Social Profile: 
✔️Breakfast ✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
In the heart of downtown, we are proud to have a footprint here in St. Augustine, Florida. We love to serve our community and visitors from around the world. We aim to provide an unparalleled experience serving delectable cuisines and handcrafted cocktails; all made fresh with the highest quality ingredients. We serve breakfast, lunch, and dinner. Our Mexican restaurant serves tacos, seafood, and all our your favorite. Our Margaritas are always made with fresh ingredients. You can sit on our outdoor patio and enjoy live music, on our balcony overlooking hypolita street, in our indoor dining area, or at one of our three tequila bars. Don’t forget to get an app from our raw bar that serves fresh oysters.
Cozy house-turned-restaurant dispatching upmarket Latin dishes inside or on its patio & terrace.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 22 Hypolita St, St. Augustine, FL 32084
Phone: (904) 823-0787
Website: http://casamayasta.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Reservations: spotapps.co
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Casa Maya Mexican Restaurant Downtown St Augustine Seafood …
In the heart of downtown, you can enjoy live music on our patio, tacos at our tequila bar, fresh seafood on our balcony or your favorite mexican food …
Food Menu – Casa Maya
Consumption of raw or undercooked meat, poultry, eggs, or seafood may increase the risk of foodborne illness. Alert your server if you have special dietary …
Casa Maya | Saint Augustine FL – Facebook
Casa Maya, Saint Augustine. 4728 likes · 16 talking about this · 26810 were here. Healthy, Ethnic, And Eclectic Eating.
Last Updates
Reviews
Tamika Lecheé Morales
Absolutely loved this place. Loved the food specifically the Mayan Soup and the Yucatan Salad was so tasty! I’ve been thinking about it for days after!!! The flavors were amazing.
My guests really enjoyed their meals as well. The carnitas, chicken fajitas and the green burrito.
The salsa and guacamole are outstanding!
The ambiance and service were fantastic! The waiter was the highlight of the experience. Highly recommend and I can’t wait to return to eat there again!
… moreMy guests really enjoyed their meals as well. The carnitas, chicken fajitas and the green burrito.
The salsa and guacamole are outstanding!
The ambiance and service were fantastic! The waiter was the highlight of the experience. Highly recommend and I can’t wait to return to eat there again!
Snigdha Agarwal
Such a lovely, warm vibe here — especially with the live music on a Saturday afternoon! Our table was a bit rickety and placed next to some stagnant water, which wasn’t ideal, but the atmosphere still carried the experience nicely.
They had about 3–4 vegetarian options, and here’s how they ranked for us:
✅ Garden Burrito – Absolutely delicious. The side sauce was perfectly tangy and full of flavor.
✅ Mayan Soup – A unique and refreshing offering, light and perfect if you’re in the mood for something simple.
✅ Spinach & Mushroom Quesadilla – Generous portion and quite flavorful.
Guacamole – We’ve had better, but it was still enjoyable.
Overall, a wonderful spot for a relaxed, satisfying lunch.
… moreThey had about 3–4 vegetarian options, and here’s how they ranked for us:
✅ Garden Burrito – Absolutely delicious. The side sauce was perfectly tangy and full of flavor.
✅ Mayan Soup – A unique and refreshing offering, light and perfect if you’re in the mood for something simple.
✅ Spinach & Mushroom Quesadilla – Generous portion and quite flavorful.
Guacamole – We’ve had better, but it was still enjoyable.
Overall, a wonderful spot for a relaxed, satisfying lunch.
Francesca Adue
Wow! I had the Chipotle Maya here and it was absolutely amazing! I ordered the spice level 2 and it was the perfect amount of spice. The flan was the best I’ve had so very tasty. Enrique gave some great recommendations and was very attentive! Highly recommend eating here. The photo is just a half portion because I split it with someone.
… moreDarshan Patel
Very fast service. Our server was really quick with drinks and food. Chips and guacamole very fresh and very flavorful. Really fresh, flavourful food. Lots of vegetarian options.
… moreSean Schuster
Food was fantastic. Vibe was perfectly curated with the live musician and outdoor lighting. Great customer service. Staff came by and took a photo and provided a nice free postcard! 10/10 would recommend
… moreNina Cash
Wanted to find a place for lunch with a nice atmosphere and good Mexican food.
I stumbled upon this place on my walk touring the town. I heard some music and walked in to a fun and beautiful place with lots of outdoor seating.
I sat at the bar and a young girl greeted me right away and eventually a guy named Christian came and took over. They were very friendly and she recommended I get the pork carnita. My first bite of the pork took me back to only one other place of when I had something similar. It was so delicious and I thoroughly enjoyed it! Great place to have lunch or just hang out and have a cocktail while listening to some live tunes.
… moreI stumbled upon this place on my walk touring the town. I heard some music and walked in to a fun and beautiful place with lots of outdoor seating.
I sat at the bar and a young girl greeted me right away and eventually a guy named Christian came and took over. They were very friendly and she recommended I get the pork carnita. My first bite of the pork took me back to only one other place of when I had something similar. It was so delicious and I thoroughly enjoyed it! Great place to have lunch or just hang out and have a cocktail while listening to some live tunes.
Hugo Morales
What a gem a little off the beaten path! We made reservations somewhere else and they had 90 minute call ahead wait time which jumped up another hour after we checked in, so we all got a little upset and cancelled it. I turned the corner and ran into this place, we were seated right away and Tyler was our waiter and the service was fantastic along with the food being delicious!
… moreFLParadise
Quaint Mexican restaurant on the main pedestrian Street in St. Augustine. The outside has a great patio and ambiance, inside. It’s basically upstairs in a cozy room. The staff was warm and friendly but found the menu to be a little small. The food was tasty and more authentic. Mexican.
… moreTyler Schmid
Absolutely Incredible!
From the moment I took the first bite, I knew this place was special. The food was bursting with flavor — perfectly seasoned, fresh, and cooked to perfection. Every dish felt carefully crafted, not rushed. The presentation was beautiful, and the portions were generous without sacrificing quality.
The service was just as impressive — friendly, attentive, and genuinely passionate about the food they were serving. You can tell they care about creating a great experience.
Whether you’re grabbing a quick bite or sitting down for a full meal, this spot delivers every time. Easily one of the best dining experiences I’ve had in a long time. Highly recommend!
Cheers!
… moreFrom the moment I took the first bite, I knew this place was special. The food was bursting with flavor — perfectly seasoned, fresh, and cooked to perfection. Every dish felt carefully crafted, not rushed. The presentation was beautiful, and the portions were generous without sacrificing quality.
The service was just as impressive — friendly, attentive, and genuinely passionate about the food they were serving. You can tell they care about creating a great experience.
Whether you’re grabbing a quick bite or sitting down for a full meal, this spot delivers every time. Easily one of the best dining experiences I’ve had in a long time. Highly recommend!
Cheers!
Dianna B
If you’re just having drinks, outdoor bar is a decent area. We had dinner (6 adults) and tried a few different things on the very odd menu. Food was mostly fresh and decent quality though it wasn’t very flavorful. Fajitas were the best item we tried. It definitely was not the quality expected for the price. Service was decent. Unfortunately, won’t be back.
… more