Holy Chick! Mother Cruster!

  4.7 – 436 reviews   • Chicken restaurant

Social Profile:

✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out Holy Chick! Mother Cruster! 07416

Hours

Monday11 AM–10 PM
Tuesday11 AM–10 PM
Wednesday11 AM–10 PM
Thursday11 AM–10 PM
Friday11 AM–11 PM
Saturday11 AM–11 PM
Sunday11 AM–10 PM

Address and Contact Information

Address: 272 NJ-23, Franklin, NJ 07416

Phone: (973) 209-1525

Website: https://www.facebook.com/share/g/1Fj1KzvhsE/

Menu Photos

Order and Reservations

Order: Order online

order.toasttab.com

Related Web Results

Holy Chick! Franklin Borough NJ | Facebook

Follow our journey as we transform the Old BK Drive Thru in Franklin NJ to Holy Chick!

FRANKLIN… IT’S HAPPENING. Holy Chick! Mother Cruster! opens …

Fries loud enough to violate local ordinances. Mark your calendars. Cancel your plans. Hydrate. Stretch. Repent. 272 NJ-23, Franklin, …

That was some Mother Crustin’ good pizza and chicken! Holy Chick …

… Franklin, NJ #foodreview #pizza #chickensandwich #foodgram # … We’re at Holy Chick Mother Cruster in Franklin, New Jersey. Pickle …

Reviews

Randall Harris
Glad to see this place finally open and thriving. It’s really wild how aggressive the townies were/are on the owner, someone opening an establishment that does offer what other places in the area have but at a higher quality. God forbid theres a wait or the staff are a little laxed (this is a chicken and pizza joint in Franklin, NJ not a 3 star michelin restaurant in NYC). The owner clearly put a lot of thought and money into the interior which should be refreshing for the majority of folks here who dine IN at McDonalds or Dunkin Donuts – good lord.

My wife had the chicken tenders and enjoyed them. I am a pizza guy and it was refreshing to find a nice Detroit style pizza which you don’t find too much of around here as most places just offer greasy cheese slop flavorless dough circles. I got the detroit option twice and the second time it was a little overcooked but I’m not judging this in comparison with the pizza that I’ve consumed around the world, this is going against what’s around.

Now regarding their “Neapolitan” style pies, this was the factor that kept me from going for five stars. Don’t get me wrong, the Margherita was tasty and edible but a proper Neapolitan pizza is light and fluffy, almost delicate. Just google it and notice the crust is like a gently charred pillow of mouthwatering goodness. I take pride in my obsession of true Neapolitan style so I am judging it on my worldly experiences and this did not make the cut. With all due respect – this leans more towards a personal jersey pie with quality ingredients.

My only complaint: SEVERELY DISAPPOINTED IN THE FACT THAT THEY DON’T OFFER FRESH HALAPINYOS!!!!!!! SHAME – SHAME – SHAME!!!!!!!!
… more
Jane Ahmon
Love this new restaraunt! Its phenomenal. The nashville chick sandwich was insanely good. The chicken was crispy and super tender and flavourful, the bread crispy and nice. I was worried the coleslaw would be too tangy but it was not and just creamy and simply perfect. It went so well, and the chick sauce was spicy and delicious. Once the fries were seasoned with salt available, they were super crispy, potatoe-e, and succulent. The tator tots were also surprisingly good. The banana pudding was perfect to top it off!
The prices are really cheap and worth it, and the vibe and atmosphere makes this a proper restaraunt, not a fast food place or diner but a real one with great food.

The food came out quickly, got a table quickly as well despite how crowded it was, the chairs are super fancy and comfortable, love the windows which welcome warm sunlight, great service, and the presentation of the water in a mason jar and the food.
Highly recommend this place and definitely will return!!!!!!!!!!!
… more
Tess Walters
Holy Chick truly goes above and beyond. We’ve been here twice already, and every single time the food, service, and atmosphere have been outstanding. On our second visit, they sold out of their Detroit-style pizza within the first 30 minutes of opening, which honestly speaks volumes. Even better, they were kind enough to let me customize a Neapolitan pizza that would’ve been the “Queen B” Detroit style pizza—that level of service is rare and so appreciated.

The food is delicious and priced fairly, and everything we’ve ordered has come out no more than 10 minutes after we placed our order. For anyone saying they waited forever, that has not been our experience at all.

A special shoutout to Lee, the owner—he is incredibly kind-hearted, loving, and hardworking. He greets everyone who walks in and truly makes you feel welcome. You can tell how much care and passion goes into this place.

All the hate this place is getting really shouldn’t be happening until people actually try the food, meet the managing staff, and understand their mission to give back to the community. Their prices are fair and even less than McDonald’s, Burger King, and Wendy’s in the area, and this is fresh food—not fast food.

Holy Chick is doing it right, and we’ll absolutely be back again and again.
… more
Adam Hansen
TL:DR – Did not live up to all the hype. Food was freshly made, but lacked promised flavors.

Was disappointed when they did not have their own website (for ordering or otherwise), and the online menu they provided through Google had the tagline “Online ordering has been disabled by the business.” So I drove down to go put my order in at the counter.

The first thing I noticed when going in was how it was a little difficult to communicate. There was music blasting over the speakers in the ceiling, and customers had to loudly talk at each other to be heard. I did not regret choosing to get my order to go. The cashier kindly took my order over the noise, and I sat nearby to wait. The arcade other reviews mention is tucked away in the back of the restaurant, by the door that goes outside to the non-ADA compliant bathroom trailer. In about 20 minutes, I got my food and was out the door.

