Social Profile: 
![]()
✔️Breakfast ✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 254 Bellevue Ave, Montclair, NJ 07043
Phone: (973) 337-6275
Website: http://www.mattarellobakery.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Mattarello Bakery & Café: Home
Italian bakery and coffee shop in Montclair, NJ. We offer best lobster tails, donuts, cannoli, coffee, cake and ship nationwide!
Mattarello Bakery & Café – Italian Desserts NJ (@mattarellobakery)
7.5K+ followers · 509 posts · Authentic Italian Bakery & Cafe Viral gooey cookies • Fresh Pastries Nationwide Shipping ✨Tag us to be featured!
Mattarello Bakery & Café – Montclair, NJ | joe coffee
Mattarello Bakery & Café in Montclair, New Jersey. 4.5 stars (246 reviews). Cafe. Hours, menu, photos & directions.
Reviews
Honest Review
I am quite disappointed on what i have brought to my friends house as some sweets to enjoy for the night. My wife & I walk into the cafe hoping to get delicious pastries & we were greeted by a young lady who was patient with me being picky & asking questions. I wanted to make sure the things i bring to someones house was worth it, tasted & looked good. She was very accommodating which is a 10/10 service. We had chosen a chocolate muse cake, i believe lobster tail, cheesecake which was horrendous, lotus cookie, & tiramisu. My wife chose the cheesecake in order to be “safe” BOYYYYYYY how that went south very quickly when we tried jt. They all look very beautifully put together but when we tried the pastries we were disappointed as well as our friends. We had tried the chocolate muse which was fluffy rich & smooth which everyone liked & we were excited for the rest. We then try the tiramisu which was more jello like & jiggly & did not look so appealing. Everyone was not a fan…
We then wanted the balance of a safe on so we try the cheesecake & as we bit with it it was crumbly & we thought it was a plane cheesecake but it had like a nasty lemon flavor to it. We all spit it out. I am not trying to be rude or anything of that sort but i have been to many many places & tried many foods but by far this one really made my stomach unwell. We then move onto lobster tail with the cream inside. The cream was soft & very light but the pastry was not crispy & actually very stale which again another disappointment infront of our friends we were embarrassed. We didnt even know what to tell them. We spent $33 on this box of nothing i could have spent elsewhere & had a better experience. We finally had a lotus cookie which was in second place to all these pastries. It tasted like lotus crunchy & soft no comment on that. I believe the pastries need to be worked on ALOT but as of right now it would def not be my go to for sweets. We shall come once again to try the place in the future & update.
… moreWe then wanted the balance of a safe on so we try the cheesecake & as we bit with it it was crumbly & we thought it was a plane cheesecake but it had like a nasty lemon flavor to it. We all spit it out. I am not trying to be rude or anything of that sort but i have been to many many places & tried many foods but by far this one really made my stomach unwell. We then move onto lobster tail with the cream inside. The cream was soft & very light but the pastry was not crispy & actually very stale which again another disappointment infront of our friends we were embarrassed. We didnt even know what to tell them. We spent $33 on this box of nothing i could have spent elsewhere & had a better experience. We finally had a lotus cookie which was in second place to all these pastries. It tasted like lotus crunchy & soft no comment on that. I believe the pastries need to be worked on ALOT but as of right now it would def not be my go to for sweets. We shall come once again to try the place in the future & update.
Antonia Taggart
Stopped in for birthday treats for my husband and was immediately greeted and helped. Friendly staff was helpful in letting us know what was in the pastry case. The prices were a bit high (we got 2 mini cheesecakes, and a tiramisu for almost $23), but the cheesecake was great and had a hint of lemon that really hit the spot. The tiramisu was also really good and not super heavy. Overall I would go back!
… moreJennifer Marino
I had an order sent to my daughter at MCU for Valentine’s Day. Sending anything to college dorms can be risky – sometimes other students take orders that aren’t theirs, and sometimes the driver gets lost – but they made sure the order was placed in my daughter’s hands. The woman on the phone was very sweet and patient and ensured my daughter would receive her order. The chocolate covered strawberries look amazing. I highly recommend them!!! I can’t wait to visit there in person one day.
