John Drews
Got a cheeseburger plate on rolls. Haven’t had stevie’s in years. It didn’t disappoint. Just wish there was more hot sauce.
… moreI Am Jackpot
The best garbage plate in Rochester, NY, can be found at Steve T’s Hots & Potatoes on Lyell Ave. Originally known as Nick Tahou’s II when it opened in 1979, the restaurant changed its name to Steve T’s in 2007. For over 47 years, they’ve been serving some of the best burgers, hots, and plates in town. While everyone has their favorite spot, this is mine. Out of all the plates across the city, Steve T’s just does it best, in my opinion. The meat hot sauce is perfect, and the potatoes are always crispy. The staff is friendly, and the classic atmosphere of this iconic location just can’t be beat. That’s why Steve T’s Hots & Potatoes is the best! If you’re in the area, definitely check them out and grab some of the best food in town. #stevets #erikandamerica #garbageplate #rochesterny #food #travel #history
… morePeter J.
Went there tonight and ordered “The Plate” which they’re supposedly famous for. It was ok at best. The macaroni salad was tasteless and the home fries are deep fried which really ruined any potential for the plate all together. The meat sauce is good but not the best I’ve ever had. We ordered the Cheeseburger ones and noticed the burgers are already pre cooked as they smacked them back on the grill as a reheat. This is pure laziness on the cooks part and it affects quality which is a huge turn off. This place is supposedly a take off of the original Nick Tahous on Main St. and I believe it’s a Family Member of the same but can’t use the trademarked “Garbage Plate”. Anyhow, go there during the day if you really must visit. It’s in a sketchy neighborhood just outside the City Line. I think at night I wouldn’t feel safe. I won’t rush back as it didn’t deliver what I had expected. . If you would like to try a real good version of the Plate, I’d definitely recommend Tom Wahls in Avon and don’t waste your time here. Their version is called the Junker Plate. Much better and worth the drive and it’s $2.00 more and a great environment too. Easy to get to off 390 Exit 10.
… moreRorie Merz
All we kept hearing from the locals was, you have to get a garbage plate.
On a Sunday in Rochester that’s easier said than done
Steve T,s was the only place out of the 5 that were recommended that was open
Worker at the counter went over the 101 of how to order a garbage plate ….kind of a confusing and not clear
Got the standard cheeseburger plate with Mac salad, onion and brown mustard and a separate white hot sandwich
The “white hot” ended up on the garbage plate? Confused
I guess this is something you have to grow up with…or drunk to enjoy. I get what it is, carb overload, but for all the stuff on it, it lacked flavor and salt. Just a big plate of bland stuff all smashed together. The best part was the white bread and butter.
Onion rings were solid.
I can say I had one and check that off my culinary list of hyper regional food. No desire to check that box again IMOP
… moreDiana Kirk
What is the allure of this garbage plate? It’s gross. Not just not good but actually gross. We stopped eating it halfway thru. The meat sauce was the worst. Why do locals recommend this,
… moreMichelle Barletta
The server that early morning hour smiled was friendly, professional and provided great service. Although she had a migraine headache. We’ve all been there. I had some medicine in my bag cuz I just got off a plane and I shared it with her and it made me feel so good to help her feel better. You will always remain in my heart. May you have a happy holiday season
… moreGayle Fleming
What happened to the hot sauce. It was very dry and disgusting. The hots were like rubber undercooked. The hamburgers were ice cold. Will not go there anymore. The burgers were also alit smaller. What happened to the quality that we always looked forward to? There were 2 younger girls one who didn’t know what she was doing and the other spoke broken English, hard to understand. I hope they up their game soon!
… moreGail Schuler
Born and raised in Rochester. Had garbage plates our whole lives and always LOVED them. Moved away 25 yrs ago and have a tradition of stopping for a plate every time we come home for a visit. We always look forward to it; actually get excited, until today.
What happened to the food?!?! It was completely disappointing! Hot sauce, macaroni salad, both tasteless, potatoes mediocre. The burgers were ok but thinner than usual. Never had to add anything before but these needed Frank’s Red Hot, extra mustard, and several other additions just to choke it down. The only reason we ate any of it was because we were so hungry and hate wasting food and money. I wouldn’t have fed this to my dog! We won’t be back, which is really disappointing. We’ll have to find a new place for garbage plates.
… moreDanielle Meehan
Lived in Rochester for 20 years and few things feel more like home than a garbage plate. Hasn’t changed. Still delicious and still one of my favorite meals when visiting home.
… moreAngela Farda
This was my first garbage plate & it was huge. Service was excellent, ladies at the counter were patient and helpful. My friends and I agreed the French fries/hash browns need seasoning. Also wished they were crispy. Meat sauce was bland. Overall, service was fast and the price is fair for the amount of food you get.
… more