Teakeyman
I had such a great experience at Blue Moon Pizza! From the moment we walked in, the atmosphere felt warm and comfortable — the kind of place where you can just relax and enjoy yourself. The food was absolutely amazing; every bite was fresh, flavorful, and perfectly prepared.
What really made the visit stand out, though, was our waitress. I didn’t catch her name but she had short blond hair. She was truly wonderful — attentive without being overbearing, friendly, and genuinely made us feel welcome. She took the time to answer questions, kept everything flowing smoothly, and added such a positive energy to the whole experience.
Between the incredible food, the inviting atmosphere, and the top-notch service, Blue Moon Pizza has easily become one of my new favorite spots. I’ll definitely be coming back and recommending it to friends!
… moreMatthew Scully
Today was my girlfriend and I first time trying Blue Moon Pizza off Windy Hill Road. The staff was so incredibly friendly and polite and quick to accommodate us. Our server Ms. Melissa was so sweet and attentive and out standing. She did a wonderful job and was polite and had amazing timing on bringing out our drinks and food. My girlfriend and I got the BBQ chicken pizza Sicilian styled. It was honestly a perfect pizza. Great taste and a beautiful crust on it. We had a lovely super early dinner and will definitely be coming back here in the future. Thank you to the caring staff at Blue Moon Pizza y’all were awesome!!
… moreNavzy Pal
Service was good but food wasn’t upto the mark !
Red velvet cheesecake was the driest here I ever had compared to other places
Calzone had too much balsamic vinegar& oil underneath it
Stromboli with the choice of toppings had cooked alrite but didn’t have a appealing crust or design & again a lot of oil beneath it
… moreDom B
LISTEN….Tony and Jessica are absolutely AMAZING. The service is top notch and the food is delicious. My sister and I were actually going to a different spot in the area but we met Tony outside and he greeted us and welcomed us inside as if Blue Moon was where we belonged. He sat us at the bar and he and Jessica tag teamed on our drinks and they provided great recommendations for pizza and wings. Overall, 10/10 we will be back again.
… moreYong Choi
The pizza was okay—definitely edible, but a bit saltier than I remember from previous visits. Still, the flavor was decent and the crust had a nice texture. Price-wise, it’s reasonable for a gourmet-style pizza restaurant. What really stood out was the service—the staff were super friendly and made the experience enjoyable. Worth a visit if you’re in the area and craving pizza with a welcoming vibe.
… moreAngela Smith
Pizza is just pre cooked cheese pizza with toppings warmed on top. I’d preferred the toppings be cooked with pizza. but nice staff.
… moreSylvia McAllister
My coworkers and I went to Blue Moon for lunch today; there was a total of 4 of us. The waitress acknowledged us quickly and took our orders. Two of us (including myself) ordered a slice of pizza with a Cobb salad. When the food was delivered to our table, we were told someone dropped both salads and they had to be remade. The waitress was very kind and apologetic and advised us it would take another 8 minutes to remake…no problem at all. Twenty minutes passed before she returned to our table to tell us the salads were now being remade and the manager had agreed to take 20% off in addition to the 10% military discount. We were on our lunch break and by this time, the other two had finished their meals. Moments later, a coworker walked to the front and asked if the salads could be made to go and dressing put on the side. She returned to the table and we waited a few minutes longer. I then walked to the front and asked for the manager. The waitress pointed him out, he was at the counter still making our salads. (It’s important to point out while we were waiting, other customers’ food was being delivered.)I proceeded to tell the manager, I no longer wanted the salad. Long story short, the manager let us know that he would not comp the salads because I said I no longer wanted it….as if they didn’t drop the salads and forget to remake them. Needless to say, 2 of us left without lunch. If this is how you train your managers to handle these types of situations , you will lose a lot more customers than you did today.
… moreJamie Allen
Katie was amazing! My team and i frequently come here for lunch and she always takes care of us. Food is just as good as her customer service! Keep up the excellent work!
… moreTherese Steele
Our server Takoa was amazing. She was on it and made us feel very welcome (including giving “new locals” some suggestions for the area). Now onto the food. Phe-nom-enal. We started with the garlic rolls and holy yum. Definitely get those. My husband got the buffalo chicken pizza and it was top notch. He’s a snooty pizza guy, and said it’s the best one he’s had! I had the hot honey pepperoni and it was a unique, delightful option! Also, drinks are *chef’s kiss*
Side note: our neighbor got the meatballs topped with ricotta and I will be adding that to my choice for the next time we come.
Come! You won’t regret it.
… moreHainalka Banfi
The quality of their pizza went down, but the price went up. Last 3 times the taste and the overall experience just wasn’t there. The pizza is flappy, the dough is too soft and no salt and pepper on the crust as their signature touch. I’ve been getting pizza from Blue Moon for ages. Different locations sometimes, but the Marietta store is the closest to me. I always get the same. Santa Fe personal size. The avocado on my pizza was very bad looking, old and brown almost black in color already. Other times was always fresh and green. I was disappointed in the quality. I believe my loyalty to them came to the end.
… more