Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Welcome to our pizzeria, where we serve authentic New York-style pizza, available by the slice or as a whole pie. Our menu features a variety of delicious Italian dishes, from classic pasta to savory appetizers, ensuring there’s something for everyone. Don’t forget to try our crispy wings, tossed in your choice of flavorful sauces. Whether you’re dining in or grabbing a quick bite, we’re dedicated to providing a delicious and satisfying experience.
Hours
| Tuesday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | 2–8 PM |
| Monday | Closed |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 200 S Peterboro St, Canastota, NY 13032
Phone: (315) 697-3993
Website: https://www.facebook.com/NewYorkPizzeriaCanastota/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Joe’s New York Pizzeria – Canastota – Facebook
. 84% recommend (58 Reviews) ; . Closed now ; . 200 S Peterboro St, Canastota, NY, United States, 13032 ; . Canastota, NY …
Order Joe’s New York Pizzeria – Canastota, NY Menu … – DoorDash
Get delivery or takeout from Joe’s New York Pizzeria at 200 S Peterboro St in Canastota. Order online and track your order live. No delivery fee on your …
Delicious Pizza at Joe’s New York Pizzeria in Canastota, NY
Located at 200 S Peterboro St in Canastota, NY, Joe’s New York Pizzeria has become a beloved spot for pizza enthusiasts since its inception.
Reviews
Richard Sharpe
Well once again I’m not going there again. They screwed up another order I had for delivery. So here it is an hour and a half later I had to call them up and find out what was going on. They had my order as pick up. If your not sure ask again people won’t mind. But now going to Sami’s I guess. What a bummer. Why didn’t they call if an order was just sitting there for that long? I guess its not in their job description.
… moreChristopher Graham
Stopped in today been awhile since eating here and wow times have changed… Got lunch special 2slice and drink for $6.50 not bad deal.
Got meat lovers and Cheese slice, now let’s get this review going. Asked for them to be warmed up , that’s didn’t go well at all tossed in quick and barely warmed the slice.
Meat lovers was loaded w toppings but no crisp factor at all on the crust, sauce okay 6.1 at best
Now my favorite slice cheese, sauce average not same as recall understand new owners or what not, dough chewy not crisp throughout it and overall 6.1 still best in Stota but no real competition. This my thoughts and opinions so enjoy
… moreGot meat lovers and Cheese slice, now let’s get this review going. Asked for them to be warmed up , that’s didn’t go well at all tossed in quick and barely warmed the slice.
Meat lovers was loaded w toppings but no crisp factor at all on the crust, sauce okay 6.1 at best
Now my favorite slice cheese, sauce average not same as recall understand new owners or what not, dough chewy not crisp throughout it and overall 6.1 still best in Stota but no real competition. This my thoughts and opinions so enjoy
Billy Sotherden
I was driving a few hours across the state and was looking for a bite to eat along the way.
Came across this pizza spot and pulled in at around noon. I was a little hesitant, because most pizza spots have reheated slices that they put out for lunch.
Joe’s New York Pizza exceeded my expectations. A freshly baked buffalo chicken pizza greeted me, the slice was absolutely perfect. A little heat, wasn’t sloppy and a generous size.
Counter guy was a really nice guy, friendly and talked about his new glasses with enthusiasm. He definitely seemed to enjoy his job, that always makes me like a place more. Wish I remembered his name, but he was a young, trim dude with dark hair. Really made a good impression.
Not a single issue, was in and out and if I’m ever in the area again, I will absolutely stop here for a whole pie.
… moreCame across this pizza spot and pulled in at around noon. I was a little hesitant, because most pizza spots have reheated slices that they put out for lunch.
Joe’s New York Pizza exceeded my expectations. A freshly baked buffalo chicken pizza greeted me, the slice was absolutely perfect. A little heat, wasn’t sloppy and a generous size.
Counter guy was a really nice guy, friendly and talked about his new glasses with enthusiasm. He definitely seemed to enjoy his job, that always makes me like a place more. Wish I remembered his name, but he was a young, trim dude with dark hair. Really made a good impression.
Not a single issue, was in and out and if I’m ever in the area again, I will absolutely stop here for a whole pie.
John Quijano
It would be good if the standard wasn’t to put the toppings under the cheese. When it’s called toppings not underings. And then when you call and complain about it after spending $70 on 2 large pies and 10 wings they tell you “I will make it right next time”. Then next time comes they say ok you get one topping free what a joke.
… moreMichael Eisinger
Gas station pizza is probably better. Got one pizza with pepperoni and one with spinach tomato ricotta because they don’t serve it with broccoli like most places, both were subpar
… moreTevo
In from Flordia for a couples days and was referred to New York Pizzeria by a family member and needles to say I was a bit skeptical as I usually head straight to Slice in Utica to tackle my pizza fix. NY Pizzeria knocked it out of the park with their slices. Amazing flavor profile with just the right amount of crunch. Will definitely be back in the future. Keep up the good work.
… moreDave Arnold
They do not know how to make a Sicilian pizza right. they use to make a very good one but for the past year or so the Sicilian pizza is terrible.. the one I ordered today was so hard it was non eatable . the one I order before this one was 2 regular crust stacked on top of each other and over cooked. There is a certain technique to making and baking a Sicilian pizza and here it’s not done.
… moreAndrew Ianniello
Phenomenal pizza.
Grew up in Syracuse. Have lived in Massachusetts for the last 45 yrs. Was in town for one night. Haven’t had pizza this good in decades. Will definitely get off this exit specifically for this pizza next time, and every time there after, when I’m coming through on 90.
… moreGrew up in Syracuse. Have lived in Massachusetts for the last 45 yrs. Was in town for one night. Haven’t had pizza this good in decades. Will definitely get off this exit specifically for this pizza next time, and every time there after, when I’m coming through on 90.
Cassie Mudge
He put Harry Potter on for my oldest son and let him sit in his spaghetti, they were wonderful. We love this place.
… moreJ B
Pure perfection!! Sweetest owners I have ever met and the food is amazing!! Will definitely be driving the 30 minutes back for more!!
… more