Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Enduring source for thin-crust pizzas & American pub eats in a classic tavern setting.
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Menu | Tilley’s Pizza House | Ballyhoo Tavern
Tilley’s Pizza House | Ballyhoo Tavern -. Tilley’s Pizza House | Ballyhoo Tavern. 900 4th Street Beloit WI 53511. 608-362-0241 [email protected]. Links.
Tilley’s Pizza House | Ballyhoo Tavern
The best pizza in Beloit plus a whole lot more! Our family has been making mouth-watering pizzas to order since 1955. Our crispy and thick crust pizzas are …
Lunch – Dinner – Beloit – Tilley’s Pizza House
Wisconsin Food Safety Agencies advise that eating raw or undercooked meat, poultry, eggs, or seafood poses a health risk to everyone, but especially to the …
Reviews
Ashley Yaldo
Went here on a Saturday afternoon and it was nice a place. The population who were present was mostly older but that didn’t bother me. The waitress was very friendly and the place was clean, which I appreciated.
I decided to get a “thick” crust pizza and it was just okay. Nothing memorable if I’m being honest. I also ordered cheese curds as an appetizer and they were fine. Standard cheese curds again. I wasn’t a huge fan of the marinara sauce. The rating of the place really comes down to if I would want to eat there again, and it truly was not memorable enough to go back with what I had ordered.
… moreI decided to get a “thick” crust pizza and it was just okay. Nothing memorable if I’m being honest. I also ordered cheese curds as an appetizer and they were fine. Standard cheese curds again. I wasn’t a huge fan of the marinara sauce. The rating of the place really comes down to if I would want to eat there again, and it truly was not memorable enough to go back with what I had ordered.
Jim Ucce.
I Moved to Harvard from the city, I’ve been looking for a Chicago deep dish pizza and I think I found it here at Tillys . I ordered the 10″peperoni with extra sauce parmesan crust it was great the sauce was tasty. I ordered extra sauce, it didn’t really need it. Pepperoni was good. The atmosphere is great the service was great. Price for 2 beers and a small Deep Dish pizza $26.00. I recommend it.
… moreJennifer Davis
Best lunch deal in town and excellent pizza! Small one topping pizza and a soda for $7.00 (extra for extra toppings, but super reasonable prices). Great atmosphere, clean and great service too.
… moreKaren Denoto
We ordered delivery tuesday. We ordered pizza and a shrimp/fish entre. It was the worst meal i have ever had from tilley’s. The pizza was overdone and no sauce on it. The fish and shrimp was was overdone. The fries were cold and tasted like they had been sitting (greassy). What is happening with their great food and delicious pizza? DeNoto family
… moreGary Myers
Thin crust with sausage and mushrooms. Good…I’d not say great. I love a great pizza place, not the “fast food” variety…this was probably a 6 out of 10. Fries were very good though! Price was reasonable
… morecrickett evitt
More times than not their broasted chicken is terribly over cooked. Dry meat, flavorless coating and burned to a crisp. Very disappointing from the home of the inventor of the Broaster.
… moreChicago Mut
If this is Beloit’s best pizza then Beloit needs help.
The crust was tasty but where’s the sauce? Maybe it’s just a Chicago thing but the basis of every pizza should be crust, Red Sauce, and mozzarella ; without those three in ingredients it’s not pizza it’s something else.
… moreThe crust was tasty but where’s the sauce? Maybe it’s just a Chicago thing but the basis of every pizza should be crust, Red Sauce, and mozzarella ; without those three in ingredients it’s not pizza it’s something else.
Doug Pierard
Burgers to pizza to broasted chicken, full bar and plenty of appetizers.
… moreMichael Jaber
Tilley’s Pizza is amazing. I love the thin crust and flavor of the cheese. The inside is very nice with plenty of seating. Their shrimp and burgers are also very good. It’s definitely worth the trip!!
… morePenny Kennedy
Ordered carryout. I got home and they gave me a medium mushroom pizza which was supposed to be pepperoni. I called and if I want to bring it back they would exchange it. They aren’t giving credits at this time??? I didn’t order that!!
… more