Social Profile: 
✔️Breakfast ✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Easygoing restaurant showcasing hearty pizzas in a mural-clad dining area with a patio.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 15725 37th Ave N Suite 5, Plymouth, MN 55446
Website: http://elmarsnypizza.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
ElMar’s NY Pizza
ElMar’s New York Pizza. 15725 37th Avenue North, Plymouth, MN 55446. [email protected]. Hours. Open today. 11:00 am – 08:00 pm. Bagel pop-up hours: Thurs …
ElMar’s NY Pizza (@elmarsnypizza) • Instagram photos and videos
NY Pizza in the Hockey State. NY food without the traffic, filth, or tolls. For menu questions email [email protected]
ElMar’s NY Pizza | Plymouth MN – Facebook
ElMar’s NY Pizza, Plymouth. 4051 likes · 177 talking about this · 699 were here. Authentic New York Pizza – Any questions on ordering email us at…
Reviews
Heavy Metal Grill (Heavy Metal Grill)
You wanted the Best! you got the best! The most authentic New York Style pizza in Minnesota! They even have the machine to adjust the water so it reflects NY water. This place is the real deal!
Trust the Truck
… moreTrust the Truck
Ryan
Phenomenal pizza, great flavors, and they don’t skimp on ingredients. When you buy a slice they throw it in the oven for you to make sure it’s hot and fresh. A but expensive, $6-7 per slice, but worth it. The employees are very friendly and quick.
… moreMike Hnat
I don’t have to travel to NYNY to get pizza anymore, after 16 urs I found it in MN. Nice little place. Outdoor seating in the warmer weather. Will be returning to try other items as well.
… moreKarrisa A
I’ve been craving a New York style pizza but didn’t know where to get one. So glad to stumble upon this place, tucked in a little nook by the Plymouth library! They had a variety of flavors and on the wall, they also have a menu of salads, sandwiches and pasta. I was there for the pizza. I got a pepperoni and ElMar’s Whoopty which had sausage, onion, mushroom and garlic. The pizzas definitely satisfied my craving. One is enough for a meal– I saved the other for lunch. The crust was well-seared and thin enough but had a good structure to hold all the toppings. I thought it tasted pretty good, with quality ingredients.
They have seating available inside and on the patio but I didn’t see anyone using them, although we came in at 3pm.
… moreThey have seating available inside and on the patio but I didn’t see anyone using them, although we came in at 3pm.
Monalisa Wanna
Bagel itself was great. Good size, crispy exterior and chewy on the inside. Not too fond of the breakfast sandwich. Overcooked flattop eggs and frozen patty sausage. I would still drive 40 minutes for the bagel
… moreYasmine Abdelal
Best bagel I’ve ever had. I would genuinely come here every single day if it weren’t for their absolutely wackadoodle online ordering system. I don’t know if the owners were aiming for a Hunger Games vibe, but that’s what it feels like — “may the odds be ever in your favor,” or whatever. There are also a lot of very specific rules about when you can order certain things, which can be confusing at first.
That said… the bagels absolutely slap. Still obsessed. Still recommend to all my friends, just with a heads-up that ordering can feel a little cutthroat. Godspeed
… moreThat said… the bagels absolutely slap. Still obsessed. Still recommend to all my friends, just with a heads-up that ordering can feel a little cutthroat. Godspeed
henry moy
Great atmosphere, the staff there care about how you want your pizza to be. I ordered garbage pizza on their menu and asked for it “well done” and I ate the whole thing including the pizza crust which is rare for me. Great pizza and will go back!
… moreStephanie Davis
Went for the bagel pop up and WOW so delicious. There is a line out front before they open and they do a lot of orders ahead of time so I recommend getting there early. It was SO delicious and great bagels!
… moreJason Christenson
Super delicious pizza. The crust is what makes it – thin and extremely crispy on the bottom but soft on the top. The toppings are high-quality and they don’t skimp on things. You can buy very large pieces of pizza by the slice from a variety of different specialty pizzas or order a pizza. This place is not inexpensive, but it is so superior to Papa John’s or Domino’s. The staff is extremely fast at their job and do a really nice job. They also have an extremely nice Outside patio so if you don’t want to eat inside in there very small room, you can definitely eat outside. Overall, five star experience!
… moreBoris T.N.
Best pizza and in fact they got bagels that are better than 99.9% of nyc bagels. Swear on my life.
… more