Social Profile: 
![]()
… View more
Lively tap house with a pool table serving up classic bar bites, plus trivia & karaoke nights.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 84 Main St, New Paltz, NY 12561
Phone: (845) 256-9289
Website: http://cuddysny.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
McGillicuddy’s Family Restaurant – Lunch, Dinner, Burgers, Wings …
Not in the mood for wings? Don’t sweat it. We also serve a variety of burgers, salads and sandwiches. We serve patrons from New Paltz, NY and surrounding areas.
McGillicuddy’s New Paltz (@cuddysny) • Instagram photos and videos
A Fine Place To Raise Your Spirits 84 Main Street New Paltz, NY (845)256-9289. Hours: Mon-Thurs: 3-10 PM Fri-Sun: 12-10 PM @cuddysnightlife …
McGillicuddy’s in New Paltz, NY – Ulster County NY Tourism
Experience great food and drinks at McGillicuddy’s in New Paltz, NY. A popular spot for casual dining and nightlife.
Reviews
Elliott Williams
My wife and I would stay at this cute airbnb in The town of New Paltz NY it’s called the tree house because it’s actually up a tree with steps its design is parisian .While visiting this wonderful town we would not miss eating at Mcgillicuddys. It is about a 10 min walk and seeing the old stone houses was amazing. When you walk in the waitress is welcoming and the atmosphere is good .you have to try the Wings ! Voted best in NY yes its that good.the burger is really good .the drinks will make you smile for sure. There are other restaurants in the vincity but Mcgillicuddys stand alone .
… morePhil S
Just got takeout. Got home and ordered pretzel bites and cheese. Confirmed on the phone pretzel bites with cheese. Get home no cheese. Kind of disappointing since I was trying to just get some comfort food and they didn’t get the order right. Drove 12 minutes there and 12 minutes back to be let down. Unfortunately a one star.
… moreEric Marto
Great food, fast service! Had the cowboy burger and it was cooked perfect and stacked high with onion straws!
… moreCarly Barbanti
Their mac attack is to die for! The inside could use a bit of an update, been the same for many years, but you can’t tell its Irish, but I guess its good it not a stereotype. Little pricey. If it had some updates and a bit lower prices on simple meals, it would earn 5 stars. But I understand small businesses dont have the luxury to update whenever and supply chains make the prices. Great place though!
… moreLenny Simone
Nice Irish Pub on the main drag in New Paltz.
Super friendly staff, we were seated right away. Lots of TV’s blaring on a game day so be aware of that but was not an issue at all when we visited. Fantastic beer selection and plenty of other drink choices. Had the Irish Potato soup. Excellent flavor and served quickly. Shared the Turkey club and a side salad. Fresh turkey, generous salad, both were delicious. Pricing is very fair also.
Parking can be tough but there is a lot behind and up the hill where we were able to pay via an app.
Lots of food choices in this college town but this is a nice, well run place so we will go again as we pass thru the area.
… moreSuper friendly staff, we were seated right away. Lots of TV’s blaring on a game day so be aware of that but was not an issue at all when we visited. Fantastic beer selection and plenty of other drink choices. Had the Irish Potato soup. Excellent flavor and served quickly. Shared the Turkey club and a side salad. Fresh turkey, generous salad, both were delicious. Pricing is very fair also.
Parking can be tough but there is a lot behind and up the hill where we were able to pay via an app.
Lots of food choices in this college town but this is a nice, well run place so we will go again as we pass thru the area.
Sam T
Lived in new paltz for a while now and have supported this restaurant so much, either it being going for a meal, trivia, or nightlife. But I no longer can give them money after being treated, and watching other regulars be treated like we weren’t people. Recently, it’s gotten worse. It’s becoming less and less of a safe college bar, with trustworthy workers. It’s becoming less and less of a family restaurant. Expect better from restaurants like this.
… moreFrenite
McGillicuddy’s offers an authentic Irish pub experience with a large menu, spacious bar area, numerous TVs, and decent food options. The Irish Stout Chicken Pie I ordered was alright, but it did not surpass my expectations. However, I found the appetizers of wings and salad to be quite enjoyable. With a wide selection of dishes on the menu, there are plenty of other delicious options to choose from. The service was excellent, the prices were fair, and the festive Irish ambiance added to the overall experience. McGillicuddy’s is a great spot for affordable pub fare in a festive Irish setting.
… moreAnestis Kariotis
Best mozzarella sticks I’ve ever had! Good vibes and great music. Staff is incredible!
… moreSuparna Banerjee
We stopped for dinner.
The service is really quick here.
We ordered a round of drinks – we liked whatever we ordered and they came out pretty fast.
Appetizers-
Magarita flatbread and chicken wings with the special sauce which was really good. Loved the sauce and the flatbread was really good and crispy. For wings they have around 10-15 sauces to select from.
Kids menu – Penne with marinara sauce which was ok ok.
Entree-
Fisherman’s catch which was like a sandwich, not so great but ok ok.
Spicy chicken sandwich and the black bean burger were really good. The fries were good and crunchy.
The big salad was not our favorites as it was way too raw.
Overall the food is good and quick services. The parking is also available easily.
… moreThe service is really quick here.
We ordered a round of drinks – we liked whatever we ordered and they came out pretty fast.
Appetizers-
Magarita flatbread and chicken wings with the special sauce which was really good. Loved the sauce and the flatbread was really good and crispy. For wings they have around 10-15 sauces to select from.
Kids menu – Penne with marinara sauce which was ok ok.
Entree-
Fisherman’s catch which was like a sandwich, not so great but ok ok.
Spicy chicken sandwich and the black bean burger were really good. The fries were good and crunchy.
The big salad was not our favorites as it was way too raw.
Overall the food is good and quick services. The parking is also available easily.
Andres Sanchez
This is a classic place to go. The service is great and the food is good. The honey Buffalo wings either boneless or bone in are delicious. If it’s not busy the food comes out pretty quick. I don’t go here that often anymore but still like going every once in a while.
… more