I got the Flight Club of pizza strips (which saves you $0.25 a strip), and Chickmate Fingers. Half of the pizza strip flavors had pepperoni, which I did not want. So I got:
Mother Clucker: chicken with ranch drizzle, and a few bacon bits
Smokeshow: chicken with BBQ sauce drizzle, a few pickled onion strings
Queen B: goat cheese (tasted like mozzarella?) with honey drizzle, a little fig sauce, & a few pieces of very cooked prosciutto
Big Dill: crust, cheese, pickles, a little bit of bacon, and white sauce
Overall these were okay, but underwhelming. Do not let the photo fool you – the pizza box was the size of a vinyl record – each pizza segment was about the size of an index card. Most of the edges were burnt. These were fine, but I would not get them again. The “best” out of the ones I got was the Smokehouse, due to the pickled onions.

The Chickmate Fingers I got were “Medium” level – they said they do not offer “Hot” Level anymore. They were on the small side, and very weakly seasoned. If not for the container of MC Sauce included, they would not have tasted like much. The “Texas toast” was a slice of potato bread lightly toasted on one side – no butter or garlic. It was basically a slice of bread. If I were to get these again, I would need to rely on ordering different sides of sauce for flavor.

Overall: disappointing. Would go with friends who have never been there just so they can have their own experiences, but otherwise probably will not be back.
… more
Silvia Kieselat
Holy smokes this restaurant is definitely one of the best in town! Let’s start with staff being super friendly and attentive the second we stepped in. Food came to our table in a reasonable manner and oh boy delicious is an understatement. We had pizza, chicken tenders, fries and a complementary cheese bread. We highly recommend it.
… more
Cat Chez
Holy Chick! Franklin Borough NJ
“A” mazingly delicious – left there so full and ordered more food to bring home for later.
Very cool vibe, excellent food. And the Detroit pizza did not disappoint, already thinking about the next one I want to try. You can even build your own. Great service super friendly staff and the owner, Lee is personable and really knows what he’s doing. We are so grateful to have Holy Chick in our neighborhood. Witnessed other guest devouring their food, chicken and waffles is definitely on my next time list which was highly recommended by the guy at the next table. Took home another staple to eat later, the Nashville Chicken Sandwich n some garlic Parmesan wings. Salads look great as well. A restaurant to frequent often!!
Yay!! — in Franklin.
… more
Catherine Mathews
First time here tonight and WOW—we absolutely loved it! From the start, we were told there would be about a 50-minute wait for food, but a table was available right away, which we were totally fine with. Honestly, the time flew by. Between the games, claw machines (which I definitely couldn’t resist ), and TVs playing NFL games, there was plenty to keep us entertained.

We ordered Flight Club with the Eliot, Mother Cruster, Big Dill, and Smoke Show, plus the Chickmate Nashville and Chickmate Hot Honey with signature fries. Everything was incredible. The Eliot and Mother Cruster were my top favorites, but the Smoke Show and Big Dill were right behind them. The chicken was cooked perfectly—crispy, crunchy, and still juicy inside—with bold, delicious flavors. The signature sauce is AMAZING. We honestly didn’t even need the fries, but they were great too.

Dessert sealed the deal. The banana pudding was hands down the best I’ve ever had—fresh bananas made all the difference—and the chocolate shake was fantastic. I also loved the mason jar-style glasses with handles such a fun, unique touch.

What truly made this experience special was the personal service. The owner, Lee, came out to our table to introduce himself and later checked back in to see how everything was. And our daughter even received a cool bracelet, which she loved—such a thoughtful touch for kids. That level of care really stands out. Our server Amanda was attentive and friendly

My daughter can be picky, but she LOVED the Eliot pizza. The pepperoni wasn’t too spicy (huge win!), she loved the pickles, and Lee even brought her her own side of pickles. She also couldn’t get enough of the banana pudding.

Overall great food, fair pricing, welcoming atmosphere, and outstanding service. This place truly gets it. We will absolutely be back!
… more
Brian Morton
We decided last minute to try this place and just like any food/restaurant review….this is based on personal preference. The garlic knots are delicious and the chicken sandwiches/fries were good. We tried a flight of pizza in order to try a few different kinds and the thick crust/crunchy edges were just not our thing. I did order the El Diablo and 100% preferred that over the flight. Thin, charred crust and the mix of jalapeños, pepperoni and drizzle of hot honey was delicious. We all would come back and have the sandwiches/fries and garlic knots.
… more
cassidy
Holy Chick is beyond amazing! I’ve been here twice and ordered takeout several times! Food was sooo delicious each time! Especially the detroit pizza! On my 2nd visit, which was shortly after they opened, Lee the manager stopped by to make sure everything was good and asked how the food was. He is such a great and friendly person and goes above and beyond to make sure his customers are satisfied. Now this is how you run an amazing successful business! The atmosphere and service is a 10/10, everyone is always making sure you have everything you need and you’re always greeted with a smile. I wish them continued success and luck! I 100% recommend coming here, it will not disappoint! If you haven’t tried tried it yet, definitely stop in and try it! Amazing food and amazing people
… more
Michael Tonner
I’ve been several times now, and every experience has been top notch. The food is stellar, the staff are top-notch, and the vibe is on point.

They make a fantastic Detroit Style Pizza and the chicken sandwiches are beyond delicious. Franklin is lucky to have this wonderful, new restaurant!
… more
… View more

Leave a Comment