Social Profile: 
![]()
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
At Papa Johns Pizza in Elizabeth, NJ, it’s our goal to always bring you Better Ingredients. Better Pizza. Whether it’s our signature sauce, toppings, or fresh, original dough, we invest in our ingredients to ensure you have the best Elizabeth pizza for any occasion. Call us for pizza delivery in Elizabeth or stop by 312 Rahway Ave. for carryout to order the best pizza in Elizabeth, along with breadsticks, wings, and more!
Pizza take-out & delivery chain offering classic & specialty pizzas, plus wings, sides & desserts.
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Papa Johns Pizza Rahway Ave. – NJ
Order from Papa Johns Rahway Ave. for the best takeout and food delivery in Elizabeth. Order online, visit or call for pizza, wings, sides and more!
Pizza in Elizabeth, NJ | Papa Johns Rahway Ave.
For pizza delivery in Elizabeth, call us at (908) 289-5766 to order, or stop by 312 Rahway Ave. in Elizabeth, NJ for carryout.
papa johns stores in elizabeth, nj
Browse all Papa Johns Pizza locations in Elizabeth, New Jersey to order pizza, breadsticks, wings and more for delivery or takeout near you.
Last Updates
Reviews
Andreia Almeida
Papa John’s are one of my favorite pizza places especially in this location. The employees are nice, the pizza is always hot when i pick it up. I want to thank this papa John’s for always supporting our community. Any event we have they are always here to support. Thank you for a job well done!
… moreUmara Campbell
I want to thank Papa John at this location for always going above and beyond customer service. They are such great big supporters of the community. Their Hospitality is transcending, and we have been partners with them for such a very long time.
Not to mention also that the quality of their food every time we order from them is ALWAYS fresh!!
Thank you so much again for always supporting our community events for the youth and for the less privilege.
… moreNot to mention also that the quality of their food every time we order from them is ALWAYS fresh!!
Thank you so much again for always supporting our community events for the youth and for the less privilege.
Anthony Luna
Delivery driver decided to block oncoming traffic while the SUV on the right was unloading. Sat there while oncoming traffic built up to 10-15 cars, creating an hostile environment for drivers while also blocking me from getting into my building. Terrible service.
… moreGG ZALMI
Best pizza store Ive ever seen fast delivery hot and fresh pizza best costumer service everyone was very professional.
… moreSis BlessedAllTheTime
I usually come to this location because it’s open late & it’s convenient for me. The pizza here is usually good but a few times it was a bit salty. Otherwise it’s a good spot for pizza. Clean inside & the staff are decent.
… moreJugal Patel
Made perfectly! My favorite item, the Papadillas, were completely stuffed out of any Papa Johns I’ve every taken out from. Keep up the great work!!
… moreKhizer Raja
Hands down the BEST pizza in town! Crispy crust, flavorful sauce, and the freshest toppings you can imagine. The staff is super friendly, the vibe is warm and inviting. Consider this your sign to ditch the screen and grab a pie.
… moreShykot Hosain
Awesome food is very hot and crispy excellent management, this manger he very nice guy. He’s very friendly. He know how to take the customer. He’s very good guy. Excellent job. I love him
This guy Best Manager Papa Johns ❤️
… moreThis guy Best Manager Papa Johns ❤️
William Andrews
Great food and service they always great u and are very clean love going there to get food when it’s family time and a movie or event
… moreKaren Salzedas
If I could give zero stars, I would.
I placed an order through the Papa John’s app — my card was charged, but the order never showed up as received on the website. To make sure everything was okay, I called the store. The cashier said they didn’t have my order. I told her I had the receipt from my bank showing I was charged, so she asked someone for help — I believe his name was Mohamed.
Mohamed claimed to be the manager (which was a lie) and was incredibly rude on the phone. He didn’t answer any of my questions, didn’t try to help, and hung up in my face. I had no choice but to leave work and go to the store in person to get this figured out.
When I arrived, I was told the actual manager wasn’t even there. Thankfully, the cashier, Maria, was respectful and took the initiative to call the real manager so we could resolve the issue. The problem eventually got fixed — but my lunch break was completely wasted, and I had to go back to work without even getting to eat.
It’s unacceptable for someone to lie about their role and treat customers like this. Whether Mohamed is just a cashier or makes pizzas, he should NOT be pretending to be a manager and making situations worse with his attitude.
Customer service here is seriously lacking — and I won’t be coming back.
… moreI placed an order through the Papa John’s app — my card was charged, but the order never showed up as received on the website. To make sure everything was okay, I called the store. The cashier said they didn’t have my order. I told her I had the receipt from my bank showing I was charged, so she asked someone for help — I believe his name was Mohamed.
Mohamed claimed to be the manager (which was a lie) and was incredibly rude on the phone. He didn’t answer any of my questions, didn’t try to help, and hung up in my face. I had no choice but to leave work and go to the store in person to get this figured out.
When I arrived, I was told the actual manager wasn’t even there. Thankfully, the cashier, Maria, was respectful and took the initiative to call the real manager so we could resolve the issue. The problem eventually got fixed — but my lunch break was completely wasted, and I had to go back to work without even getting to eat.
It’s unacceptable for someone to lie about their role and treat customers like this. Whether Mohamed is just a cashier or makes pizzas, he should NOT be pretending to be a manager and making situations worse with his attitude.
Customer service here is seriously lacking — and I won’t be coming back.