Suzette Briner
Went on a Thursday Bus Trip. First time to PIB. It was suggested by a friend’s daughter who bartends on the Island. Glad we did! It was super reasonable and I keep saying that hot dog was the highlight of the day! The other 3 got the Sloppy Scotty and enjoyed theirs as well. They didn’t have table service ( sign on table) and had to order at the bar. The bar was pretty busy but we got our order in and delivered pretty quickly. Definitely a place to check out!
… moreDaniel Happ
This place was great. Small little hole in the wall bar. We needed something fast for our kids and they provided just that. Hots dogs were great and would highly recommend the loaded dog with bacon! Yum! We happened to stumble upon put in bay and will hopefully be returning one day!
… moretRic Ster
As advertised……five star dive bar! Great place, our favorite bar on the island. Come hungry, the food is great! Smell the barbecue and it’ll make you hungry!! Nice folks great service. Just plain cool. You’ve got to love a dive bar with clean nice bathroom’s.
… moreYvonne Edwards
The bar was ok but the bartenders weren’t real friendly. The margaritas were good but they are known for their Bloody Mary’s and I didn’t like it at all. The food was subpar. Still probably the best dive bar in town. The location is good because it’s away from downtown and unique to the area.
… moreTool Man
Wild place. Fun atmosphere. I’m glad the weather was nice otherwise we would’ve had to have waited for a table, but it is Put-In-Bay, Right?
… moreKevin Mccausland
Great friendly environment. Thinking about making the trip again this summer. Is the neighbor Jerry still around? He was a blast!!!
… moreMorgan
Fun dive bar. Great décor. 1800’s cemetery across the street. Smaller menu. I had Eddie’s Bid Bad Bratwurst and my friends had the fried pickles, and burger. The Bratwurst was great it came with chips that were also great. I was told the burgers were juicy and the pickles were good as well.
… moreAmber Funke
Wish we would have found this place on our first day instead our last. Cheapest drinks on the island!
… moreMatt Smith
Patrons are very helpful and friendly people. The patio was fun. If you don’t want to use Port a Potties don’t go here. Nothing wrong with them if they are cleaned. I’d give the place a 3.5. I didn’t rate the food because we didn’t eat anything.
… moreJeff W
Definitely a dive bar. Sat at the bar for lunch, the bar (and bathroom) didn’t really appear that clean. I had the Sloppy Joe. It was a good sandwich at a very good value for the island. Fried foods were not available that day.
Could have been much better had I not had to listen to the conversations of the employees on their period amongst other things while I was eating. Other than, that adequate service.
… more