Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Right here in the heart of Canastota, NY, Theodore’s is where families and folks hang out. Our grub’s top-notch, serving up lunch and dinner that hits the spot every time. Check out our menu packed with tasty picks that’ll make your taste buds do a happy dance.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 3231 Seneca Turnpike, Canastota, NY 13032
Phone: (315) 697-7929
Website: https://www.theodoresrestaurant.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Theodore’s Restaurant – Canastota
Right here in the heart of Canastota, NY, Theodore’s is where families and folks hang out. Our grub’s top-notch, serving up lunch and dinner that hits the spot …
Theodore’s Restaurant and Banquets – Facebook
Mary Kurec and 38 others · . 39 · 3 · Theodore’s Restaurant and Banquets. Nov 12, 2025 . . Village of Canastota Recreation. Nov 6, 2025 . Get those wish …
Theodores’s Restaurant – CLOSED, 3231 Seneca Tpke, Canastota …
Theodore’s Restaurant, located in the heart of Canastota, NY, is a beloved local spot where delicious food and good times come together, making it a popular …
Reviews
Dave P
Stopped today for lunch, and glad we did. The food was incredible, and the service was awesome. Ordered a buffalo chicken sandwich and fries, as did my girlfriend (sandwich and onion rings). Might just be the tastiest sandwich ever, and the fries and onion rings were just terrific. Can’t say enough about this place. We visit the area a few times a year, and this will be a regular stop from now on. Five stars is not enough.
… moreBrianna Sullivan
An amazing day! Great for 16th bday parties. Staff is so helpful and go above and beyond.
… moreKenneth Parkhurst Jr
Had a wonderful meal here on Thanksgiving! Very home style cooking. We made reservations and were promptly seated upon arrival. The decor is a little dated but the food is great. Wait staff was attentive and cleared empty dishes quickly. Many style meals were available to include steak, shrimp and the classic turkey. Ordered the turkey meal and it came with white and dark meat, mashed potatoes, stuffing, cranberry sauce covered in gravy. There was also a side salad and dessert, apple or pumpkin pie! Food was plentiful and warm when arriving at the table. Very tastey. It was filling to the point we had to get pie to go! Kudos to the staff for taking Thanksgiving to make other a meal. Great job and would recommend Theodore’s to anyone for a good home style cooked meal.
… moreLinda Whelan
Their chicken and Biscuits are amazing and their pork chops. I haven’t had a bad meal there
… moreDonna Costanzo
I’ve eaten at Theodore’s 3 times – 6 persons for dinner, solo dinner and solo lunch. Food was excellent (had steak for one dinner that was perfectly rare, which seldom happens at any restaurant). Service was prompt, professional and friendly even when dining solo. Pricing is also very reasonable, especially for the quality. I definitely recommend Theodore’s.
… moreCarmel Watson
Our first time here and we were not disappointed! We had sirloin steak and pork rib eye.
… moreDenise Egan
Very nice agenda, presentation, food for an awards ceremony; well presented I should say for theodores nice work gents ladies. Thank you
… moreBen Johnston
Waitress was nice other then that kinda sucked ordered ribeye w fries ordered mozzarella sticks never got the mozzerlla sticks. Steak was like rubber I’m not from area truly would have rather eat McDonald’s or anything really I’m not one to complain but onion ring on top of steak just didn’t taste right A1 was old…..lemonade was good Truly feel was waste of $100 and I didn’t pay for it and I’m still hungry. I did bring steak for my dogs it truly was trash I had to use two hands to pull apart and was a struggle I would keep Driving
… moreSteve Otto Stansbury
Got in at 4:00 chicken almost ready. Had a beer and the double order of chicken fricassee and Polly remembered my moms loves them. Super super A+++ customer service. We are like family! 20 plus years?
… morePeter Ferretti
The Republican meeting held there was very good. Except, the lack of soda was kinda odd. Water n coffee only
… more