Liz-Beth Raphael
The guy taking my order was not paying any attention and messed up everything I ordered. When I told him he messed up he said no it was my fault and just moved on to the next customer. I ordered 2 pizzas he charged me for 3 and they were all wrong 0/3!!! I hope they find people better at customer service because that guy sucked and then some!!
… moreItzThatEmo
I went here on monday 10/20/2025 and me and my friend ordered 2 orders of pizza bites and 1 order of garlic knots. They told us it would be a 10 minute wait so in the meantime we went to the lucky 7 to get some drinks, which took about 10 minutes. When we got back we had to wait another 10 minutes and we only had gotten 1 order of pizza bites. We decided we’d share the pizza bites but we had to reorder the garlic knots after already paying for them?? So we had to wait another 20 minutes for those. We waited a total of 40 minutes when they said it’d only be 10. AND we never got one of the orders of pizza bites?? This was extremely disappointing and frustrating. Would not recommend this place.
… moreNick Crescenzo
Honestly, I know this is chain pizza and standards are relatively low, but we’ve ordered from here occasionally over the last few years and our order is always right and delivered on time.
… moreWinnifred ivy Manu
I like my pizza hot and with no tomato sauce and it tasted amazing.
I got a medium size pizza with 3 toppings and it was all less than $20.
… moreTiggy N
Been ordering here for over 5 years now, WAS always great. Now the food isn’t done right and the owner that works the register and phone has a serious attitude problem. When I called to complain about the food, he was considering and has an attitude saying it’s suppose to be that way. When I tried to give another chance, as I have been going here for a long time with no problem, when I went in no greeting from the counter person and completely treated like I was an inconvenience. No thank you have a nice day nothing. I will not be ordering here again and will never recommend this location
… moreSusan Williams
Consistently Delicious Pizza and Outstanding Service**
I’ve been a regular customer at Papa John’s in Bordentown, NJ, and I cannot praise this location enough. The food is consistently delicious, and the service is top-notch.
The owner of this establishment is a true professional who genuinely cares about his customers. Every visit is met with a warm welcome, and you can always count on the staff to be friendly and efficient. It’s clear that the owner has instilled a sense of pride and dedication in his team, as their commitment to providing an excellent dining experience shines through every time.
The pizza here is always fresh, with a perfect balance of toppings and that signature Papa John’s taste. Whether I’m ordering for a quick lunch or a family dinner, I know I’ll be getting high-quality, mouthwatering pizza every time.
If you’re in the Bordentown area and looking for a reliable spot for great pizza and friendly service, look no further than Papa John’s. Highly recommended!
… moreJay A’
First I ordered online. Once I got to the store to pick up my order they said they never received my order and to check to make sure I was at the right location. I showed the the confirmation message, I showed them that this was the right location and I also showed them that I paid and also the money was taken out of my bank account. That took another 30 minutes. After all that they still didn’t believe me and had me call the customer service number, I did. The customer service rep told them to make my pizza because they could see my order. That was another 10 minutes. After all that I was just ready to get my money back and leave but we had been waiting so long we just decided to wait till it was done. Once we got home and started to eat, we were very disappointed! The pizza was disgusting! And I usually love papa johns. I Will not be going back to this location. The male owner was very rude. However the female owner was very sweet and I appreciate her great service! Overall this was a terrible experience and the food was very bad. I literally ordered just cheese pizza. I’m not sure how you could mess that up. I paid almost $30, I should’ve just went with my gut and got my money back and went somewhere else.
… moreNina Sarafina
Need to reconsider Ubereats platform spoke to driver & never delivered my order not sure why he was even able to mark as delivered when he was at a completely different address!!! Will not be ordering again
… moreDouglas Ashley
Owner tried to blame it on the delivery drive r that they forgot our sauce for our pizza bread when the sauce is sealed inside the box and not the side. Owner didn’t want to fess up on the error or try to rectify it. So if your order is wrong don’t bother calling in.
… moreMr. Usery
Who was wonderful but service was very poor. When we ask, can we get some plates to go with the pizza? We were given two plates. , And we had an XL New York style pizza very heavy!!
Hopefully next time will be better
… more