’s typical to try to figure out the ebb and flow of things. I noticed several people being rude to the employees. Some things are out of their control when it comes to running out of supplies. I wish more people were kind, and empathetic. I would definitely give this place a try, it’s a great establishment, and that pizza was top notch as were the garlic bread bites. I’m sure as time goes on, they will know the supplies to stock for business needs. Let’s all practice a little more patience. I was disgusted by the attitudes of customers coming in. I’m excited to see newer restaurants opening in Fenton, especially coming off the pandemic. Five stars! ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️
… moreLeandra Kohnen
I had their pizza a few weeks ago and it was delicious! Today I tried the Oh My Italian sandwich for lunch and it was phenomenal! I highly recommend Pie O My Pizza!
… moreDamien Smith
Tried Pie O My in Fenton for dinner tonight. It is really good pizza! Definitely worth trying! Sorry for the bites before the photo- it smelled too good to wait.
… moreAlexis Hendrickson
Omg this the type of pizza I’ve been craving near STL. I ordered extra light pizza, a little well done #chefskiss.
Well priced and the guys at the shop (especially Master G) were very helpful and friendly
… moreWell priced and the guys at the shop (especially Master G) were very helpful and friendly
Dan Kraus
7.5/10 pizza but gave 5 stars to support a small business.
Pros: Staff greeted me with a smile and friendly attitude . Toppings were very fresh even though I placed my order less than an hour till close. The char on the crust was almost perfect! The outer crust was very light and fluffy. The price was very reasonable. ~$22 for a large meat lovers is pretty darn good.
Cons: The center was thin, doughy, top of center was undercooked , and overloaded with toppings.
Very uneven shape and cut. No two slices were the same size.
If they had a proper pizza maker I feel like this could have been my favorite pizza in STL.
I understand the owners are new to pizza. Hopefully they can work through the growing pains. I see a bunch of potential. Night and day better than anything the big chains have to offer!
… morePros: Staff greeted me with a smile and friendly attitude . Toppings were very fresh even though I placed my order less than an hour till close. The char on the crust was almost perfect! The outer crust was very light and fluffy. The price was very reasonable. ~$22 for a large meat lovers is pretty darn good.
Cons: The center was thin, doughy, top of center was undercooked , and overloaded with toppings.
Very uneven shape and cut. No two slices were the same size.
If they had a proper pizza maker I feel like this could have been my favorite pizza in STL.
I understand the owners are new to pizza. Hopefully they can work through the growing pains. I see a bunch of potential. Night and day better than anything the big chains have to offer!
Jason Clark
The hand tossed crust is excellent! Beyond any expectations. Generous toppings and the provel, mozzarella blend is my personal favorite. We ordered sausage and pepperoni and it did not disappoint. Extra large pepperoni, and perfectly seasoned sausage. Can’t wait to get back for another Pie!! This place is a gem.
… moreShar Mae
We loved the flakey thin crust pepperoni/sausage pie. We will definitely be back to try the hand-tossed
… moreScott Cisco
First visit tonight but won’t be our last. Really friendly staff! We ordered a 16″ meat lovers hand tossed pizza that was so good.
Crust had an excellent crunch without being tough! It had strips of crispy bacon. Overall very good and we will be ordering again!
… moreCrust had an excellent crunch without being tough! It had strips of crispy bacon. Overall very good and we will be ordering again!
Lou Mayes
I ordered the meat lovers pizza with green peppers, onions, and mushrooms online. I paid with my credit card. I drove to Pie O My Pizza to get my pizza and they said they didn’t have my order. They wanted proof and I opened my email and there was a message and it said they couldn’t honor my order. I then opened my text messages and it said they were out of stock and couldn’t honor my order. With this information, the order taker said they could make the pizza with a 20 miinute wait. They were right on time with my pizza and I paid for it with the same credit card that I used on line. The big disappointment was the pizza itself and the almost $30.00 I paid for a 14”. The sauce was good with plenty of cheese and 6 large pepperonis and that is where it stopped. I couldn’t find the bacon or ham. There was a small portion of sausage, maybe 8 slivers of green pepper and onion with no trace of mushrooms. The final disappointment was the topping didn’t go to the edge but was 1 1/2”-2” from the edge. If you took the 1 1/2” to be conservative and subtracted it from the 14” all the way around, I got a 11” pizza for almost $30.00.
Don’t think I will be back, to many problems.
… moreDon’t think I will be back, to many problems.