Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
The Tally-Ho Restaurant in Tinton Falls, New Jersey, is commonly referred to as the “hidden gem” along Route 33. We are locally owned and operated and have been proudly serving our community since we opened our doors in 1995. Our menu features a contemporary blend of American cuisine with a strong Northern Italian influence. Our dinner menu features enticing appetizers and succulent entrees that range from fresh seafood, to hand-crafted pasta dishes, to deliciously prepared meats. Our lunch menu features pasta, hearty soups, hand-crafted sandwiches, and signature salads. We are open seven days a week, including many major holidays. We also offer catering and private event services.
Enduring local spot features American comfort eats & Italian classics in spacious, comfy surrounds.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 4118 NJ-33, Tinton Falls, NJ 07753
Phone: (732) 918-0900
Website: http://www.tallyho-nj.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Tally Ho Restaurant
Want to stay up to date with all major announcements and updates for Tally-ho? Join … Tinton Falls, NJ. 07753. Google My Business Badge. Click to review.
Tally Ho Restaurant – Tinton Falls, New Jersey
In the mood for savory Italian-American cuisine? Come visit us in Tinton Falls, New Jersey! Call today at (732) 918-0900 or make reservations online!
Tally Ho Restaurant – Tinton Falls, NJ – OpenTable
Tally Ho is open seven days a week. Current posted hours are: – Mon–Thu: 11:30 AM–9:00 PM – Fri–Sat: 11:30 AM–10:00 PM – Sun: 3:00 PM–9:00 PM Guests also note …
Reviews
B T
Don’t let the name fool you, it’s an incredible gastronomic treat.
Located on a strip of road you wouldn’t expect a restaurant to be located at is this restaurant. The name makes it sound like a pub, and although it does have a large bar, it also has a restaurant with tables and booths and am incredible menu.
Very generous portions, amazing treat of flavors, very attentive and professional staff. Great meal experience overall.
Two pro tips: make reservations if you plan on eating at a table or booth. When the place is full, there’s not enough parking so carpool if you can.
… moreLocated on a strip of road you wouldn’t expect a restaurant to be located at is this restaurant. The name makes it sound like a pub, and although it does have a large bar, it also has a restaurant with tables and booths and am incredible menu.
Very generous portions, amazing treat of flavors, very attentive and professional staff. Great meal experience overall.
Two pro tips: make reservations if you plan on eating at a table or booth. When the place is full, there’s not enough parking so carpool if you can.
Steve D
Came here for our anniversary dinner and wee brought our 2 girls, aged 10-12.
Never heard of the place, but I wanted to try somewhere different.
They don’t have a host table which was rather odd, but we were seated once someone noticed us standing awkwardly by the door.
We loved everything we got and we were treated very well by the wait staff. Good house wine too.
Prices were fair.
We’ll definitely be back.
… moreNever heard of the place, but I wanted to try somewhere different.
They don’t have a host table which was rather odd, but we were seated once someone noticed us standing awkwardly by the door.
We loved everything we got and we were treated very well by the wait staff. Good house wine too.
Prices were fair.
We’ll definitely be back.
Paul Sardella
A hidden NJ gem! A very deceiving exterior! The food and service were equally amazing!
Hi highly recommend!
The Murphy Chicken was absolutely delicious! The Sirloin Steak was as good as any top steak house! Their Chicken Parm was fantastic too!
… moreHi highly recommend!
The Murphy Chicken was absolutely delicious! The Sirloin Steak was as good as any top steak house! Their Chicken Parm was fantastic too!
John Byrne
I’ve been passing by Tally Ho for a while and today I decided to stop in. So glad I did. This little gem is serving great food and great service. I sat at the bar and had soup and escargot ( which is tough to find). Both were delicious. Kim was bartending and was super kind and attentive. Really enjoyed Tally Ho and would highly recommend for great food and service at very reasonable prices. I’ll be back with my family. Cheers.
… moreMike Greco
Such a great place with even better prices. Food is fantastic! Come hungry!
… moreDaveT
This is a nice restaurant with decent Italian food. The atmosphere inside is a bit on the plain side for my liking but I do like the food and they make good espresso. I have been here when parking was rather on the difficult side, but usually there are no real problems. A nice place to dine out.
… moreSteve X
My wife and I had dinner here at 7 pm on a Monday night during the first half of July 2023. The place was pretty empty. That was good because there’s not a lot of parking spots, and no nearby stores to park in. We later learned from our server that on weekends people often have to park on the grass.
The outside is not particularly inviting. When I saw the neon Coors Light sign in the window, I thought this was going to be a sports bar joint. I was wrong.
Yes, there is a bar with multiple TVs inside, but there is also a separate seating area for non bar patrons. There are also a few private tables alongside the front of the restaurant, and there is a partial glass wall separating them from the bar, so they are nice and quiet. We sat in one of those.
The bar was not real busy that night and neither was the restaurant, so it was nice and quiet to talk. I imagine it would be quite different on the weekend, and our server told us so. Service was good.
There is an extensive menu, and all the dishes are very moderately priced. Our dinners came with delicious Italian bread and salads and a side of our choosing at no extra cost. The pierogi appetizer was delicious, the chicken piccata was very tender and tasty, and the chicken/shrimp/filet mignon dinner with Romano sauce was wonderful. Portion sizes were nice, though not overwhelming. The pinot Grigio available was good and not super expensive.
Bottom line. This is a very good casual dining restaurant, very moderately priced, and with a huge selection of dishes. I do think the food is a notch below some much more expensive restaurants we have gone to, but is a very good value for what you get. This is a nice alternative to a fine dining restaurant. We will probably be back the next time we vacation at the shore.
… moreThe outside is not particularly inviting. When I saw the neon Coors Light sign in the window, I thought this was going to be a sports bar joint. I was wrong.
Yes, there is a bar with multiple TVs inside, but there is also a separate seating area for non bar patrons. There are also a few private tables alongside the front of the restaurant, and there is a partial glass wall separating them from the bar, so they are nice and quiet. We sat in one of those.
The bar was not real busy that night and neither was the restaurant, so it was nice and quiet to talk. I imagine it would be quite different on the weekend, and our server told us so. Service was good.
There is an extensive menu, and all the dishes are very moderately priced. Our dinners came with delicious Italian bread and salads and a side of our choosing at no extra cost. The pierogi appetizer was delicious, the chicken piccata was very tender and tasty, and the chicken/shrimp/filet mignon dinner with Romano sauce was wonderful. Portion sizes were nice, though not overwhelming. The pinot Grigio available was good and not super expensive.
Bottom line. This is a very good casual dining restaurant, very moderately priced, and with a huge selection of dishes. I do think the food is a notch below some much more expensive restaurants we have gone to, but is a very good value for what you get. This is a nice alternative to a fine dining restaurant. We will probably be back the next time we vacation at the shore.
John McLucas
This place was recommended by a local hotel we stayed at. Terrible food, no flavor and the worst old fashion I have ever had. Who puts it in a shaker cup! ♂️
Bartender damn sure doesn’t need to quit his day job!
… moreBartender damn sure doesn’t need to quit his day job!
Peter
Used to go often and it was great, went first time in a couple years with 4 top. All 4 dishes were either dry, bland, or overcooked. Service was typical for them which is basically diner style rather than any degree of polished.
… moreDiane Goncalves
Tally Ho is a hidden gem in Tinton Falls, NJ. Ate here last night for Mom’s Birthday. From the minute we walked in the door, we were greeted, sat, and ate delicious food! We will definitely come back!
… more