Social Profile: 
![]()
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
At Papa Johns Pizza in Lake Mary, FL, it’s our goal to always bring you Better Ingredients. Better Pizza. Whether it’s our signature sauce, toppings, or fresh, original dough, we invest in our ingredients to ensure you have the best Lake Mary pizza for any occasion. Call us for pizza delivery in Lake Mary or stop by 4300 Lake Mary Blvd for carryout to order the best pizza in Lake Mary, along with breadsticks, wings, and more!
Pizza take-out & delivery chain offering classic & specialty pizzas, plus wings, sides & desserts.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 4300 W Lake Mary Blvd, Lake Mary, FL 32746
Phone: (407) 829-7272
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Related Web Results
Papa Johns Pizza Lake Mary Blvd
At Papa Johns Pizza in Lake Mary, FL, it’s our goal to always bring you Better Ingredients. Better Pizza. Whether it’s our signature sauce, toppings, …
papa johns stores in lake mary, fl
Browse all Papa Johns Pizza locations in Lake Mary, Florida to order pizza, breadsticks, wings and more for delivery or takeout near you.
Papa Johns Pizza West Lake Mary Blvd
Call Papa Johns West Lake Mary Blvd at (407) 328-7272 for more information or to place a catering order today. How do I join Papa Johns Rewards? Earn Papa Dough …
Last Updates
Reviews
Nick
Faith did an absolutely phenomenal job on my carry out pizza that I ordered!! It was loaded with flavor, the cheese ACTUALLY had a legit cheese pull, AND she was kind as can be!! This location is doing amazing work if you ask me. Great job!!
… moreHarry Ochoa
Lunch Break Gone Wrong
I stopped in for a pizza during my lunch break, with plenty of time to spare since I get an hour. After ordering and paying, the clerk said it would take 10-15 minutes, which was perfectly fine.
A few minutes later, I was told the payment was still pending. I scanned my card again, but it was still pending on their end. To double-check, I called my bank. They confirmed the payment had gone through and even provided a transaction ID, which I showed the clerk. Their only solution was to ask me to wait while they made the pizza, hoping their system would catch up.
After waiting for another 15-20 minutes, I asked if my pizza was ready. To my surprise, the manager informed me they had cancelled the order because the payment was still pending on their screen. I showed them the bank’s confirmation again, but they refused to acknowledge it.
What bothered me the most was that they could have told me about the cancellation much earlier, instead of making me wait for so long. I left without my pizza, frustrated and now on the phone with my bank to get my money back.
… moreI stopped in for a pizza during my lunch break, with plenty of time to spare since I get an hour. After ordering and paying, the clerk said it would take 10-15 minutes, which was perfectly fine.
A few minutes later, I was told the payment was still pending. I scanned my card again, but it was still pending on their end. To double-check, I called my bank. They confirmed the payment had gone through and even provided a transaction ID, which I showed the clerk. Their only solution was to ask me to wait while they made the pizza, hoping their system would catch up.
After waiting for another 15-20 minutes, I asked if my pizza was ready. To my surprise, the manager informed me they had cancelled the order because the payment was still pending on their screen. I showed them the bank’s confirmation again, but they refused to acknowledge it.
What bothered me the most was that they could have told me about the cancellation much earlier, instead of making me wait for so long. I left without my pizza, frustrated and now on the phone with my bank to get my money back.
Tiffany Borges
Clean restaurant, friendly staff, and accurate orders!Our order is always fresh and hot, topped and baked to perfection! The consistency of their quality and value keep us coming back. We enjoy the classics on the menu but the team always gets our custom orders right too!
… moreK L
Ordered our pizza at 3:00 for 5:00 delivery
5:37 pizza not here and update shows driver will make one stop before ours. We called and the person that answered said let me get my manager. Woman gets on the phone starts telling us about how they are short handed, they are unloading a truck. Excuse after excuse a customer does not want to hear excuses. My husband kept asking can I plz speak and she kept going on and on finally she said yes you can speak then said but you weren’t quite while I was trying to explain our structure. She hung up and pizza was delivered 45 min late and crust was burnt. This person does not need to be in a managerial position she was awlful. Get it together and retrain. Will never deal with this store again!!
… more5:37 pizza not here and update shows driver will make one stop before ours. We called and the person that answered said let me get my manager. Woman gets on the phone starts telling us about how they are short handed, they are unloading a truck. Excuse after excuse a customer does not want to hear excuses. My husband kept asking can I plz speak and she kept going on and on finally she said yes you can speak then said but you weren’t quite while I was trying to explain our structure. She hung up and pizza was delivered 45 min late and crust was burnt. This person does not need to be in a managerial position she was awlful. Get it together and retrain. Will never deal with this store again!!
Abigail Wright
Love Papa John’s and this location never misses! The manager, Charley, is kind and poised and understood that I was hungry when calling this evening to ask about my delivery!
… moreJacob Oneill
Ordered a pizza here that wasint cut when we got to the park we had to tare our pizza and it was so messy. Called and they gave me a pizza on them next order….. for it to not be cut again…. its funny but frustrating.
… moreRoberto Aciel Lorenzo
This pizzeria is super bad, extremely slow. If you take Uber or Dordash, I don’t recommend it, as you can wait more than 20 minutes for your order. In short, I give it a star. I don’t recommend it for anyone.
… moreMoises Rodriguez
Delivery pick up Staff playing around not working 1:25 till 1:57 and my Pizza was done since I arrived but, the guy completly ignored me and didn’t hand me my order. Just to be playing and chatting with the girl co-worker.
… moreF Rodriguez
Shoutout to the employee working the front last night around 630pm when I was there. Place was packed busy for halloween and despit several impatient customers who were very rude, this employee was able to stand there and keep their cool amongst the amount of orders that they had last night
… moreCam
It had been a while since I last ordered from Papa Johns, so I decided to give it another shot. Overall, it was decent. The cheese and sauce had good flavor, but the toppings were noticeably sparse, which was super disappointing.
What stood out to me most, though was the extra charge of 99 cents for the sauce cups. For the price of the pizza, I can’t believe these aren’t included. Charging nearly a dollar for a small sauce is ridiculous.
The pizza itself was fine, but nothing special. I likely won’t return unless it’s one of my only options.
… moreWhat stood out to me most, though was the extra charge of 99 cents for the sauce cups. For the price of the pizza, I can’t believe these aren’t included. Charging nearly a dollar for a small sauce is ridiculous.
The pizza itself was fine, but nothing special. I likely won’t return unless it’s one of my only options.