Social Profile: 
✔️Breakfast ✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 5445 Somers Point Rd, Mays Landing, NJ 08330
Phone: (609) 625-0538
Website: https://eatsugarhillsubs.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
SUGAR HILL SUB SHOP
Sub aficionados love to compare Sugar Hill Subs in Mays Landing to White House Subs … 5445 Somers Point Rd, Mays Landing, NJ 08330, USA. (609) 625-0538. Hours …
Sugar Hill Subs in Mays Landing Review – Facebook
So we heard that Sugar Hill Subs in Mays Landing was voted best in the US so we tried their “claim to fame” Italian Stallion. White House has …
No Panic: Mays Landing’s Sugar Hill Subs Closure Is Temporary
Burst Pipes Cause the Closing of Sugar Hill Subs. Sugar Hill Subs & Deli, at 5445 Somers Point Road, the sandwich pride of Mays Landing — and …
Reviews
Henry Hand
Ordered a reuben sandwich and tuna sub. The reuben was absolutely fantastic… among the best I’ve had. The tuna sub was fine, but neither the tuna nor the roll were as fresh-tasting as at my favorite shops up north. I like a softer, fluffier roll on a cold sub. The atmosphere was quintessential Jersey sub shop, with chips and snacks all over the walls. I will definitely go back to try the cheesesteak and other hot sandwiches.
… moreM Alger
Lots of places to get a sammich. This place is the top of the list! I have been several times in the past few years. I have tried several different items on the menu. Taken to the beach taken home I’ve even eaten at the shop every single sandwich I’ve had has been stellar! My son’s favorite is the pickled gerry, hes completely captivated by it! So much so that he drives an hour just to get one! I like to try something different every time I go. The service is very fast, friendly and most importantly patient. It’s a very vast menu. I like to take my time and figure out what I’m going to try next. Trying to decide where to grab something? There should be no hesitation. This is it!
… moreKeith Brock
Drove three hours to try this spot on recommendation of “the godfather of meats ” on FB . It didn’t disappoint, the sub was on point and so fresh, the tomatoes were delicious. Also got side of pepper shooters and damn they were good. Awesome food, cool spot and nice people, definitely stop in and see them
… moreDeborah Berdel
Finally trying Sugar Hill Subs after hearing how great it is and it was fantastic. I had the Italian Stallion and my husband had the Italian – both were great! The staff was super making good recommendations and reasons why. They use good quality ingredients and it all comes together great. We ordered the Italian wedding soup and it was incredible- totally worth getting their fresh soup. Their broth is full of flavor. Probably the best hoagie (sorry, I can’t say sub) I’ve had in decades!
… moreCashanova Entertainment
I was in the area and decided to give this deli shop a try. I went for a whole Italian it came out to $12.53. The lady taking my order was very pleasant l. Surprisingly the sub came out pretty quick less than 5 minutes after I ordered it no exaggeration. There is ample parking and they have literally every chip and drink you can think of to go along with your sandwich. The lettuce, tomatoes, and onions etc were very fresh. I would give a try again when in the area I would recommend to give it a try.
… moreHarvey Kesselman
Everyone knows that Sugar Hill Subs and Deli has the best subs in the area. My family has been going there for decades and Denise (the wonderful owner) consistently provides a quality product.
Today I tried their homemade chicken noodle soup and chili. Both were excellent! Also, the service provided by Becca was first-rate.
It is so rare to have such a gem for such a long period of time. We are so fortunate in Mays Landing to have Sugar Hill Subs and Deli.
… moreToday I tried their homemade chicken noodle soup and chili. Both were excellent! Also, the service provided by Becca was first-rate.
It is so rare to have such a gem for such a long period of time. We are so fortunate in Mays Landing to have Sugar Hill Subs and Deli.
Mary Young
The people were super nice and made me feel like a “regular”. They have the best cheese steak subs made fresh to order. I will definitely make this my go to spot whenever I come to visit. Stop by you won’t be disappointed. 10/10⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
… moreDarThefoodguru !
This place screams classic, Sugar hill has been serving the community for 30+ years. the sandwiches were incredible and so was the staff!
… moreMartha E. Anderson
Ordered 3 sandwiches for lunch today. One was totally wrong, they redelivered after trying to charge again for their error. The Veg lover was drenched in pesto goo.
Mine was a turkey sub – if that turkey was Boar’s Head, they need to talk to their rep – cheese was missing, and triple onions, way too much mayo.
The chicken salad sub was good. Sugar Hill you have fallen way off your game.
Keep driving by….. I’m a local and know what used to be. I threw my turkey sub away.
… moreMine was a turkey sub – if that turkey was Boar’s Head, they need to talk to their rep – cheese was missing, and triple onions, way too much mayo.
The chicken salad sub was good. Sugar Hill you have fallen way off your game.
Keep driving by….. I’m a local and know what used to be. I threw my turkey sub away.
Jeffrey Bailey
This was my first time getting a hoagie from this place. I have to say. I was extremely happy with the food. It was very flavorful and very well made. The staff was absolutely fantastic. The whole store reminded me of the general stores I grew up with as a kid. I don’t get into this area very often but I will make a point to get here more. I can’t wait to try more of the offerings from this amazing deli. If you’re in the area or just looking for one of the best hoagie places around. Definitely go check this place out. You will not be disappointed. I picked the Italian Stallion this trip. Also, spend the extra .50 and get the crushed pepper spread. If you like spice. It only makes the whole thing better.
… more