Address and Contact Information
Address: 11 N Main St, Mt Gilead, OH 43338
Website: https://www.toasttab.com/the-rusty-horseshoe-galion/v2/online-order!/
Menu Photos
Related Web Results
The Rusty Horseshoe – CLOSED, 11 N Main St, Mount Gilead, OH …
Get more information for The Rusty Horseshoe in Mount Gilead, OH. See reviews, map, get the address, and find directions.
The Rusty Horseshoe (, Mt Gilead) – Restaurant Reviews, Menu …
11 N Main St, Mt Gilead, OH 43338, United States. View on Map.. Reviews. Congratulations! You found a new place! Why not leave a review and help other …
Rusty Horseshoe aids in Sheriff’s safety awareness
MOUNT GILEAD — The National Child Safety Council is the oldest and largest 501(c)(3) federal tax exempt, not for profit charitable …
Reviews
David Clifton
Excellent food and service; a great value. We had breakfast on a Saturday around 10:00 a.m. They were busy, but we were seated immediately and served promptly. Thumbs up!
… moreMary Walters
Food was excellent, staff was friendly. They were extremely busy when we went but didn’t have a long wait for a table or our food. I see a few complaints about the open faced roast beef and undercooked burgers. These were part of our order and they were excellent! We will definitely be back!
… moreTiffany Loccisano
1st visit….
Giving a 3star because the inside atmosphere was nice. Friendly servers. The issue was the food. Ordered steak and eggs, the eggs and potatoes were good, the steak, not so much. I asked for medium, they gave me well done. And I would hardly call it a steak. There was more fat than meat. But I’m willing to give it another try.
… moreGiving a 3star because the inside atmosphere was nice. Friendly servers. The issue was the food. Ordered steak and eggs, the eggs and potatoes were good, the steak, not so much. I asked for medium, they gave me well done. And I would hardly call it a steak. There was more fat than meat. But I’m willing to give it another try.
Cindy Faller
Delicious, and I swear that Einstein, or his doppelganger was seated next to us the day we ate there! I had the fish and Mac n Cheese side. My husband enjoyed the largest grilled chicken sandwich ever served him. Great service at this little eatery in this tiny town.
… moreThis Guy
Been here twice, breakfast and lunch. I ordered a simple well done cheeseburger, it was nearly completely raw, even the waitress said, oh damn. My breakfast was steak and eggs with potatoes, steak was like a tire, potatoes absolutely dry and eggs weren’t near the way I ordered them. Maybe some new cooks would help. Also, they should do something with the look of this place, paint the walls or something, plain white, makes it feel like it’s under construction.
… moreDave Gardner
I’ve always experienced excellent service here. The food is good and the portions are always very good for the money. The main dining room is small but they do have a larger dining room on the other side of the kitchen.
… moreHarley the Beagle & Friends (Harley the Beagle)
First and last time for dining here. Hot chocolate was watered down and pop was flat. The sausage gravy tasted like it came out of a can. Asked for coffee and was charged for it, too! Menu doesn’t have a lot of options.
… moredane johnson
Took an hour and a half to get food, wanted my burger med rare came back burnt. Would of had them take it back but didn’t have another hour to wait, appetizers came after we were done eating our entree. Server was pleasant.
… moreDanielle Thompson
I never leave hungry and the food is always good. My only criticism of the place is about the odd mix of Western decor alongside English riding tack. It seems like they tried to go with a country western theme, but did not have a lot of knowledge about horse tack.
… moreRandall Sparks
Seriously? Where do the 4 and 5 star reviews come from. I gave them 2 chances for dinner. Tonight, I had the open faced roast beef. It was so over-cooked, dry, and tough that it was inedible.
Breakfast is usually ok. Hence, the 2 stars.
… moreBreakfast is usually ok. Hence, the 2 stars.