Meghan McMullen
Hands down the best corned beef and coleslaw sandwich ever! I have been getting the #6 for years, it’s amazing every time. The only complaint I ever had was that it was too big, I could never finish it! I did notice that they now offer 1/2 a sandwich, I’ll definitely be going that route next time. I recommend Siegels to everyone looking for a good sandwich, they’re simply the best. Pictured below is the #6 Soni.
… moreE Grace
Recently went and had the turkey corned beef salad( chopped) -Sooooo good-enough for two meals-
Wow! It’s been about three years since we visited. We used to visit at least twice a month and then Covid came and when we returned after they first opened, it definitely was struggling and our experience was pretty bad-
Well, our visit here last week was great. The food was on point. The only reason I couldn’t give a five stars because the potato salad wasn’t the same as what it used to be. It was way too sweet and a little too wet. My go to was always the Reuben and potato salad. This time, I tried the corned beef and turkey grilled on rye and it was perfect. They get points for actually using bread that is full size and not giving you a full-size piece on one side and a small tiny piece on the other side-The corn beef was flavorful and so tender it melted in your mouth. They use fresh roasted turkey. They give you quite a bit of meat on the sandwich as compared to some places who charge the same price if not more—
Our waitress was so nice and attentive – I was surprised they weren’t busier considering it was around dinner time, but maybe they close earlier and their rush is earlier in the afternoon -we definitely will be back. They are on our restaurant rotation.
… moreAlexandra Caruso
$16 for an egg salad sandwich with absolutely zero seasoning. Not my fav. Pickles were awesome tho
Also charged me 50 cents for lettuce which is just kinda strange
… moreTyrone Williams
I was doordashing on the order. They had ran out of and item. The customer request.
One of these staff offer to speak with the customer and together they worked out. A very nice replacement, needless to say, the customer were very satisfied and thank me with a generous tip. A few days later I came back with my wife for a Birthday Brunch. We got even a better level of service. I tip my hat to the owner and outstanding staff.
… moreNikki Marku
An hour drive and worth every minute! The sandwiches at Siegel’s Deli are incredible. The staff was so kind and attentive, and the whole experience was wonderful. Highly recommend!
… moreCharles Vickers
In town for business was looking for a good sun shop or deli and had passed by Siegel’s earlier in the way to an appointment so I looked up the address and made it back about an hour before they closed. They had some regular customers and were winding down a bit but several other people came in and ate after I did. Atmosphere was average to above average but that is not a major factor to me. I ordered the Reuben with pastrami. Stacked high, the pastrami was great!! Tasted almost like thinly sliced brisket! Good smokey flavor. The sauerkraut was not to heavy and the sandwich included Swiss cheese. Also had a salad which was huge – wish they offered a more traditional small side salad but it was very good!! Enjoyed some thick cut “steak fries” and then I heard another waitress offer another customer the option of waffle fries which I would have preferred.
… moreJulie McBride
Rice Pudding consistency is soup. It is clearly not pudding. Store manager was rude, requested a refund. It’s now in the trash.
… moreVinny Gjokaj
My absolute go to Demi when I’m in the area, I always get the Ruben. Very fresh, definitely home made corned beef. I also got cabbage soup and it was also very good. Great prices and large portions.
… moreBarry August
Just had the worst corned beef sandwich I have ever had. It was so salty that it tasted like someone poured a bunch of salt on it. Also there were really only a few real pieces and the rest was like it was chopped up. Maybe it was sliced incorrectly. Needless to say I threw it out. I have eaten there before and everything was great. Something very wrong today.
… moreChristopher Schrader
I went to Siegel’s Deli thinking it was going to be a traditional jewish deli. I ordered Matzo ball soup. It was the most bland soup I’ve ever had. My son’s club sandwhich was OK but overall this place is just average. I left quite disappointed.
… more