Timothy Vaughn
I passed this place while taking a delivery from findlay to kalida. On my way back in I had to try it and i was not disappointed. This pizza has all the qualities im looking for that other places just miss on.
Im not a huge fan of the stereotypical cheese pull because that leads to messes and burning and too much grease. This pizza is more like baked to perfection and holds the toppings under it perfectly so you know the bites are gonna be amazing. The sauce tastes fantastic, a lot of tomato and spices coming through with the tiniest hint of sweet to round it out. And the thin crust I got wasnt like the cracker crust you get from most places. It has a little bit of body to it so it can hold some heavy toppings but not overpower the pizza with dough taste.
The people there were kind and quick, especially for a friday night. I was absolutely blown away, you guys are doing fantastic work and I will 100% be back
… moreLarry Edmiston
I am extremely disappointed and unhappy of their present management. I have been a lifetime consumer of the pizzeria. I even purchased pizzas when Tom Cartwright started the Business. And followed it through with Ron and Patsy Schaffer, Then continued with their sons in Columbus Grove and Ottawa. I am Unable any longer to go to the Ottawa store because of my physical disabilities. But I still yearned for that pizzeria taste. Until recently when I phoned to order a pizza and have it delivered. That is when I become very upset due to the fact that they told me they would no longer deliver. Pizzas to my location. They told me they was gonna go to a different delivery service, such as DoorDash, but did not yet have it set up or working. I told them if that’s the way they treat loyal customers they could forget about any business from me henceforth. After our phone call and discussion I then ordered my pizza from Pizza Hut. And they were very happy to have my business and deliver their product to me. If this is anyway to run a business, I no longer wish to be affiliated with them. So goodbye, pizzeria, and hello to Pizza Hut. Larry Edmiston
… moreAustin Is a Person
Pizza!
I’ve been eating Pizzeria just about every Thursday for well over a decade. Excellent food, good service, and if they make a mistake they’ll do right by ya every darn time. Good fellas up there at the pizzeria. Not just the best pizza in Putnam county, but honestly some of the best pizza I’ve had anywhere. Subs are fantastic as well, and an order of breadsticks are fantastic after or midway through a hard day or night’s work. Pizzeria, 10/10!
… moreCasey Black
We opted to eat here during an event at the school. Food was better than concession food but wouldn’t visit again.
… moreGunner Kuhlman
This place is the best everytime I come here the best pizza is waiting for me and I feel as if I am going to be having the best food ever!
… moreGriffin Leopold
The skill, the love, the craftsmanship, the passion, the family, the dedication, the effort, the kindness, the pizzeria. Crafted with ingredients that taste like food. The sauce made by the infamous sauce master himself. It’s safe to say I would really like what they’re cooking
Ps: it smells good
… moreAaron Suter
I had just returned from a 6 month deployment and my mom and dad are visiting from Ottawa. They all said they wanted pizza and to my surprise they pulled out a frozen pizzeria pizza. My mom had gone to the location and asked them make one but not cook it so she could bring it to me in New Mexico for me to enjoy after I had returned. It was a great a surprise and tasted just as good as I remember. Thanks for bringing a smile to my face and letting me get a taste of home.
… moreJose’ Rangel
First time I’ve ever had terrible service . I kept getting told few more min few more min after I was told it was 45 min wait I ended up waiting hour and half . I had truck and trailer it wasn’t easy to keep pulling around . If lady would have just said they messed up orders I’d had been fine but I just kept getting told to keep pulling around that upset me greatly. Just tell the truth. And my order still wasn’t done right. Not happy first time in many many years.
… moreLinda Laughlin
Took forever to place order because phone was busy. Took over an hour to get food which was burnt and warm. When delivery was late I tried for 20 minutes to call to see where order was. Once again, phone was busy. Was told the place employs mostly teenagers who mess around and talk on phone majority of the time. Used to be my favorite pizza place…can’t say that now.
… moreCharles Case
We tried this place, because the Pizza Hut down the street was closed in their dining room due to lack of staff. This place had a inviting smell and a really good menu. We were quite pleased with our experience.
… more