Longtime restaurant offering NYC-style pizza & other items in no-nonsense surrounds.
Hours
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 4–8:30 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 4775 S Harvard Ave, Tulsa, OK 74135
Phone: (918) 779-7760
Website: https://nyc-pizza.shop/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
NYC Pizza Tulsa – Savory Slices & Cozy Italian Vibes
NYC Pizza in Tulsa feels like a small gateway to classic New York street-style pizza, tucked away on South Harvard Avenue. The moment you step inside, …
NYC Pizza South | Tulsa OK – Facebook
We take pride in serving you Bixby, and surrounding areas. We will be launching specials pretty shortly, so keep your eye out for those!
Best NYC pizza in the Tulsa area? – Reddit
Late night slices always hit the spot. (Empire Slice House, Oklahoma City, OK) · r/Pizza – Late night slices always hit the spot. (Empire …
Reviews
Timothy Williams
This was my first time going here.
I got a 16in pepperoni pizza for about 23 dollars.
The main dining room was clean, but some of those booths are not for the obese.
I walked in and ordered. I already knew what I wanted, but there wasn’t an obvious menu anywhere.
Their website menu on mobile was unhelpful as you cannot zoom in.
The pizza was okay. Trying a pepperoni alone it had a decent heat but a rather basic flavor.
The cheese was quite elastic and flavorful.
The crust was pleasantly thin with a good flavor.
Overall the pizza was decent, but I have had better elsewhere. However, you should give them a shot.
Also, be careful. When fresh, this pizza will lose all its toppings if you tilt it.
… moreI got a 16in pepperoni pizza for about 23 dollars.
The main dining room was clean, but some of those booths are not for the obese.
I walked in and ordered. I already knew what I wanted, but there wasn’t an obvious menu anywhere.
Their website menu on mobile was unhelpful as you cannot zoom in.
The pizza was okay. Trying a pepperoni alone it had a decent heat but a rather basic flavor.
The cheese was quite elastic and flavorful.
The crust was pleasantly thin with a good flavor.
Overall the pizza was decent, but I have had better elsewhere. However, you should give them a shot.
Also, be careful. When fresh, this pizza will lose all its toppings if you tilt it.
Jordan Riddles
For anyone who’s ever been to New York City and had an authentic slice, you’d know immediately that this supposed “NYC Pizza” is a big flop. Literally.
I live in Tulsa but have been to New York a fair amount and love the pizza there. I’m always trying to find a good, authentic NY slice here at home. Some places come close—this one does not. I even asked for the pizza well done as it’s hard to get an actual low-flop, crispy NYC slice here. Look at that flop! The toppings slid right off. This was not well done.
If you’re looking for more authentic NYC pizza, look elsewhere. I’ve had better luck at Empire and Pie Hole, especially with the crust.
I will say, the delivery driver was very nice. One star added for the delivery man.
… moreI live in Tulsa but have been to New York a fair amount and love the pizza there. I’m always trying to find a good, authentic NY slice here at home. Some places come close—this one does not. I even asked for the pizza well done as it’s hard to get an actual low-flop, crispy NYC slice here. Look at that flop! The toppings slid right off. This was not well done.
If you’re looking for more authentic NYC pizza, look elsewhere. I’ve had better luck at Empire and Pie Hole, especially with the crust.
I will say, the delivery driver was very nice. One star added for the delivery man.
Brad Nail
I have been going to this place many of years and I just recently noticed they got pastas. I tried the penne à la vodka and it was the most delicious pasta I’ve ever had in my life. I compared it to cheesecake factory. You must stop in and try.
… moreLogan Montgomery
NYC is the best pizza place in Tulsa, hands down. I can’t even explain how good this place is, you’ve just got to try it yourself. Underrated, underpriced, and one of the best bites in Tulsa.
… moreToby Trevett
We went today 5/16/2025 for lunch. We drove past it and decided to give it a try. We each got a slice of the supreme pizza. It was good. We also got salads and the garlic bread knot. It was all good. It is a come as you are restaurant. I recommend giving them a try.
… moreChantel Titsworth
Best New York pizza in town! I enjoy the white pizza they offer and the supreme pizza. They are open late on Saturdays for a quick snack. I come back everytime for the garlic knots. They are golden crisp on the outside and chewy soft inside. If you enjoy layered textures, they are for you.
… moreKeaton Parish
I don’t know where all of these reviews came from but this has to be one of the worst pizza places I’ve ever tried. The sauce tasted like watered down great value pizza sauce. I left here and didn’t leave the bathroom all night I would not suggest going here unless you want to a upset stomach and explosive diarrhea. not to mention it wasn’t in a good area with homeless people lurking around outside constantly staring inside at the customers. In my opinion it was way over priced and not worth more than 1 dollar a slice of that. I hope in the future they can improve the quality of this restaurant for their own sake but I personally will never return to this restaurant.
… moreJohn Whitaker
Hands Down… It’s the “bomb diggitty”…THE BEST EVER…GOAT!!!
Eddie and his crew there at the store….Do an excellent job.The pizza is spot on perfect…All the time every day, I couldn’t ask for better… the best of i’ve ever had!!! 5 stars is not near enough. They need at least 10 stars☆☆☆☆☆☆☆☆☆☆
… moreEddie and his crew there at the store….Do an excellent job.The pizza is spot on perfect…All the time every day, I couldn’t ask for better… the best of i’ve ever had!!! 5 stars is not near enough. They need at least 10 stars☆☆☆☆☆☆☆☆☆☆
Hawkins H
They need to hire someone who can actually understand what customers are saying. Was excited to try but our order was completely wrong even though I repeated it about 3 times and they said it back to me. Also was immediately met with an attitude as soon as I walked in the door and the prices that they show online are not accurate to what they try to tell you when you go in. Online menu is also not updated properly as it only says “pizza” and does not tell you which pizza you are ordering. They also tried to cheat us out of our money when we attempted to pay. Total was supposed to be $34 and they kept putting $49 on the screen after saying they “fixed it” and from what I’ve seen in these reviews the pizza wouldn’t have been worth it anyway so we dodged a bullet!
… moreFred Santaliz
Being from new york I gotta say it brings me back when I eat here. Pizza is great friendly staff but I love the fact they have beef patties and you can put pepperoni and cheese. Now that’s the new york I remember. So thank you guys appreciate everything I try to stop there at least once a week a grab a slice.
… more