Kimverli Halili
Got the craiglist.com and only pans 14 inches for both. Saw the video by Dave Portnoy Barstool pizza review – one bite pizza reviews on youtube and we had to give it a try! We are so glad we did place our order in this exclusive pizza place
The crust, explosion of flavors and how they complement each other.. everything is perfect! Would definitely try the other types that they sell next time.
Definitely worth the drive, wait, and money!
… moreJessica Lundy
I have to say, exceptional pizza and customer service! My cousin introduced me to Milly’s back in June, and it’s the best pizza I’ve ever had. The flavor profile and crust were out of this world. Just straight perfection. This morning, I ordered the same pizza so a friend flying into town could try it, but his flight was canceled this evening. Since I live over an hour from Berwyn, I called and left a voicemail to see if I could cancel the order. The person who called me back (Daniel) was incredibly kind and understanding. He even apologized about the flight cancellation, which was so thoughtful. He had already canceled and refunded the order before reaching out. I will absolutely be ordering from Milly’s again whenever I am back in the area south of O’Hare!
… moreR L
Honestly it might be the best pizza I’ve ever had. But for different reasons than usual. The combination of flavors and toppings is just unreal. I’ve watched so many people say things like “each bite is a journey” when eating fancy foods and I never understood what they meant. Well now I do. Every single bite of this pizza is an adventure and every bite is different. The way these flavors combine is just the best thing I’ve ever had. The charred pepperoni, the carmelozed crust, the plump tomatos, ricotta with a hint of spice. Pesto. The way the pizza stays together. I was wondering why the hell I paid $30 for a ten inch pizza but now I’m wondering why I didn’t do it sooner. This is both the most beautiful looking pizza and most beautiful tasting pizza I’ve ever had
… morePaulina Pinzon
I finally remembered to place an order at 8 am to be able to place an order before orders were fulfilled for the day. I placed the pick up order to be ready at 6:00 pm. I was wondering a bit late but didn’t think anything of it because the website states they’re opened until 8. Well I got a call at 6:15 to remind me of my order and asked when I would be picking up because they were closing in 15 minutes. I communicated to the employee I was on my way and it would take me about 15 minutes to get there so asked if they would be open until I got there since they should be open until 8 according to their site. I was told yes, and they’re usually open until 8 but they closing early for Halloween, which is fine but I think that should have been communicated before. The pizza was good, a little soggy in the middle. Also comes uncut so would recommend requesting to be cut.
… moreAlec Cepak
All of the different pizzas we got were 2 things. First they were delicious, and secondly they were all works of art. The amount of care and time put into these amazing pizzas really shows. This was our first time trying Milly’s and will not be the last.
… moreBharat Walia
Hands down one of the best pizzas in Chicago.
Had the Clickbait and it superseded expectations.
This pizza rescues deep dish pizza from the attacks of its too heavy and a total pie. Milly’s circumvents the heaviness of typical deep dish pizza with how light the crust is made and the way the cheeses are layered so as not to bog it down.
The flavors, sauces are all incredible. Can’t wait to be back.
… moreB B
We ordered three different pizzas and they were all DELICIOUS!! The toppings, the crust, amazing! The staff was very friendly as well! Can’t wait to order from here again 🙂
… moreDave L
I wasn’t sure if this would live up to the original location I had years ago. It did. One of the best pizzas I have ever had and isn’t close. For those complaining about how hard it is to order because it sells out that is because they are making incredible pizza. I had wondered if you could sit inside and eat as I saw some stools. You can’t it is take out only no dine in although there may be local delivery. That said plenty of places nearby to park and eat if you drove far just bring a decent knife and some paper plates. Altogether outstanding pizza and one of my favorites in Chicago along with Vito and Nicks.
… moreAl Gonzalez
First time order, forever customer. The pizza and ingredients combinations are superb. The cheeses and sausage are delicious and unique in flavor. The pizza bread is just perfect in thickness and flavor. Way better than Fre$$’s pies. Not sure why the owners don’t expand in service and hours.
… moreMartina Marcin
I don’t get it in terms of the hype. Pricey – about $40 for a pizza off the menu. The toppings were good, but the crust and dough were not remarkable, not very seasoned and therefore I don’t understand why their pizza is so highly reviewed. The pepperoni was good. Images attached.
… more