Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Hours
| Tuesday | 4–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 4–9 PM |
| Thursday | 4–9 PM |
| Friday | 4–9 PM |
| Saturday | 4–9 PM |
| Sunday | 4–9 PM |
| Monday | 4–9 PM |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 976 County Rd N, Niagara, WI 54151
Phone: (715) 589-4270
Website: https://www.facebook.com/bartolettis/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Bartolettis Restaurant – Cozy Local Dining with Classic Comforts in …
Discover warm hospitality and hearty favorites like broasted chicken and walleye at Bartolettis, a welcoming spot rich in local charm.
Bartolettis Restaurant Menu (Updated 2026) – Wheree
Bartolettis Restaurant features a menu that highlights quality and flavor, making it a favored dining destination in Niagara.
Bartolettis, 976 County Rd N, Niagara, WI 54151, US – MapQuest
Bartolettis in Niagara, WI is a cozy restaurant offering a variety of Italian-inspired dishes and casual dining experience.
Reviews
Michael Silas
Bartolettis Restaurant is located in Niagara Wisconsin near Kingsford, Michigan. The restaurant has a bar in the front where people wait for a table. They have steaks, seafod, and Italian food. We visited on a Tuesday for dinner and they have a dinner special of fried chicken and spaghetti served with bread and coleslaw for $5 with the purchase of a drink. This was all you can eat. This was an amazing deal and the food was fantastic. The service was great. I would highly recommend this restaurant. I would like to try the other items on the menu in the future.
… moreRaven Schulke
Went tonight (New Years Eve) with our kids. We waited 30 minutes for food at the bar. There were several open tables. Once we were seated, at a small booth, we were quickly over crowded with water, bread, our app, so much I felt claustrophobic.
We ordered the basket app and for $15 we got mostly 2 kinds of fries that tasted like fish, 2 onion rings, 4 mushrooms, and 2 moz sticks.
One daughter ordered the grilled chicken sandwich and it was very cordy. One daughter ordered a burger which was good. My husband ordered the prime rib which was a midcut, but flavorful. They wouldn’t let him get fries or the loaded baked potato, only spaghetti or baked potato. He opted for the spaghetti which was small, ok sauce, but over cooked sticky noodles. I ordered the chicken cordon bleu Alfredo. Ok sauce, thick but flavorless. The chicken was cooked ok but lacked flavor and one tiny piece of ham. The noodles were over cooked and sticky.
The salads …… A pile of lettuce with one tiny round of red onion. My husband ordered dry and I ordered French, it was swimming in dressing. They were pretty much sent back uneaten.
For $120 ….. Not worth it.
Our waitress was in a hurry constantly.
The bread served was good, fresh baked, warm.
It’s a pretty place but the food was definitely not worth the price.
… moreWe ordered the basket app and for $15 we got mostly 2 kinds of fries that tasted like fish, 2 onion rings, 4 mushrooms, and 2 moz sticks.
One daughter ordered the grilled chicken sandwich and it was very cordy. One daughter ordered a burger which was good. My husband ordered the prime rib which was a midcut, but flavorful. They wouldn’t let him get fries or the loaded baked potato, only spaghetti or baked potato. He opted for the spaghetti which was small, ok sauce, but over cooked sticky noodles. I ordered the chicken cordon bleu Alfredo. Ok sauce, thick but flavorless. The chicken was cooked ok but lacked flavor and one tiny piece of ham. The noodles were over cooked and sticky.
The salads …… A pile of lettuce with one tiny round of red onion. My husband ordered dry and I ordered French, it was swimming in dressing. They were pretty much sent back uneaten.
For $120 ….. Not worth it.
Our waitress was in a hurry constantly.
The bread served was good, fresh baked, warm.
It’s a pretty place but the food was definitely not worth the price.
Angela Stafford
Food was wonderful. I ordered the Prime Rib and my husband had the Ribeye. Steaks done to perfection. Gnocchi was fresh and hot. Service was just OK. Bartenders were friendly and accommodating.
… moreAnatolii Tereshchenko
The cod tasted good. Very big meal.
Thank you …
… moreThank you …
Krystal Lancaster
This is one of my most favorite places to come on Earth. Chicken night is everything. The BEST you will ever have in your life. I ham not overexaggerating either. Come here once every year because that’s the only time that I can. Will always come back and bring new people with. I wish I could always come here and am jealous of anybody that gets to.
… morePhyl Carlson
I had the 8oz tenderloin & hubby had the shrimp, both were good. Salads were good. I had the baked potato & hubby had the gnocchi. The baked potato was, well a baked potato, hard to mess one up. However the gnocchi was so tough it took effort to cut one in half with a fork. I’ve had good gnocchi, they are tender, these were like rubber. Bartolettis has not in my past memory never had good gnocchi, which is why I didn’t order them, but these were even worse than their past efforts. So if you go here just dont order the gnocchi as a side, the rest of your meal should be great. Note on parking: on nights they are busy their lot fills up. You can park on the street but be sure to note the signs that say no parking between them, you will get a ticket. You can park at another business across the street that is closed at night.
… moreDouglas Nord
Food was barely warm. Baked potatoe didn’t even melt the butter. Butter for boiled cod was barely melted. When we days something instead of I’m sorry about that. I watched the cook take it out. Should have said something when I first came back. Well damn, we were just starring our meal. We had no idea the whole meal was crap and had a waitress that wanted to make excuses. Never go there again. Bartenders were good. That’s all.
… moreMoon Ryder
We had a fabulous party there tonight. Tye food was great and the service was excellent
… moreBrandi Poggemann
Delicious! Good price. Fun atmosphere. Decent wait staff. Only complaint I will say because it stuck with me after a few days is that there was a booth that ordered ribs. When the server brought the ribs, she dumped them onto the table. She apologized profusely, but then used the patron’s utensil to put the ribs back on the plate before walking away. She left the plate of ribs. I know that that is a no no in the restaurant industry. It is gross. You don’t know what is on that table. You’ve now contaminated the plate and the food. She never brought them a new plate of food and didn’t offer. Just apologized. She was an older woman (50s or 60s) with very dark (almost black) hair pulled into a partial ponytail.
OUR server was awesome and we had no issues. It just made me question if this is normal practice at this establisment….
… moreOUR server was awesome and we had no issues. It just made me question if this is normal practice at this establisment….
Andrew Frievalt
Hi there. So, I ate at your restaurant with my family earlier this evening. I ordered the 25 Oz porterhouse I think. And it was served to me well done when I asked for medium rare. So they took it back, at that point my family was almost done eating, so I had them just put it in a to go box for me to take home, I checked over it, seemed like it was medium rare. Well, I went to enjoy my steak before bed this evening. And this is what I received. Basically raw, that is not medium rare. Not even close. I am very unhappy with this. My food was wrong. Twice and the second even worse than the first! This is unacceptable and I would like some sort of compensation for this.
… more