Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Frosty On The Hill, nestled in Marengo, IN, since 2025, is a cozy American diner offering a mouthwatering array of classic favorites. Our menu features delicious burgers, savory hot dogs, crispy wings, loaded nachos, brick oven pizzas, golden fries, and delectable baked goods. Whether you’re dining in or opting for carryout, our friendly service ensures a delightful experience. Don’t miss out on our tempting weekly specials that add an extra dash of excitement to every visit. Come savor the flavors of Frosty On The Hill, your go-to destination for scrumptious comfort food in the greater Marengo area.
Hours
| Monday | 6 AM–10 PM |
| Tuesday | 6 AM–10 PM |
| Wednesday | 6 AM–10 PM |
| Thursday | 6 AM–10 PM |
| Friday | 6 AM–1 AM |
| Saturday | 6 AM–1 AM |
| Sunday | 6 AM–10 PM |
Menu Photos
Related Web Results
Frosty on the Hill | The Diner Restaurant Experience
Visit Frosty on the Hill for an authentic diner experience. Enjoy our famous ice cream, pizza, and classic American-style food.
Frosty on the hill – Facebook
Frosty on the hill , Marengo. 1993 likes · 9 talking about this. Hello we are an American Diner Restaurant, Ice cream malt shop also a Brick oven…
Frosty On The Hill, 5756 E State Road 64, Marengo, IN 47140, US
Get more information for Frosty On The Hill in Marengo, IN. See reviews, map, get the address, and find directions.
Reviews
Mad Fleetwoodz
Ordered the breaded tenderloin…it was a joke! Very small, thin and burnt! Mushroom and Swiss burger was good. Had to wait an hour for our food. Not impressed….will drive a few miles more to the Curbette next time!
… moreSean Cochran
I ordered a 16″ meat lovers pizza. Pizza was good. No sauce to think of. Topping and seasoning were good. But… My 16″ pizza was in a 14″ box. I measured the pizza. 14″ one way and 12″ the other. Rectangle pizza. So was definitely not what I ordered and not what I paid for.
… moreJennifer Smith
This was awful! We were on our way to an appointment and was terribly hungry. We sat outside for 30 whole minutes and they came out and told us that they were very sorry but that they were out of EVERYTHING! How is a restaurant out of everything? And why would you wait 30 minutes to come out and tell us. So now we are late to appointment and still hungry. You guys should consider closing the doors.
… moreJohn Harmon
Being local and wanting this place to succeed it’s hard to write this review I feel the management needs to hear this.
My wife and I bought two calzones this week and they were supposed to be stuffed with 5 ingredients. What we got were two pieces of dough big enough for a large pizza folded over with maybe three pieces of each ingredient in each.It was basically just a piece of dough.This was disappointing because when they first opened I saw a gentleman eating one that looked delicious and was full of what you would expect one to be.
… moreMy wife and I bought two calzones this week and they were supposed to be stuffed with 5 ingredients. What we got were two pieces of dough big enough for a large pizza folded over with maybe three pieces of each ingredient in each.It was basically just a piece of dough.This was disappointing because when they first opened I saw a gentleman eating one that looked delicious and was full of what you would expect one to be.
Rhonda Bullington
Last week we tried to order food outside and couldn’t get any one to even acknowledge we were there, much less wait on us. We left.
Today we ordered and my sister got her order and finished, I still hadn’t gotten mine so I asked for it to go. That’s when I was told they were out of what I ordered! I asked the waitress why she didn’t tell me that and was told she thought I knew. Really?
… moreToday we ordered and my sister got her order and finished, I still hadn’t gotten mine so I asked for it to go. That’s when I was told they were out of what I ordered! I asked the waitress why she didn’t tell me that and was told she thought I knew. Really?
Stephen Robin
Called in an order for a supreme 14″ pizza and a Super Stromboli. They said 15 min. I live 5 miles away drove there right away was there in 10 min. Max.
