Social Profile: 
✔️Dinner ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 18 Mckabe Rd, Colton, NY 13625
Phone: (315) 274-2014
Website: http://www.bakerssizzlinggrill.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Baker’s Sizzling Grill | Colton NY – Facebook
Today’s Special: 3 pigs in a blanket- cabbage rolls made with pork $17.00 we also have our pizza and wing deal: Any topping pizza with a dozen wings $30.95 …
Bakers Sizzling Grill – 18 McKabe Rd, Colton, NY, 13625 – MapQuest
Baker’s Sizzling Grill is a family-owned takeout and delivery restaurant located in Colton, Town of, NY. With a dream of providing delicious meals to the …
Baker’s Sizzling Grill – Fasprint Menus
Our Menus. Baker’s Sizzling Grill. February 2023 • New York, Pizza • bakers sizzling grill, fasprint, menus, New York, Pizza. Search for: Categories.
Reviews
Bree
We got a large 16” pepperoni pizza, 1/2 dozen mild bone-in wings, 1/2dozen bbq wings, and an order of garlic knots. We were starving passing through Colton which is rare and saw this on google with all good reviews and went for it. But man were we disappointed… I will say that it’s pretty hard to mess up a pizza, and they did. I’m sorry but I’ve tried lots of pizza and I’m usually not picky but by the end of my slice I was about to gag. The wings were awful. The chewiest, fattiest weirdest tasting wings. We stomached the bbq wings since there was enough sauce to mask the cheap chicken taste. I’ve had better food from 7-11/Sunoco! The garlic knots were supposed to be no cheese and there was a layer of crusted stinky cheese on the bottom of them. They were not light airy garlic goodness. They were thick dense dry slabs of bread and somehow still raw. This place really reminded me why we don’t try new places and stick to what I know. My dog who eats anything, didn’t even want this food. My boyfriend ended up getting sick later on.. We just wanted some good food and this was EXTREMELY upsetting. I just don’t want someone else to go through what we did. Disregard all these good reviews people! Pizza is deceiving as it looks great but it is NOT
… moreGavin Anderson
We got take out tonight, medium wings and pizza. I didn’t pick it up and haven’t been there before so this review is only on the food and no rating on service or atmosphere. The wings were cooked well enough to where I could pull the bones out of the flat, which is perfect. The medium wings are perfect for a group that includes people who can’t handle spicy food, I think. The pizza was a nice thin crust and had some bubbles, it had the right amount of crisp.
… moreMegan White
Have ordered from them many times in the past. Seems like they just dont care anymore. Not putting in the effort now that 11 west is open. In the past every meal has been great. Last night I ordered a pizza, a dozen wings and a salad. The pizza was not cooked all the way, not even enough to eat it. The wings were burned and had barely any sauce on them and the Croutons were soggy. Mind you the dressing was not on the salad they send you one little container for a large salad. No where near enough always have to ask for extra. On top of all that the girl that took my order told me half hour to 45 mins for delivery which is very reasonable for the distance we are from them. The driver showed up an hour and a half later. I spent $64 on a meal that I couldn’t eat. I called and they offered me credit for the pizza. 20 dollars doesn’t cover the money I just blew for nothing. Ended up cooking dinner in the end.
… moreAlexa Backus Chase
Baker’s Sizzling Grill catered our wedding reception on 9.23.23. Both Les and Peggy were very accommodating and helpful. The food was amazing (prime rib) and their dessert treats were amazing. We’ve had so many people comment about how great their meal was at dinner.
We are looking forward to frequenting their newest endeavor, 11 West, when it opens! Thank you Baker’s for providing exceptional customer service and food!
… moreWe are looking forward to frequenting their newest endeavor, 11 West, when it opens! Thank you Baker’s for providing exceptional customer service and food!
Jenny Virnig
We were thrilled & looking forward to ordering when we received their menu in our post office box just before they opened – and we were not disappointed when we did!
I admit I felt like a jerk when we called on a Sunday night to order half an hour before they closed (didn’t mean to, just lost track of time! ), but the person that answered was very nice & polite while insisting it was just fine. (We promise not to do that again! )
Anyway, we ordered a pepperoni & mushroom pizza, breaded mushrooms, and the fried dough balls with cinnamon and everything was Great! (The dough balls especially did not last long! )
Everything was great, and despite ordering as late as we did, our order was delivered Extremely quickly! (Even though we fall within the Free Delivery Within 4 miles – totally thrilled about that, by the way! – we’d happily pay a fee for the food & convenience!)
We look forward to ordering again, and trying out all they have to offer! Oh, and they keep their fb page up to date, so it’s convenient to check out specials & any announcements that may come up! (So go Like their page… )
… moreI admit I felt like a jerk when we called on a Sunday night to order half an hour before they closed (didn’t mean to, just lost track of time! ), but the person that answered was very nice & polite while insisting it was just fine. (We promise not to do that again! )
Anyway, we ordered a pepperoni & mushroom pizza, breaded mushrooms, and the fried dough balls with cinnamon and everything was Great! (The dough balls especially did not last long! )
Everything was great, and despite ordering as late as we did, our order was delivered Extremely quickly! (Even though we fall within the Free Delivery Within 4 miles – totally thrilled about that, by the way! – we’d happily pay a fee for the food & convenience!)
We look forward to ordering again, and trying out all they have to offer! Oh, and they keep their fb page up to date, so it’s convenient to check out specials & any announcements that may come up! (So go Like their page… )
Shana Shantie
I have always had great service employees are very friendly and always a good meal thank you. When you offer more than meat lovers or pepperoni in you fried pizza rolls let me know but always a have had a great experience
… moreSamantha Dugan
This is easily our favorite restaurant in the area. We order from here on an almost weekly basis, so much that I kind of wish they had a points system! Haha. The only complaint that I have is that they ever close! We regularly order their specials like beef tips, turkey dinner, and prime rib; and we regularly order pizza, burgers, wings, homemade Mac and cheese, and various appetizers! They make at least most things fresh and homemade! If you need some catering or a good family dinner then this is the place to go! They are good people and I feel more than welcome every time I walk in the door. Also, I’ve been able to speak directly to the owner on occasion and it’s so relieving to know we have someone that cares about the community here. Baker’s goes above and beyond to accommodate customers.
I should add that the pictures of the food are accommodated to our request and not how they would typically come!
… moreI should add that the pictures of the food are accommodated to our request and not how they would typically come!
Scott Reynolds
This is my go to when I don’t feel like making dinner for myself. Last time I ordered there was a mixup (I have poor telephone reception which is probably the root cause) and instead of a pizza with sausage, onions and peppers, I arrived to a sausage with onions and peppers. They were very apologetic and refused my offer to pay when they said they would correct my order while I waited. I have had a consistently positive experience, the people are nice, the location is clean and pleasant, and the food is good at Bakers and I recommend them.
… moreAmber Hughes
Just hired Baker’s for our parents 50th Anniversary Party. Everything was EXCELLENT!!! We did pulled pork, ziti, Mac and cheese, spaghetti, meatballs, coleslaw…it was all delicious! Peggy went above and beyond and their team is great! We had a lot of family from hundreds of miles away and EVERYONE was asking where the food was from. Thank you so much Peggy and team for everything!!!! Highly recommend and their prices are great too!
… moreEmma Young
I’ve ordered from Bakers Sizzling Grill 2 times now. I’ve gotten the white pizza and a pepperoni. The pizza is always great…but both times we have ordered our food has been at least 45 minutes late. (or past the estimated delivery time) the pizza was still semi warm, good but not hot, fresh pizza.
… more