Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Related Web Results
Italian Pizza and Subs Wilson NC | Italian Restaurant serving Quality …
We are Italian Pizza and Subs. New York style pizza cooked on a real stone oven. Authentic Italian food cooked in our show kitchen. Come in for a party or a …
Italian Pizza & Subs, 3711 Peppermill Dr N, Wilson, NC 27896, US
Italian Pizza & Subs is a family-oriented restaurant located in Wilson, North Carolina, specializing in New York-style pizza cooked in a real stone oven and …
Italian Pizza & Subs Delivery Menu | 700 US-301 Wilson – Grubhub
Order delivery or pickup from Italian Pizza & Subs in Wilson! View Italian Pizza & Subs’s March 2026 deals and menus. Support your local restaurants with …
Reviews
Mike Germann
Delicious meatball parm sub sandwich special with fries and a drink for less than $11. Great bread, nice and airy with a light snap and crust. Good meatballs, homemade. Good sauce, again scratch made. Lots of melty cheese and a good portion. Fries were typical but nice and hot. They serve Pepsi (I’m a coke fan myself). Will go again, hear from friends that the lasagna is fantastic.
… moreTarek Alshamy
Very delicious food And the good service also the price fair
… morePeter Herrington
Ordered a small Italian pizza and large Neapolitan pizza. The small Italian pizza costs the same as the large Neapolitan pizza. There wasn’t one bit of difference between the two. Both were thin, greasy, and undercooked. Sauce and crust had zero flavor. Save your money and go with a frozen pizza instead of this place!
… moreJenna Pate
Food is always great. Call and check that they’re open. Showed up an hour before closing per the time on the door and the time listen online and were told they are closed.
… moreA Zuluaga
Service was good. My sub was good. The pizza was soggy crust was too soft I think it needed a few minutes more in oven. I like a crisp crust. But I will go back.
… moreAlexis
Best food in all of Wilson – I cannot even begin to explain how phenomenal the pizza was. The crust was perfection, the sauce was perfectly seasoned and the mushrooms were the best I’d ever had. The entire staff was so kind and considerate to slice my toddler’s pizza for her.
… morejakespop67
Being originally from N.J. I always thought this place was the closest in taste to Yankee pizza ! It was my Go To with the original owner and original crew ! When they first changed hands I tried it ! I thought the pizza was too doughy so I would go all the way to Peppermill from Stantonsburg ! Last night we decided to give them another chance after years of bypassing this place . I am so glad we did ! I apologize for my stubbornness but in my defense I am a loyal person ! I wish they would spruce up the place but that is not on them ! That is on Wilson County powers that be for letting certain parts get dilapidated while pouring monies into other parts ! I thought we were in this together ?
Yours truly ,
Jody L. MF Scheer
… moreYours truly ,
Jody L. MF Scheer
L J
I visited the store on 301. I ordered and once I arrived, I found that the prices posted online were incorrect. The person who waited on me stated that I’d probably seen old pricing. When I mentioned that the online pricing was different, he said that the online pricing wasn’t for the their store. How was I to know (because when i clicked on the menu associated with the 301 location, the menu by which I used to order, was displayed)? I paid with cash and then came back in for more clarification on the pricing discrepancy. When I asked for a receipt, the person with whom I spoke seemed agitated. He then showed me the handwritten changes made in the laminated menus kept on the counter. The food was hot, as usual, but the sauce, noodle, cheese combination tasted spoiled. The elderly gentleman was quite nice and suggested that I take a picture of the menu with my camera. After trying to force myself to eat (because I’ve never had bad food from either location), I threw away the food and decided count my losses and find another spot for my pasta.
… moreVasti Formica
Great service! Excellent pizza, slices are huge and delicious! Really tastes like NY pizza. Also their tables were clean, nothing worse than eating on a dirty table. Overall thumbs up!
… moreLogan Long
Pretty rude individuals answering the phone. Called once and was put on hold. Understandable, especially considering everything going on. After waiting on the phone for 7 minutes. The guy clicks back over and hangs up in seconds. Call right back and immediately get put on hold again. When answering the second time, the guy was very rude in his tone and response. No need in ordering anything at that point. Some people just shouldn’t work in anything dealing with customer service. Don’t recommend dealing with this. Too many other choices.
… more