Stood at the pick up window for a few min. 4 people saw me and never tried to help, went to the order window again the same, so went inside. A gentleman came to the counter and helped me. He gave me the two boxes. I paid and tipped. He asked me if I would like marinara or garlic butter. I said I would like both please.
I got home with the 2 items and my wife and I sat down to eat. The pizza was very light and was very light on the sauce The toppings were a decent size, cheese pretty light as well. Very utilitarian pizza.
The Super stromboli was a decent look from the outside, the filling was a little light again with light sauce.as I was eating the stromboli acouple of spots had raw dough , not cooked at all.
I really want this place to succeed giving another local option for food. They have a new building, a great parking lot, what appears to be a gas fired brick pizza oven ( one of the few in the area). The kitchen looks clean with newer looking equipment. So for it not to be better makes me think, staff and lack of proper supervision of staff. Those place has potential to be great and I hope that once they are here longer that the issues will be worked out. Will try again once growing pains get resolved.
… moreStood at the pick up window for a few min. 4 people saw me and never tried to help, went to the order window again the same, so went inside. A gentleman came to the counter and helped me. He gave me the two boxes. I paid and tipped. He asked me if I would like marinara or garlic butter. I said I would like both please.
I got home with the 2 items and my wife and I sat down to eat. The pizza was very light and was very light on the sauce The toppings were a decent size, cheese pretty light as well. Very utilitarian pizza.
The Super stromboli was a decent look from the outside, the filling was a little light again with light sauce.as I was eating the stromboli acouple of spots had raw dough , not cooked at all.
I really want this place to succeed giving another local option for food. They have a new building, a great parking lot, what appears to be a gas fired brick pizza oven ( one of the few in the area). The kitchen looks clean with newer looking equipment. So for it not to be better makes me think, staff and lack of proper supervision of staff. Those place has potential to be great and I hope that once they are here longer that the issues will be worked out. Will try again once growing pains get resolved.
Kenneth McSpadden
I really want this place to succeed. I hope they get the kinks worked out. I got a Flaming Yeti burger, onion rings, slaw and a vanilla shake. The shake was good and the onion rings were as well. The burger tasted good, but it had a huge stem of jalapeño on it and the wrong cheese. The slaw was actually spoiled and I threw it away. I waited for over an hour for this carryout and they really weren’t busy.
I had plenty of time to watch how the staff worked and it is vary apparent that everyone is new and maybe not a lot of restaurant experience. One thing that bothered me is they have a window inside for ordering and a window outside, but I saw the young girl make everyone order outside, including an old man who could barely stand.
In summary, you cannot sell spoiled food. Check the dates. The jalapeño I can let slide, but it isn’t great. You really need to speed up your ticket time. I wish I could say the food was great, but it just took a long time to get my food, but that really isnt the case.
… moreI had plenty of time to watch how the staff worked and it is vary apparent that everyone is new and maybe not a lot of restaurant experience. One thing that bothered me is they have a window inside for ordering and a window outside, but I saw the young girl make everyone order outside, including an old man who could barely stand.
In summary, you cannot sell spoiled food. Check the dates. The jalapeño I can let slide, but it isn’t great. You really need to speed up your ticket time. I wish I could say the food was great, but it just took a long time to get my food, but that really isnt the case.
Kayla Crum
went back on a Friday after having gone on a Tuesday before…the staff definitely matters the food was not as good the second time around and we got the same thing. it’s hit or miss but with other options around for less money and less wait time I don’t think I’ll be back.
… moreRobert Ridener
We were fairly disappointed in the burgers and the milkshakes. The burger was burnt and crunchy as well as the bun. And the milkshakes were very runny and tasted like strawberry nestle syrup and milk. Very little ice cream. That said the service was great and the environment was great.
… moreMarquita Meyers
Left without ordering. Was never recognized as a customer although 6 people were standing around. Very disappointed. Live locally and will not be back. Too bad because someone has spent a lot of money on renovating this building.
… more