Elaine
Finally had the chance to try this spot in Kearny. It’s difficult to find a decent and affordable spot for Mediterranean food but this one hit the spot! We ordered the beef and lamb gyro and the falafel gyro. Do not skip the hot sauce they provide!! It goes so well with the dishes. The portions were amazing; the pitas came with other toppings beside the main protein.
The service is quick and friendly- the workers were chill and gave us time to decide since it was our first time. The place is cozy and nicely decorated. Everything is labeled and sauces/utensils are accessible to customers.
I’d definitely go back and try the other dishes in this menu
… moreLisa Tampa
Really good food. Lost one ☆ because the tabbouleh was very bland, actually, disappointed. The chicken pita dish was great; fries & hummus, tsiki sauce & their specialty (garlic) sauce were all good. The ingredients were displayed & properly labeled for convenience & boy, were they fresh! Tabbouleh missed the flavor boat for me, not enough feta goodness! Service & atmosphere, 5☆
Would recommend & return. Constructive crit only, guys!
… moreMatt Patterson
As I sit down to eat Athenian fresh for the third night in a row I figured they’ve earned a review. Lol. Delicious, fresh food. Consistent. Staff is always friendly, helpful and patient. Food is so good and even found out they import their deserts from Greece. Definitely get the orange pie!!! Happy this place is nearby. Will continue ordering out and dining in.
… moreV J
Update: please have all of your workers wear gloves before handling food. My fiance goes to pickup often and the last time he went he noticed someone touching the food and other things w their bare hands. Someone else waiting noticed the same, refused the order and walked out! food still tastes good but I’m more hesitant to order now.
We order delivery/pickup. The food is very good and fresh! One of the only restaurants I can order from multiple days in a row.
… moreNathalie
Got a falafel bowl w rice, mixed greens, tomato’s, cucumbers, onions, feta ch, spicy potato’s, tabouli, and the spicy sauce . Everything was so good, filling, and felt like a well balance meal that I came back the next day. Glad I found a new spot near me . Will obv be coming back. I tried the pumpkin spice smoothie, it’s dairy free , but that taste was a bit off for me , tasted minty and has a weird after taste. Won’t get that again but I’ll def be coming back for the bowl . Staff are v friendly and attentive both times I came to eat . Clean space, lots of food & drink options . Like that u can customize ur meal. Vegan friendly options as well.
… moreCoach
This restaurant is by far my favorite in my area! I spend at least $200 A month here for me and my family! Every time I order my Gyro is always packed with meat! And every time I order they never disappoint me with their portion size that’s why I keep coming back affordable great food and healthy!!! Highly recommended! Order the fries and a Gyro and I bet you’ll be back. Thank you for always having fresh food Athenian
… moreNoah Zahran
I do pick up orders many times . workers are kindly and professional. I recommend ordering from here , they have delicious dishes. And this places always clean.
Uber driver
… moreBrigitte Washington
I ordered 2 salads consisting of the same ingredients to be delivered via Uber Eats. The delivered salads were not the same. Both were supposed to have grilled chicken and feta, along with the other veggie ingredients. Both salads had all the veggies requested. One salad included the requested feta and the other salad included the requested chicken. Neither salad was exactly what I ordered. After reading the reviews, I believe Athenian Fresh Grill is ripping off customers who order through the delivery services. If they don’t add requested ingredients, they still get paid and they get to keep the ingredients. Feeling like a fraudulent business strategy…
Update: Really nice of the business to reply, but their reply missed the entire point! My post specifically stated that chicken, which was an added expense, was missing from my order, not tomato or cucumber. I was missing an item that I paid extra to obtain.
… moreKaterina
This is really fresh and delicious! I will definitely order again. It came looking well presented. Well packaged and fast delivery. The fish is crispy and well flavored. I ordered on doordash. I recommend supporting this small business!
… moreJiles Nerahoo
The food here is absolutely fabulous. You cannot go wrong with anything I have yet to be disappointed. Staff is super friendly and food is always fresh and fast.
… more