Social Profile: 
… View more
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Ice Cream Island, LLC Cadiz, Ohio – Facebook
So many people have asked lately but we are not open yet for the season, very soon though! Check our page for opening date coming soon! you can visit our …
Ice Cream Island, LLC
Ice Cream Island, LLC. Pickup Delivery. Select location. Find the nearest store. Ice Cream Island, LLC. 812 east market st. Cadiz, OH 43907. +100 miles.
Ice Cream Island, 812 E Market St, Cadiz, OH 43907, US – MapQuest
Own this business? Claim it. See a problem? Let us know. United States ›Ohio ›Cadiz ›Ice Cream Island. Partial Data by Foursquare. See more.
Reviews
Bridgette Turner
Their menu is is diverse compared to other small ice cream stands and the size of the portions are huge for the price! So many creative new items too. It can get busy but is totally worth the wait. Every time I’ve gone the staff was incredibly friendly. Definitely go!
… moreSarah F
Hello and good afternoon! Thanks for taking the time to read my review!
This was the first time we have ever been here so we got a few items to sample the wares!
The menu today:
Nutella Mason jar milkshake with a funnel cake, raspberry cheesecake parfait, chocolate malt shake with caramel, pulled pork tots, pulled pork nachos, cheeseburger, corn dog, onion rings, and deep fried oreos.
Everything overall was really good!
The milkshake was a bit plain ish but it had a good flavor. It’s definitely a share size. I couldn’t finish it and no one wanted to share haha you get to keep the mason jar when you are done.
The daughter loved her parfait. The cheesecake was stellar on it!
The funnel cakes were a smidge on the drier side. But still tasty. Maybe the cold weather cooled them down too fast so the sugar didn’t have time to melt into it. Good regardless haha
The pulled pork they use is really good. I love me some basic cheese nachos with a good pulled pork! The nacho cheese was good too. Sometimes you get some thats eh. These were pretty good. Reminds me of the movie theater nachos and i love those. Simple and delish!
The onion rings are amazing. I just wish they had a good homemade ranch to go with them besides hidden valley (yucky). That would just elevate the experience to another level!
The deep fried oreos were probably my favorite (next to the nachos) of the trip. Perfect ratio of batter to oreo.
Overall, I’m extremely happy with our trip here and can’t wait to visit on a nicer warmer day! Sitting under that huge magnolia tree and chatting with the fam and trying all these different dishes was a blast! Ice Cream Island, thank you for the opportunity to eat your food! and thank you, reader, for sticking with me thru this review! Definitely give them a try!
… moreThis was the first time we have ever been here so we got a few items to sample the wares!
The menu today:
Nutella Mason jar milkshake with a funnel cake, raspberry cheesecake parfait, chocolate malt shake with caramel, pulled pork tots, pulled pork nachos, cheeseburger, corn dog, onion rings, and deep fried oreos.
Everything overall was really good!
The milkshake was a bit plain ish but it had a good flavor. It’s definitely a share size. I couldn’t finish it and no one wanted to share haha you get to keep the mason jar when you are done.
The daughter loved her parfait. The cheesecake was stellar on it!
The funnel cakes were a smidge on the drier side. But still tasty. Maybe the cold weather cooled them down too fast so the sugar didn’t have time to melt into it. Good regardless haha
The pulled pork they use is really good. I love me some basic cheese nachos with a good pulled pork! The nacho cheese was good too. Sometimes you get some thats eh. These were pretty good. Reminds me of the movie theater nachos and i love those. Simple and delish!
The onion rings are amazing. I just wish they had a good homemade ranch to go with them besides hidden valley (yucky). That would just elevate the experience to another level!
The deep fried oreos were probably my favorite (next to the nachos) of the trip. Perfect ratio of batter to oreo.
Overall, I’m extremely happy with our trip here and can’t wait to visit on a nicer warmer day! Sitting under that huge magnolia tree and chatting with the fam and trying all these different dishes was a blast! Ice Cream Island, thank you for the opportunity to eat your food! and thank you, reader, for sticking with me thru this review! Definitely give them a try!
Cowboy
Actually, insane portion sizes and prices are fantastic!
Had the Oreo Blizzard style sundae (giant and delicious)
Fried balongna sandwich, full fries, and a hot dog for $13 with a tip?! I mean, that’s a great deal. I also highly recommend the fried cookie dough (it was probably the best dessert I have tried in a long time). Every time I’m back up north, I’ll make a stop!
Fyi- wait can be long depending on the time of day
10/10
… moreHad the Oreo Blizzard style sundae (giant and delicious)
Fried balongna sandwich, full fries, and a hot dog for $13 with a tip?! I mean, that’s a great deal. I also highly recommend the fried cookie dough (it was probably the best dessert I have tried in a long time). Every time I’m back up north, I’ll make a stop!
Fyi- wait can be long depending on the time of day
10/10
Diablo Dan
We got the frozen hot chocolate mason jar for $14 and it was plenty enough for us to share! (32oz) It was super filling and we had enjoyed every bite.
They also do a happy hour ice cream cone deal from 3-4pm for $1. We didn’t go at the time of the deal but definitely would recommend it!
… moreThey also do a happy hour ice cream cone deal from 3-4pm for $1. We didn’t go at the time of the deal but definitely would recommend it!
Bryan Terrill
Apple Dumpling, Pumpkin Roll Mason Jar, Brownie Sundae & pup cups are great portions for the price!! Sometimes it’s a little bit of a wait, but worth it! Happy Hour 3-4 with $1 any size cones.
… moreDanielle Painter
Very friendly staff, good food and the shakes are phenomenal. We had the Funnel cake and Banana Split shakes. Buffalo chicken fries and Loaded baked potato tots
… morePatricia Moser
Definitely recommend! Friendly staff, didn’t have to wait long, & the ice cream is amazing so much to choose from and honestly everything I have tried so far has been really good! It is a little pricey depending on what you get, but I promise it’s worth it with the amount you get and the quality. Hands down best ice cream shop!
… moreJennifer Jordan
Very busy place! Large portions for the price! very tasty! Menu is large- take a.minute to browse! Unique icecream items!
Hubby got the cheeseburger wrap and onion rings, I got Philly cheese wrap with a sampler basket- a mix of fried pickles, cauliflower, broccoli cheese bites, zucchini fries, banana rings, mushrooms and a jalapeños popper!
… moreHubby got the cheeseburger wrap and onion rings, I got Philly cheese wrap with a sampler basket- a mix of fried pickles, cauliflower, broccoli cheese bites, zucchini fries, banana rings, mushrooms and a jalapeños popper!
Julie Whiteman
Our first time at ice cream island was delicious! We got a couple corn dogs, fish sandwich, and cheese waffle fries (very good) to eat and then a couple salted caramel shakes and a strawberry cheesecake sundae! Everything was delicious but the ice cream was the star by far!! There are a few picnic tables there where you can sit and enjoy if you have time!
… moreJulie LeBeau
Bad Milkshakes! This was our first time here. I ordered a mason jar Buckeye milkshake. I assumed it would be peanut butter flavoured. I was then told I needed to order a flavour for the milkshake they were out of peanut butter. I ordered vanilla. What I got was a runny glass of milk with some small buckeye candies thrown on top and no vanilla flavour. Cost $10.00. My husband got the Frozen Hot Chocolate mason jar milkshake. It was just runny chocolate ice cream with some whip cream. Not worth $10.00. I came home and found a picture on their facebook page of the buckeye. Mine didn’t look anything like that one as you can see by the pictures.We could have gotten a better milkshakes at Dairy Queen for less.
… more