New York Pasta Garden

by

  4.4 – 1,406 reviews   • Italian restaurant

Social Profile:

New York Pasta Garden is a romantic Italian restaurant in the heart of Key West near to Duval street, offering pasta, fresh local seafood, and an award-winning wine list. Known for its intimate outdoor garden seating with magical fairy lights, we create the perfect setting for date nights, anniversaries, and unforgettable dinners on Duval Street. Enjoy classic Italian cuisine, lobster ravioli, seafood risotto, chicken parmesan, and premium wines in a charming tropical oasis. NEW OPEN FOR LUNCH Join us for Italian best lunch near downtown. Enjoy fresh pasta, Italian sandwiches, crisp salads, and classic appetizers. Lunch specials and bottomless Sangria’s. Best Italian Sandwiches & Subs and atmosphere.

Cozy place for basic breakfasts, lunch menu with pizza & sandwiches, & Italian fare for dinner.

✔️Breakfast ✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery New York Pasta Garden 33040

Menu Photos

doordash.com

Photo Gallery

Related Web Results

New York Pasta Garden

Use tab to navigate through the menu items. Wix Facebook page · Yelp Social Icon · Instagram Social Icon · Trip Advisor Social Icon.

New York Pasta Garden – Key West, FL – 1075 Duval St – Hours …

New York Pasta Garden is currently located at 1075 Duval St. Order your favorite eats all with the click of a button. (305) 767-4771.

Dinner Menu | New York Pasta

Dinner Menu · From The Ocean · Lobster Ravioli – 36.95. Jumbo lobster Ravioli’s are tossed with a saute of fresh lobster, smoky · Stuffed Florida Lobster Tail ~ …

Last Updates

Reviews

AR & J
Located in a quaint quiet little spot just off Duval and Virginia street. The food was phenomenal!!! Service was exemplary!!! Welcoming friendly and informative we were greeted by the owner who was a wealth of information on the area and history. The wine was perfectly paired with our meals, everything was fresh flavourful and cooked to perfection. He adjusted my ingredients to allow for a garlic sensitivity without a second thought. Desert was amazing especially the Limoncello cake!!! We will be back for certain!
… more
Elmo Bluffer
Donna our server was excellent , she’s from Brooklyn, been here 30 years, a great host. Our food was amazing, meatballs, french onion soup, lobster ravioli all tremendous! As a European visiting the keys this was really great, I hope one day I’m lucky enough to return!
… more
Stacy R
Absolutely LOVE this place, it truly is a hidden gem. From the food to the atmosphere and the staff. Everything is amazing from start to end. Every time we visit Key West we always come here! Always made to feel so welcome, l could hang out all night. Love this gem! Don’t miss out! You will thank me!❤️
… more
Robin Merideth
Stopped in for dinner and we’re pleasantly surprised they were offering a happy hour special of 50% off pasta dishes. The chicken picatta was delicious. My daughter ordered the Pasta Primavera and she said it was good. They served the meal with garlic knots that were warm and yummy. Service was friendly and helpful.
… more
Roman “Romko”
New York Pasta Garden is a fantastic place for Italian food lovers. The pasta dishes are fresh, flavorful, and clearly made with care. Portions are generous, ingredients taste high quality, and everything is cooked perfectly. The staff is friendly, attentive, and makes you feel welcome from the moment you arrive. The atmosphere is cozy and relaxed, making it a great spot for a casual dinner or a special night out. Overall, excellent food, great service, and a place I would gladly return to.
… more
Ian Boyd
Absolutely! Here’s the revised version:

⸻

A Taste of Tuscany in Key West

Pasta Garden is a hidden gem! The homemade pasta — especially the lobster ravioli and carbonara — was outstanding. The cozy courtyard feels like a little slice of Italy. A bald man served us, recommended the best wine pairings, and was incredibly knowledgeable. The wine list is amazing and made the whole experience even better. Can’t wait to come back!
… more
Jenni Gerstle
We have eaten at most of the Italian restaurants in Key West and hadn’t been to this one in a couple of years. It was time to come back and we were not disappointed. The wait staff were very friendly and our waitress Kamila even though new did a great job. I ordered the pasta Belle Mare which was excellent, very flavorful and no fish taste which seafood dishes often have. Sad to say I ate the whole thing. My husband had the Lasagne – one of his favorite things to eat which he often orders and he said it was one of the best. No leftovers there either! This restaurant is tucked in a square off Duval so easy to miss but it is worth searching out. You won’t be disappointed.
… more
Bobby Lusby
We have been to KW several times, but as vegetarians it’s hard to find a place the isn’t burgers or seafood. We stumbled upon this beautiful little place and we LOVED it. We went back a second night as well. The first night we went there, Fletcher was our server and he was absolutely amazing. The second night we had, Donna, she was just as amazing as Fletcher. They welcomed us like we had known them forever and treated us like family.
… more
Rosa Morales
My Husband and I always always come here when we first arrive to Florida. We have been coming here three years straight. Its such a beautiful setting. You get to sit outside, enjoy the breeze and the service is great. Now if come at a busy time, relax get a cocktail and enjoy the island. The garlic bread and pasta here is phenomenal (there portion size is worth it)

Thank you!!!
… more
Mein Family
This was the best place we’ve dined in Key West by far!!! The Hostess & Fletcher was fantastic. Everything was delicious. The fettuccini Alfredo and manicotti are the best we’ve ever had. Wish we were staying longer so we could come again. If we visit Key West again, we’ll definitely be back.
… more
… View more

Leave a Comment

© 2026 Marketer • Built with GeneratePress

Privacy Policy

Terms

Contact