Social Profile: 
![]()
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Longtime chain known for its pizzas, pastas & other Italian staples served in a casual setting.
Hours
| Monday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–8 PM |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 12939 Wicker Ave, Cedar Lake, IN 46303
Phone: (219) 401-8188
Website: https://www.aureliospizza.com/locations/?zip-code=46303&submit=Search
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Cedar Lake IN Pizza Restaurant | Aurelios Pizza®
12939 Wicker Ave Cedar Lake IN 46303 219-401-8188 Hours Sun – Thurs: 11am to 8pm Fri – Sat: 11am – 9pm Dining Room Hours: Mon – Thurs:
Aurelio’s: Cedar Lake – Facebook
Don’t forget about our Wednesday Dine in Special! Every Wednesday, order a medium, large, or fiesta size pizza and get an appetizer or small antipasto salad …
Aurelio’s Pizza – Cedar Lake, IN – 12939 Wicker Ave – Hours, Menu …
View the menu, hours, address, and photos for Aurelio’s Pizza in Cedar Lake, IN. Order online for delivery or pickup on Slicelife.com.
Reviews
FRANKYG
I ordered a thin crust pizza on super bowl Sunday. Ordered from their website and it showed about a 2hr delivery; which I was ok with.
The pizza we got was the worst Pizza I have ever had. It had an awful smell, the pizza was over cooked, the ends were curling over….
There was no time to send it back.
Joe Aurelio would be very upset.
In my opinion, pizza is mostly good or great. This was super bad. I should’ve taken a picture.
Hope you guys can improve…
… moreThe pizza we got was the worst Pizza I have ever had. It had an awful smell, the pizza was over cooked, the ends were curling over….
There was no time to send it back.
Joe Aurelio would be very upset.
In my opinion, pizza is mostly good or great. This was super bad. I should’ve taken a picture.
Hope you guys can improve…
Kim Brown (Sassy2021*)
We had it the prize, get together for my niece. The place was not busy. I don’t know if the waitress was busy, but she did not pay that good attention to us. By this is fiance, ordered 4 large pizzas. I had to look for the waitress because we weren’t done ordering.
And then when I found her, we got our salads right before our pizzas came out.
I know we weren’t her only table. I’m sure she was a little busy, but the place really wasn’t busy to where she couldn’t have handled us. And a lot of restaurants will give you another table until after your food goes out. I don’t know how aurelios works, but most of them do that.
The pizza was okay. I’ve had much better pizza from aurelios. Maybe it was just the one in Cedar Lake. That’s the first time I had eaten there in quite a while.
Once the waitress was caught up, things went pretty smoothly.
… moreAnd then when I found her, we got our salads right before our pizzas came out.
I know we weren’t her only table. I’m sure she was a little busy, but the place really wasn’t busy to where she couldn’t have handled us. And a lot of restaurants will give you another table until after your food goes out. I don’t know how aurelios works, but most of them do that.
The pizza was okay. I’ve had much better pizza from aurelios. Maybe it was just the one in Cedar Lake. That’s the first time I had eaten there in quite a while.
Once the waitress was caught up, things went pretty smoothly.
Michael Mccann
I think this is my favorite Pizza. I’ve been eating their my whole life. I traveled with my job. We had a saying on Pizza at work, Pizza north of the Ohio River and BBQ to the South. You have to go with the flow
… moreBrian K
Went for lunch buffet. Pizza was fantastic and kept full. Other options that day were not great but menu changes. You go for the pizza and it did not disappoint.
… moreDennis Suttinger
14.99 for buffet ok ordered a Diet PEPSI
MY BILL $20.42 Nah overpriced won’t be back for FRIDAY BUFFET
… moreMY BILL $20.42 Nah overpriced won’t be back for FRIDAY BUFFET
Kathy Pazak
Arrived around 5 on a Friday and waited30 minutes for a table.
Small space, limited seating but the servers were quick, helpful and very efficient.
Pizza was good…. Great mushroom and sausage ;light on the sauce…at first we thought it was a white pizza. Antipasto salad for 2 easily fed all 4 of us. Limited drink menu…. No Chianti or Lambrusco..
Plenty of leftovers.
… moreSmall space, limited seating but the servers were quick, helpful and very efficient.
Pizza was good…. Great mushroom and sausage ;light on the sauce…at first we thought it was a white pizza. Antipasto salad for 2 easily fed all 4 of us. Limited drink menu…. No Chianti or Lambrusco..
Plenty of leftovers.
CR X
Probably the closest in taste to the original in Homewood but only if you dine in.
Ordered a pizza and received a burnt mess.
Could only offer a credit on the account for next visit or remake a pizza with a 2hr delivery window.
… moreOrdered a pizza and received a burnt mess.
Could only offer a credit on the account for next visit or remake a pizza with a 2hr delivery window.
Samuel Bokodi
Huge fan of deep-dish and pizza in general so I was looking forward to this.
I’ll start negative and finish with the positives.
Negatives: Service was subpar. The restaurant was fairly busy for a Tuesday night and it appeared understaffed. It took way longer than most restaurants to get the server to see us after being seated. We ordered garlic bread as an appetizer and it contained an excess amount of salt.
Positives: our server was great and did her job well. The garlic was still delicious even with too much sodium. We got a Medium 13″ Stuffed Pepperoni Pizza and it was great. Pizza had the right temperature, was deliciously messy, and the stringy cheese seemed fresh based off of its consistency. The sauce was tangy with a hint of sweetness. It was good.
Overall I would go back. The subpar staffing for accommodating guests is worth the food.
… moreI’ll start negative and finish with the positives.
Negatives: Service was subpar. The restaurant was fairly busy for a Tuesday night and it appeared understaffed. It took way longer than most restaurants to get the server to see us after being seated. We ordered garlic bread as an appetizer and it contained an excess amount of salt.
Positives: our server was great and did her job well. The garlic was still delicious even with too much sodium. We got a Medium 13″ Stuffed Pepperoni Pizza and it was great. Pizza had the right temperature, was deliciously messy, and the stringy cheese seemed fresh based off of its consistency. The sauce was tangy with a hint of sweetness. It was good.
Overall I would go back. The subpar staffing for accommodating guests is worth the food.
Leslie Pirtle
My husband ordered from here because he knows we love Aurelio’s Pizza. We normal order from the one in Winfield. I sure wish he had. The pizza was delivered was burnt, dry and look disgusting. We told them and they made a new pizza that still was over cooked. It was disgusting and looked like old tops were put on it. I’ll never order from here again. They were very nice to try and replace it but we are all sick now from this pizza.
… moreyammy gaga
Ts So Peak Bro Their Piza So Delicious And I Brought Ma Whole Family, Mi Papi, Mi Mami, Mi Brothoer, Mi Grandpapi, Mi Grandmami, And Mi Sistor. 11/10 Pizza Riht Heer Boiz And Tha Waitresses Loweki Looked Liek Aliens Ngl But Still Gud Pizza Tho. Also I Made A Drawin Of Whot Thei Looked Liek.
… more