Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Relaxed counter-serve chain dishing up giant thin-crust, NY-style slices & pies till the wee hours.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 1906 E Carson St, Pittsburgh, PA 15203
Phone: (412) 709-6077
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Benny Fierro’s
Working hard? Hardly working? You deserve a 28” pizza from Benny Fierro’s in Pittsburgh, PA. Located in South Side, we are open late and it’s BYOB.
Benny Fierro’s | Pittsburgh PA – Facebook
love is in the air… heart shaped pizzas with breadstick arrows available for valentines day! call and get your preorders in. #bennyspizza #bennyfierros # …
Benny Fierro’s (@bennyfierros) · Pittsburgh, PA – Instagram
sunday – thursday: 11am – 12am friday – saturday: 11am – 2am …
Reviews
Matt Ruffell
Good thin crust pizza made from a large 28 inch pizza dough. It has a strong underlying parmesan flavor and pairs well with hot sauce. I wish the crust was a bit more firm. It reminds me of a typical college town pizza place that serves up slices all hours of the night. Most people would think it is average tasting pizza, but I bet the college crowd treasures it.
… moreRon Branch II
The pizza was very good. Chewy crust, not too greasy, and the slices were HUGE. My son and I both ordered 2 slices of pepperoni, but we each were only able to eat one. Each slice was 6 bucks, which I thought was a good deal. The guys manning the counter were polite and helpful, and we got our pizza in under 10 minutes.
… moreSmokin’ Barrel Barbeque
Visiting Pittsburgh and had this on our list to try! So good! So worth it!!! Our crew devoured the biggest pizza we ever had! That ranch, so good!!
… moreaf *
I’m revamping my pizza reviews.. here goes:
(These are all based on a scale of 1-5, with 1 being the worst and 5 the best.) i like a thin crust, they nailed it! bonus points for perfect amount of pizza juice. Perfect sized crust. Thank you for NOT using sandwich pepperoni on your pizza slice. Flavorful cheese. Great pizza! Delicious!!
Thickness of the dough: 5 nice and thin
Crust thickness:4 decent
Toppings ratio: 5
Crispiness: 3
Flavor: 5 all around-good ingredients!!
Price: 5
Size: 5+
Crust overall: 5
Freshness:5
The only thing i can ding them on is atmosphere. That said- The 2 guys working were great!! Kind and helpful! I hope the money not invested into the appearance of the pizza joint is going straight into their employees pay! No air conditioning, benches are torn and tattered, springs broken. Not the cleanest restaurant you’d want to eat in .Wobbly benches. I guess you could say this is a well loved pizza place and it shows?
… more(These are all based on a scale of 1-5, with 1 being the worst and 5 the best.) i like a thin crust, they nailed it! bonus points for perfect amount of pizza juice. Perfect sized crust. Thank you for NOT using sandwich pepperoni on your pizza slice. Flavorful cheese. Great pizza! Delicious!!
Thickness of the dough: 5 nice and thin
Crust thickness:4 decent
Toppings ratio: 5
Crispiness: 3
Flavor: 5 all around-good ingredients!!
Price: 5
Size: 5+
Crust overall: 5
Freshness:5
The only thing i can ding them on is atmosphere. That said- The 2 guys working were great!! Kind and helpful! I hope the money not invested into the appearance of the pizza joint is going straight into their employees pay! No air conditioning, benches are torn and tattered, springs broken. Not the cleanest restaurant you’d want to eat in .Wobbly benches. I guess you could say this is a well loved pizza place and it shows?
Izabel Rue
I come here all the time and its always a great experience, everyone is always super nice besides one person. Everyone is always super nice and polite, but she is very cold and standoffish everytime. If it’s a one off I understand, but it’s every time she’s on the other side of the counter. Unsure of her name but brown hair with glasses
… moreAllegra Pierce
I ate here while visiting Pittsburgh for a wedding . The wedding hosts served Bennys large boxes of pizza at their rehearsal dinner and they are truly massive (I’d never seen them before being from out of town) , it was a great idea for a party. I came by the store in south side flats to grab a slice the next day. I ordered the Italian sausage slice. For the price ($6) it’s a great lunch option- very filling and tasty.
… moreNicholas Basile
I finally gave this place a try and it totally lived up to the hype. Don’t be intimidated by the price — you get what you pay for, both in quality and quantity. The employees were friendly and the pizza was ready in short time. This is a nice New York style pizza — the pepperoni wasn’t my favorite (a bit flimsy and lacking flavor; the sausage was a marginally superior topping) but this place is still great and worth trying in my opinion.
… moreKeith
Benny Fiero’s is no doubt fire ! The slices are literally massive, the cheese the right balance of flavor and “feel”, and the crust is thin and Goldilocks crispy, just right! The spot is a neat old building with tall ceilings and cozy window front seating. Good vibes and great customer service. Plus the prices are a steal, 6 bucks for what is easily 2.5 normal slices. Benny’s is unforgettable, one slice and you’re hooked!
… moreTony Oddera
Guys were great here, friendly and accommodating. As far as the pizza, this is definitely a case of bigger is not better. Pizza is all flop no firm at all. Looking at the undercarriage is light, the outter crust no char at all, so no crispness in any bite or crunch at the end. Looking at the cross section you can see at times some of the dough is not thoroughly cooked so when eating it, it’s a little doughy at times even though it’s thin crust. At $6 a slice and $45 a pie with two sodas this is a pass with so many other better pizza options in Pittsburgh.
… moreS T (LLA__EVOL)
LOOK! What an amazing place and huge and delicious pizza! A hidden gem
… more