Social Profile: 
✔️Breakfast ✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 25 Middle Country Rd, Middle Island, NY 11953
Phone: (631) 846-8833
Website: https://luciamiddleisland.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Lucia Middle Island – Food Restaurant
Lucia Middle Island established 2021 by Melvin Recinos and Estela Palacios. Serving you the best fresh authentic Latin food.
Lucia Middle Island – Facebook
Details. . 100% recommend (15 Reviews). . $$. . Closed now. . 25 Middle Country Road, Middle Island, NY, United States, 11953 ; Links. . luciamiddleisland.
Lucia Middle island (@luciamiddleisland) – Instagram
574 followers · 105 posts · Variety of Latin food, freshly made everyday.
Reviews
Alexia Ramirez
!!!!NEVER AGAIN AND NEVER RECOMMEND!!!!
I am a lover of papusas and I wanted to give Lucia’s a try. I received my papusas and they have no vegetables that comes with it and the red sauce is spicy, so I ate one papusa DRY…I can’t even eat anymore of the papusa because it is DRENCHED in grease which made me sick to my stomach(any other place does not drench their papusas in grease). I had also gotten a STEAK quesadilla just for the meat to be ground beef and look like cat food!!! I spent $52 on this just to throw it all out. What a waste of time and money. I should’ve stayed away!!!!!!
… moreI am a lover of papusas and I wanted to give Lucia’s a try. I received my papusas and they have no vegetables that comes with it and the red sauce is spicy, so I ate one papusa DRY…I can’t even eat anymore of the papusa because it is DRENCHED in grease which made me sick to my stomach(any other place does not drench their papusas in grease). I had also gotten a STEAK quesadilla just for the meat to be ground beef and look like cat food!!! I spent $52 on this just to throw it all out. What a waste of time and money. I should’ve stayed away!!!!!!
Whiskey Snobs
Everything I had was delicious. All of the staff are warm and friendly. They really seem like they enjoy being at work and what they do. I’ll always miss The Cook Room, but they did a nice job renovating and creating a delightful atmosphere.
… morekevin
The food was incredible, and they even added fruits on the side. Our server was incredibly friendly and welcoming, definitely coming back here again.
… moreGeorge Ginsburg
Every time we go there, the food is amazing! The food is presented so nicely on rectangular plates, but with exotic garnishes like papaya and seasonal fruits and greens. They use herbs and vegetables that are grown on the property when in season. The portions are more than generous. Very tasty, very good food! Even the coffee, their own blend, is delicious.
… moreDerik G
We went for lunch and had the Cuban sandwich and cheeseburger. The burger was good served with a side of fruit (not great)
The Cuban sandwich was amazing, served with pickled jalapenos and carrots.
The fries was good but not memorable.
This is definitely a great place to enjoy a good meal.
… moreThe Cuban sandwich was amazing, served with pickled jalapenos and carrots.
The fries was good but not memorable.
This is definitely a great place to enjoy a good meal.
R P
I love this place. I call it the little diner that could. Great food, nice atmosphere, and very affordable. I eat here often. Give it a try, you’ll love it, too.
… moreJustin Chuang
Oh wow. I’ve never had a breakfast so good. I had to write a review before I’m even done eating. This chorizo breakfast special is delicious!!! 5/5
* update
I really think this place needs a bigger location with more parking. That’s just how good the food is as well as the quality. Poor souls who haven’t tried this place yet
… more* update
I really think this place needs a bigger location with more parking. That’s just how good the food is as well as the quality. Poor souls who haven’t tried this place yet
Amanda A
This place is the best hidden gem and I don’t want to risk never being able to get a table but I have to brag on them. The food is incredibly fresh and surprisingly elevated. I’ve never ordered anything that isn’t phenomenal and full of flavor. I love their pancakes and anything with their homemade chorizo in it. They have fresh squeezed juices and iced coffee. Don’t sleep on the papusas too! I always look forward to going there becuase the staff is also extremely personable and welcoming.
… moreBen Ericsson
Food is ALWAYS SABROSA! and it actually tastes healthy, always fresh.
… moreIt’s just me
First time coming here.. We loved everything!!
Food is delicious and very good portions.. presentation of food looks yummy.. Ernesto is a lovely helping guy., and the whole atmosphere here is relaxing.
This small restaurant is a gem, Will definetely coming back with family.
… moreFood is delicious and very good portions.. presentation of food looks yummy.. Ernesto is a lovely helping guy., and the whole atmosphere here is relaxing.
This small restaurant is a gem, Will definetely coming back with family.