… moreKhara Kelsch
You have to make a stop at Mattarellos! It’s the only Italian bakery in town and their treats are top notch. We absolutely love their cannolis and their pumpkin pie is a seasonal must-have.
One of the things we appreciate most is their wide selection of gluten-free and dairy-free options. It’s rare to find a bakery that offers both incredible traditional treats and such thoughtful allergen-friendly choices without compromising on flavor.
The quality is consistently outstanding, the staff is always friendly, and everything feels made with care. Highly recommend!
… moreOne of the things we appreciate most is their wide selection of gluten-free and dairy-free options. It’s rare to find a bakery that offers both incredible traditional treats and such thoughtful allergen-friendly choices without compromising on flavor.
The quality is consistently outstanding, the staff is always friendly, and everything feels made with care. Highly recommend!
Gabe K
The food is good service is nice. So a decided to take some pastries home. They put it in a box and a paper bag. I live 15 min away. See what happened to them. Today is Rosh Hashanah – Jewish New year. I am invited to a festive dinner and this was what I wanted to bring. See photos and judge yourselves!
… moreTerri Tat
I chose Mattarello Bakery for a Birthday Canolli Cake. I wanted one that was authentic like we use to have. They did not dissapoint.
It was absolutely beautifully done and tasted amazing. I chose a specific day and time and had it delivered.
It was on time and beuatiful.
It was the best we ever had. Thank you.
… moreIt was absolutely beautifully done and tasted amazing. I chose a specific day and time and had it delivered.
It was on time and beuatiful.
It was the best we ever had. Thank you.
Anna Ul
Such a beautiful and welcoming place. We stopped by to get a birthday cake for my daughter and decided to stay there to continue celebration with the cake and the candles. The host was very welcoming and helped us with lighting up the cake sparkles. The bakery had a big selection of cakes, pastries and other bakery items. It is also very aesthetically pleasing! We ended up taking a lot of beautiful pictures.
… moreMike Ramos
I came here this past Sunday on the 19th to the bakery. The community was beautiful. The atmosphere was nice and the diverse culture in town was a breath of fresh air. I came into the bakery and it is such a beautiful bakery with lots of varieties and selections, but two inexperienced young men The customer service was great. The seating area was plenty, but the selections were horrible. I chose the cheesecake which was absolutely disgusting and I have had cheesecake from all over the world and this place was by far the worst the cheesecake taste like processed lemon juice. It had no sugar in it, and it was hard. I chose the lobster tail pastry and the cookie the cookie was tart and flavorless and the lobster tail filling custard was overpowered with almond extract and no sugar. I kindly went up to the associate, and I explained to him in a low voice that it wasn’t good at all, and that they should consider changing the ingredients in the product. He was respectful and apologized, but didn’t come up with a solution or a refund of any kind which I wasn’t expecting, but I felt that it was the most justified thing to do because I didn’t finish it. I feel they need to change bakers or add people from the outside. These were two young men that were Not from this country Who I guess open up a little business and is trying to make it and I am not trying to shoot the business down because it’s a nice business but the pastry selections there are disgusting. The only thing that’s good is the coffee because you can’t mess that up
… moreJay Smith
A really nice bakery and cafe with a wide assortment of baked goods and some meals. The raspberry filled donuts and custard filled donuts are delicious. The tiramisu is also very good. The prices are very high, a single donut is $4, but the quality of the baked goods seems excellent and I assume the rent in this area is high. Staff was friendly and helpful.
… moreCarly
I’m a Vermont wedding planner and always refer my clients to Mattatello. Alma never disappoints with her beautifully designed cakes and equally as delicious desserts. I feel confident sending my clients to her and know they will be in amazing hands. I’ve ordered from her numerous times for both my business and my own children’s birthday cakes. Always happy with the outcome!
… more