Son’ja
Terrible. Please STOP putting “NY STYLE” on every thin crust pizza! Guy took my order, answered the phone then stuck his hands in the cheese to finish making a pizza. NO GLOVES AT ALL. then the pizza had very little sauce and cheese. I wanted to try a slice before buying a whole pie, so Glad I did. I will not be back. No flavor at all and no use of gloves or washing of hands
… moreKevin Houston
This was my first time visiting. They have a lot of pizza options, but the slices available at dinner time were limited. They have 3 indoor tables with bench seating (no backs) and a few outside tables. There are no wait staff, you order at the counter. They offer Coke products on fountain with free refills.
The pizza was thin, and floppy (like a NY style should be). The sauce was not too sweet and not too acidic. The cheese was just the right amount for my liking and the pepperoni was mildly spicy.
A large pepperoni pizza was $17.49 (for the Neapolitan, cheese) plus another $2.99 for the pepperoni. They do have a loyalty program upon checking out. One thing to be aware of is they charge a 3% surcharge for using your card. I didn’t see a sign at the register that stated this, so I was a bit shocked to see it when I read my text receipt.
… morecharles king
This pizza was pretty darn good. The wings weren’t my personal favorite, however I can see many people really liking them. The price was fair and the service was fast and friendly. Will definitely be back.
… moreMia Ferrell
Happened upon Grandma’s NY Pizza accidentally and so glad we did! Customer appreciation day so we received a free 3 topping large pizza. We bought Grandmas salad and it was fantastic. Very nice owner, and very good food. We will be back, on purpose this time!
… moreSrinivas Komma
Grandma’s NY Pizza in Cumming, GA, offers authentic New York-style pizza with a crispy thin crust and hearty toppings. Highlights include the Grandma’s Pizza, garlic knots, and friendly service. Perfect for casual dining or takeout, it’s a local favorite for quality and taste.
… moreStephanie Kramer
As a New York native, this pizzeria feels like home. Delicious pizza, amazing flavors, fresh salads, and a peaceful spot to dine inside or outside. Grandmas NY Pizza truly hits the mark!
… moreFeisty Grandma
A local pizza joint that our hotel recommended. Traditional NY pizza. After a day in the city, their pie hit the spot. Delicious! Costs more than the pizza chains but worth it. Highly recommend. 10/10.
… moreCeline Cevikel
Amazing pizza! I’m always craving cannolis and they have the best in north Atlanta metro I’ve ever had. Here’s a pic of my half eaten cannoli cuz I couldn’t even wait! Evan’s had the best attitude and customer service the two times I’ve been here (will be back again)
… moreErica Carter
When I tell you this place is official! Top notch! If you are a true New Yorker looking for authentic NY Style pizza… This is what you want! Check em out! I’ll be back! 10 stars!!
… moreJennifer Hardin
We tried this place with high expectations. I haven’t had a great NY style pizza in this area yet… and we have tried a bunch that advertise as such. I ordered a 14” Neopolitan with extra cheese. The only thing that disappointed us was the fact I didn’t order a bigger pie. When I picked it up it was fresh and piping hot. I sprinkled some Parmesan I saw on the tables and headed for the car. We didn’t make it out of the parking lot before digging in. The sauce is delicious and the cheese on point. The crust is thin and delicious. Perfect foldable goodness. We will be back!
… more